Hawthorne effect

From RationalWiki
Jump to: navigation, search
Tell me about
your mother


Icon psychology.svg
For our next session...
Popping into your mind

The Hawthorne Effect is an observed phenomenon in experimental testing, in which the subject's behavior changes as a result of being observed. It sometimes leads to fallacious conclusions involving magical thinking if it is not carefully accounted for. It is strongly related to the confirmation bias. While it is demonstrably present in the short term, it tends to deteriorate over time as the subject becomes habituated to the presence of the observer.

As an example, if a researcher were to visit a non-technological people living in a remote part of the world, obtain permission to live with them and learn about their style of life, and immediately begin documenting, there is a strong possibility he or she may produce an inaccurate representation. A far better approach would be to first live with the group for some significant length of time in order to allow its members to get used to his or her presence, and only then begin.

One real-world example of the Hawthorne Effect is displayed, possibly, in response to high-stakes educational testing. School systems commonly respond to testing under No Child Left Behind by taking measures that improve schools' performance on standardized tests (e.g. selective retention of students in critical years, limited effort to deter low-performing students from dropping out, reclassification of students as special-needs) without necessarily improving their educational success. (In general terms, it is usually much easier to manipulate — "game," if you prefer — statistics that represent reality than it is to change the underlying reality itself.)

Personal tools