Thread:User talk:Reckless Noise Symphony/Philosophy of "RationalWiki"/reply (6)

You still didn't provide context of what you're talking about, which is what I was specifically asking for. Without context of what you're complaining about what was reverted, no one can judge. All you said above was "why did you revert me!!!" and then espoused the glory of facts. That could have referred to anything.

I've since spotted the complaint that I think you're referring to - even in your second posts you provide no context as to what incident you're referring to - and found no posts on the talk page, but a lot of very indignant edit comments. Now, if I guessed correctly, I believe reasons for that revert were given that sufficiently supersede your own reasoning. If it's about whether the Zeitgeist Movement is apolitical, then the fact that it wants to change society and all its own self-aggrandising gumph says puts it in the realm of politics. You may have meant non-partisan, but that's not quite the same thing. Claiming to be apolitical isn't the same as acting in an apolitical manner. I can claim to be blonde, but it doesn't magically dye my hair. I thought someone claiming to be the ultimate authority on rationality would understand that.

Then you went on a personal attack that merely dismisses everyone else "a drunk", which I'm sure you can tell that I'm not because I know what my typing is like under various mental states (this is currently "before coffee" typing, not "6 pints down" typing).

Then you said that this was a personal discussion between you and one user - yet addressed your complaints to the wiki in general, which is composed of multiple users which, therefore, opens the comments up to everyone. Using a user's talk page for discussions like "hey dude, how was your holiday" implies a personal discussion - few people will be even interested - but using a user's talk page, which remains a public forum here, to say "RationalWiki all sucks because beans" invites more people to comment.

Is this clear enough? Did I miss anything? Are there places where I be more condescending?