Thread:User talk:Blue/reviews/reply (4)

That's rather arbitrary and should have nothing to do with how essays are defined. Half of the essays in essay space are 3rd person. Reviews are comments about a film or book by One person. That's what all the reviews in the section "review" are.

Feredir has written most of the reviews in the review cat, and they are all just his opinion. I think "review" should be something distinct from article or essay. but we need to treat all of them the same, and not just say "oh, it's first person".