Information icon.svg Please vote in the 2017 board of trustees election. The cabal thanks you for your service.
Bronze-level article

James Hansen

From RationalWiki
Jump to: navigation, search
Hansen in 1988 being right about global warming and getting no credit for it from deniers.
The poetry of reality
Science
Icon science.svg
Extraordinary claims with
extraordinary evidence
Hot from the
giants' shoulders

James E. "Jim" Hansen is an alarmist, warmist shill for the global warming hoax and bankrolled by none other than the nefarious George Soros."[1]

...which is the case if you live in the alternate universe of global warming deniers. In reality, Hansen is an atmospheric physicist, former head of NASA's Goddard Institute for Space Studies (GISS) and an adjunct professor at Columbia University in New York City. He wrote a book on global warming in 2009 called Storms of my Grandchildren.

Science stuff[edit]

Early days[edit]

Hansen spent his early career researching the atmosphere of Venus. This work on Venus inspired him to look at the effects of greenhouse gases on Earth's atmosphere. He coined the term "Venus syndrome" in reference to the runaway global warming on Venus that caused its oceans to evaporate.[2] On Earth, this remains a logical possibility, but still a speculative and very worst-case scenario.[3] It could happen, but only if we burned about ten times the total fossil fuel deposits on Earth in a very short amount of time.[4] The fact that Hansen was wrong on this one entirely theoretical question hasn't prevented bullshit artists from trying to use it to discredit his entire body of work, however.

The models are(n't) broken (or, that 1988 paper)[edit]

Hansen's work during the 1980s demonstrated that global temperatures were rising. His work consisted mainly of reconstructing temperatures from weather station data and building some of the earliest climate models. A 1988 paper of his which was a centerpiece of his testimony to Congress has become a bete noire among deniers.[5] He offered three different scenarios, of which "scenario B" fits the current rate of greenhouse gas emissions the best. While this scenario did overestimate temperatures to a certain degree, it actually provides the best fit for current temperatures and emissions.[6] Magnifying this discrepancy or outright falsifying Hansen's predictions has become a part-time job for many deniers, most notably Patrick Michaels in a 1998 Congressional testimony wherein he simply erased all but the least accurate of the scenarios.[7][8] A host of other deniers including the bullshitters at Climate Fraudit have quote mined or otherwise misrepresented this paper in order to claim that the models are "broken" or "incredibly alarmist."

Further work[edit]

Hansen has done prolific work in climatology and is also known for his work on black carbon.[9] Many of Hansen's predictions are less conservative than those of the IPCC (making him a nutty "alarmist" among deniers, of course), though some of his own earlier predictions have been on the conservative side, so take that for what it's worth.

Controversies (Some of them manufactured)[edit]

Activism[edit]

Hansen being arrested on August 29, 2011

Hansen has become known for his activism on climate change in recent years and for not hiding his massive hate-on for deniers, which is why he has been promoted to the higher echelons of the Evil Liberal Science Conspiracy, probably second only to Michael Mann. In a 2008 statement, he commented that the CEOs bankrolling denialist think tanks should be put on trial for "high crimes against humanity and nature", which caused quite some butthurt.[10] He was also arrested at two protests against strip mining[11][12] and one against the TransCanada pipeline.[13]

Censorship at NASA[edit]

As was the case with many other scientists in the Shrub administration, Hansen was censored at least once from appearing before the media and it was later found that NASA's findings had been downplayed for political purposes. The public relations arm of NASA had prevented him from making public appearances to talk about his work. A 2008 investigation by NASA concluded:

After carefully reviewing the relevant facts and circumstances in this matter, we conclude that officials in the NASA Headquarters Office of Public Affairs did, in fact, manage the release of information concerning climate change in a manner that reduced, marginalized, and mischaracterized the scientific information within the particular media over which that office had control. Further, on at least one occasion, the Headquarters Office of Public Affairs denied media access to a NASA scientist, Dr. Hansen, due, in part, to that office’s concern that Dr. Hansen would not limit his statements to science but would, instead, entertain a policy discussion on the issue of climate change.[14]

