Talk:StoneToss

The expanded image captions
I feel it's better when these captions are far shorter comebacks because I don't think GraniteDrop deserves them. 22:45, 24 June 2020 (UTC)
 * Well if you argued that it looks bad (as in, image captions have smaller letters therefore it looks ugly), I would understand. On the other hand, I do think sometimes people only mock reactionaries without giving the reason why they suck. For instance, the trans suicide one being about trans people "are mentally ill" when in fact gender discrimination and societal acceptance, a study about it was linked by me, could help someone argue online. Tl;dr it's not good form for ratwiki to just make fun of stonetoss without debunking his harmful nonsense. 02:57, 25 June 2020 (UTC)

Soy
Best to be factually correct. Soy is a well-researched phytoestrogen because of its high isoflavone content. Second sentence in subheading "Structure". Wiki link
 * -- Goatspeed. 07:10, 7 November 2020 (UTC)

Bitcoin
In bitcoin comic one person rides the bitcoin wave up while the other keeps derriding the first one because bitcoin is a bubble. It got added here because bitcoin bubble burst in 2018, proving the doubter right. Since than bitcoin took off again, is higher priced than it was ever before. Until it bursts again this section is counterproductive to the message the entire article wants to send (one could even say - wrong). &mdash; Unsigned, by: 83.29.147.161 / talk

Possibly excessive amount of comics
It's one thing to be good commentary but it's another thing to be a host of commentary. Maybe it's just me, but the presentation of this page comes off as excessive. I don't like how it looks either. But for starters, I think we can do without the suicide one, that's too abhorrent for this wiki and we already know how transphobic he is from the other visceral diarrhea he substitutes for ink on his drawings. 23:29, 21 September 2021 (UTC)
 * We could possibly rewrite it so that he have a couple sections on his views, how he conveys them, and how his comics spread and then put the comics in a (possibly collapsed) gallery. I think it's important to show even the worst ones so that we can show just how utterly evil this person's views are, for example the Holocaust denial one is also really abhorrent but is needed to show that he is a Nazi. Casually joking about trans suicides goes way beyond ordinary transphobia, and it is important to show that he is not just bigoted but outright hateful. Plutocow (talk) 23:48, 21 September 2021 (UTC)
 * What he shows is indeed vile, repugnant, abominable, abhorrent, disgusting, atrocious, horrific, and every other of the most depraved synonyms, and I don't want to downplay any of that, but I don't want the content surprising and disturbing more vulnerable readers. Probably can use a content warning then. But do you know any comics we should trim out? 03:41, 22 September 2021 (UTC)

A question
Has he ever made a comic about Undertale/Deltarune? I'm asking because I feel like he would do that considering the entire moral of the Games (being respectful to one another, even if they are different from you) doesn't bond well with far-righters, to put it simply. TheOneAndOnlyCirrusMan (talk) 19:14, 26 September 2021 (UTC)
 * UT/DR also have a large number of queer-relationships (The dog marriage scene might be the only hetero thing in the series) and characters that break a lot of gender stereotypes. 04:09, 13 October 2021 (UTC)

Holocaust Denial Section
Do we need to go into so much detail on this? I don't personally see how dumping an infodump into the description of an image keeps the flow of the page looking well. I'm all for stating facts, but is there perhaps a way that it could be shortened?--153.91.207.90 (talk) 20:52, 31 March 2023 (UTC)