Debate:Should Brandon Hill Have Been Punished?

My debate is this. Should this lil mofo have been punished?. I think, in my awesurme, spectacular, wonderful, humble opinion, the answer is yes. He broke a rule, plain and simple. I may feel different if my family member was in Iraq (though I would ask why they had been smashed over the head and/or shit-faced drunk enough to sign up), but I think he should've waited. It was against the rules.

What y'all think? -- Gen. S.T. Shrink  *Get to the bunker*  01:28, 14 April 2008 (EDT)
 * Unflinching application of rules causes more pain than good. While there have to be standards, God bless us, that's why there are lawyers!  I say this kid should've been fine, and encouraged to take his time.  What a great example to talk about an important issue, thanks!
 * Poor kid.- 01:37, 14 April 2008 (EDT)
 * Excellent point. You did a helluva lot better at convincing me than Fox News or conservapedia. And, by the by, was there any sarcasm in that last sentence? -- Gen. S.T. Shrink  *Get to the bunker*  01:39, 14 April 2008 (EDT)