Christopher Horner Suits[edit]

In 2011, Christopher Horner, a hack at the Competitive Enterprise Institute and author of The Politically Incorrect GuideTM to Global Warming and Environmentalism, spammed Hansen with Freedom of Information Act requests regarding payment for his lectures and scientific awards (apparently, some of those AAAS awards carry tidy sums in the hundreds of thousands of dollars, no kidding).[15][16] Ironically, deniers like Horner who constantly whine about "academic freedom" saw fit to urge Hansen to "release the data." Except it wasn't data about any substantive scientific issue, but about his scientific awards (and bogus connection to George Soros), which are already listed on his curriculum vitae anyway.[17]

The fictional Soros connection is based on the fact that he accepted pro bono legal advice from the Government Accountability Project,Wikipedia's W.svg which receives grants from Soros' Open Society FoundationWikipedia's W.svg. This was summarily inflated to Soros bankrolling Hansen to the tune of nearly $1 million — definitive proof that global warming is a hoax![18]

Freeman Dyson[edit]

Hansen is also friends with eminent physicist (and unfortunate climate crank) Freeman Dyson, though they do throw insults at each other when it comes to global warming.[19]

New York Times op-ed[edit]

An op-ed by Hansen published on May 9, 2012[20] sparked a minor controversy among some meteorologists and climatologists. Hansen claimed that a semi-permanent drought would develop in the Western and mid-Western United States, leading to Dust Bowl-type conditions, among other things. This prompted a response from Martin Hoerling disputing his claims. A second response by climatologist Kerry Emanuel challenged the claims of both Hansen and Hoerling.[21] Hoerling expanded on his original arguments, while Dan Miller, a venture capitalist and engineer, defended Hansen.[22]

External links[edit]

References[edit]

  1. Is Global Warming Alarmist James Hansen a Shill for George Soros?, NewsBusters (Archived Copy)
  2. James Hansen interview on Climate Tasmania
  3. Clarons Despair, Brave New Climate
  4. http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2013/13/130729-runaway-greenhouse-global-warming-venus-ocean-climate-science/ National Geographic
  5. Hansen et al. (1988) Global Climate Changes as Forecast by GISS Three Dimensional Model. Journal of Geophysical Research vol. 93, D8, pp. 9341-9364.
  6. Hansen's 1988 Projections, Real Climate
  7. Hansen's 1998 prediction was wrong, Skeptical Science
  8. Pat Michaels: Fraud, pure and simple, Deltoid
  9. Dorothy Koch and James Hansen. (2005) Distant origins of Arctic black carbon: A Goddard Institute for Space Studies ModelE experiment. Journal of Geophysical Research Vol. 110.
  10. Put oil firm chiefs on trial, says leading climate change scientist, The Guardian
  11. Hannah, Hansen arrested in mountaintop removal process, West Virginia Public Broadcasting
  12. James Hansen Arrested With 100 Others at Mountaintop Removal Mining Protest in DC, Huffington Post
  13. NASA's Hansen Arrested Outside White House at Pipeline Protest, Bloomberg
  14. Investigative Summary Regarding Allegations that NASA Suppressed Climate Change Science and Denied Media Access to Dr. James E. Hansen, a NASA Scientist, NASA Office of Inspector General, June 2, 2008. (Further commentary at Climate Science Watch)
  15. ATI appeal to Nasa, Climate Science FOI Report
  16. ATI NASA lawsuit, Climate Science FOI Report
  17. Hansen's CV
  18. Investor's Business Daily has as much as 100 lies on every page, Deltoid
  19. The Civil Heretic, New York Times
  20. "Game Over for the Climate", New York Times
  21. Varied Views on Extreme Weather in a Warming Climate, New York Times
  22. More on Extreme Weather and Global Warming, New York Times again