Pithecophobia

From RationalWiki
Jump to: navigation, search
Tell me about
your mother

Psychology

Icon psychology.svg
For our next session...
Popping into your mind

Pithecophobia (from the Greek πίθηκος pithekos, "ape, monkey" as in the genus name Australopithecus; and φόβος, phobos, "fear", as in phobia) is basically the fear of apes, or at least the uncomfortable feelings surrounding the idea of apes and common descent.

Take a wild guess if this phobic aversion has been actively cultivated in the religious mindset.

Contents

[edit] Really?

Pithecophobia was first coined by William K. Gregory in a 1927 issue of Science magazine's letters section, describing it as:[1]

...a new kind of phobia which is now widely prevalent among the American public. ...pithecophobia, or the dread of apes — especially the dread of apes as relatives or ancestors. ...this phobia has become almost pandemic...

The letter is fairly humourous in nature, stating how some sufferers can't mention the word "gorilla" without shuddering, and that they should be inoculated with Darwinian theory (Richard Dawkins would be proud).

Despite the joking nature of the letter (a reference to the early battles for the acceptance of evolution like the Scopes trial) there are some serious messages in the idea that people might be disturbed by the thought of apes, and their close proximity to humans in genetics and appearance.

[edit] The uncanny valley

It has long been remarked that the appearance and behaviour of other primates uncomfortably remind us of ourselves, from the BC 2nd century Latin poet, Ennius: "The ape, vilest of beasts, how like to us."[2] to the 18th century founder of Methodism, John Wesley:[3]

We now come to a numerous tribe, that seem to make approaches even to humanity; that bear an awkward resemblance to the human form, and discover the same faint efforts at intellectual sagacity.

Animals of the MONKEY class are furnished with hands instead of paws; their ears, eyes, eye-lids, lips, and breasts, are like those of mankind; their internal conformation also bears some distant likeness; and the 
whole offers a picture that may mortify the pride of such as make their persons the principal objects of their admiration.

Those with an interest in robotics or artificial intelligence might recognise that this is describing the "uncanny valley" - where people are more disturbed by non-human things that look sort of human than they are by non-human things that are totally human. Consider that no one seems fazed by the brilliantly realistic waxworks of Madame Tussauds, but a Japanese sex-robot with its plastic skin and slowly blinking eyes is pure nightmare fuel (despite the lost souls making up the MGTOW community insisting otherwise[4]).

Pithecophobia may be the best explanation for the unpopularity of evolution — as ever since Darwin, evolution has popularly been identified with the descent of humans from a non-human primate, rather than a scientific process of "descent with modification", or "change in the frequencies of hereditary traits in a population"; and there is no known objective reason for doubting that evolution happens (and always has happened) in all forms of life as we know it.

In fairness, many primates are highly aggressive, possesing sharp teeth,and chimps, gorillas, and orangutans are considerably stronger than humans, being capable of inflicting traumatic injuries, so many zoo keepers, medical researchers and big-game hunters have every right to fear non-human primates, especially non-human simians.

[edit] References

  • K. Christopher Beard, The Hunt for the Dawn Monkey: Unearthing the Origins of Monkeys, Apes, and Humans. Berkeley: University of California Press, 2004, ISBN 0520233697 Chapter 11, "Paleoanthropology and Pithecophobia", especially pages 289-293.

[edit] References

  1. William K. Gregory, "Two Views of the Origin of Man", Science volume 65 number 1695 (June 24, 1927), pages 601-605.
  2. Quoted in Cicero, De Natura Deorum, Book I, Ch. 35. In Latin, there is word play with simia ("ape") and similis ("similar").
  3. John Wesley, A Survey of the Wisdom of God in the Creation; Or A Compendium of Natural Philosophy. New York: Bangs and T. Mason, 1823, Part the Second, Chapter I, volume 1, pages 147-148.
  4. We Hunted the Mammoth, "The MGTOWs were nestled all snug in their beds, while visions of sexbots danced in their heads"
Personal tools
Namespaces

Variants
Actions
Navigation
support
Community
Tools