Corporal punishment

From RationalWiki
Jump to: navigation, search
It's not just
a good idea

Law

Icon law.svg
Random enforcement
Were you looking for super crazy fun time?

Corporal punishment is the use of violence, specifically pain, as a form of punishment. Usually this involves striking an offender in some way.

Corporal punishment has been widely used throughout history by many governments, as well as schools, armies, navies, employers and parents. It remains common to many societies, although the laws restricting it differ widely.

Corporal punishment is controversial because in a free, just and modern society, dealing with people through violent means does not square with the notion of inviolable human rights. There is also considerable debate over its effectiveness, and the long-term physical and psychological effects it can have, especially on children.

Contents

[edit] Child disciplinary issues

Notwithstanding the expected exception, most Western democracies have outlawed corporal punishment in schools and 36 countries worldwide have banned it in the home as well.[1] In the UK, where some corporal punishment in the home is still legal, a survey suggested that a majority of parents supported the right to smack their children, although a minority understood the legal situation.[2]

Some parents claimed that smacking a child provided a shock to them that remedied bad behaviour, but this must be balanced with the possible problem that a child grows up to believe that violence is a way to solve disputes. There's no clear consensus on this, and there is obviously a difference between an occasional light smack and beating a child on a regular basis.[3] Proponents have also used the argument that they were hit as a child, yet "turned out fine", a rather fallacious argument. The context in which the punishment takes place is also important, since the parent's punishment may be more influenced by their own emotional state rather than a rational determination of the action necessary to correct the behaviour of a child. It's a bit like allowing a judge to preside over a court case (and act as the jury) in which the defendant is on trial for punching the judge shortly before the trial began. It's difficult to guarantee an impartial appraisal of the case.

[edit] Corporal punishment in American schools

Almost twenty American states allow corporal punishment, and, in the 2005-2006 school year, about a quarter million American children were subjected to corporal punishment. [4] [5]

[edit] See also

[edit] Footnotes

  1. [1]
  2. Times Online:Majority of parents admit to smacking children
  3. The latter is good fun for all the family.
  4. [2] The Center for Effective Discipline
  5. ABC News
Personal tools
Namespaces

Variants
Actions
Navigation
Community
Tools
support