YKW was fun,, but the funny parts were the ones on horrific works such as FATAL and My Immortal. However, those days ended a while ago with the "be nice to everyone" policy. Especially agree on the points about editors and admins.
Which translates into "never criticize anything ever" in day-to-day operations. Even maintenance stuff, like fixing up the articles, and meta stuff, like trying to limit the amount of in-jokes, is off limits because it might offend someone.
And we all know how the "clam up, you're just a hater" viewpoint works out for websites.
What's YKW? A terrible fanfic site I'm guessing?