We are 100% user-supported!
Without you, there is no RationalWiki!
|Goal: $5000||Donations so far: $4910|
Help and donate today!
On the Eugenics article.
Please summarize the below thread in the editing box. You may use any wikitext in your summary. When you finish, click "Save page".
You keep asking me to debunk things. Why do you always start with the assumption that they are false?
He wants you to remove the bunk.
Because you're a highly-trained performing seal, and your trick is to debunk things for fish. Now, I happen to have a juicy sardine here, and you're gonna have to earn it first :-)
It's true -- I've always subscribed to the adage that you can't debunk something unless it's already full of bunk. However, I'm not a seal. In any sense of the word.
I was observing that Osaka seemed to treat you less like a human being and more like a debunking machine that starts working when you pull a lever—"there's this thing I want you to do, so snap to it."
Oh, sorry for seeing something that seems out of place and asking someone who is knowledgeable about it.
No problem with bringing it to my attention. It just seems like you are expecting the comment to be wrong. I think the post does have a point, though it is largely a semantic argument IMO.