Korean Air Lines Flight 007

From RationalWiki
Jump to: navigation, search
Some dare call it

Conspiracy

Icon conspiracy.svg
What THEY don't want
you to know!
Sheeple wakers

On September 1, 1983, Korean Air Lines Flight 007, a Boeing 747-230B flying from New York City to Seoul, South Korea via Anchorage, Alaska. It flew into prohibited Soviet airspace, crossing over the Kamchatka peninsula. It was shot down by a Soviet Sukhoi Su-15 supersonic fighter west of Sakhalin island before crashing near Moneron island in the Sea of Japan. Or was it? Yes.

Because it was carrying a prominent anti-Communist (Larry McDonald) to a meeting in Seoul at a time of mounting tensions in the Cold War, because of disinformation from the communist Soviet government, and because most of the bodies and luggage were never recovered, the incident has become a favourite topic for conspiracy theorists. While many blame Soviet perfidy, the finger is also pointed at the US government, and wilder theories have also implicated giant flesh-eating crabs. And luggage-eating crabs.

Contents

[edit] The facts

The most probable explanation, in those days before non-military GPS, is that the plane accidentally strayed into Soviet airspace due to an error setting the autopilot and was shot down by panicky Soviet air defense forces.[1] The Soviet military was anxious about rising tensions with NATO and the possibility of a sneak strike by the USA, and embarrassed by its failures to stop American spy planes overflying the Russian far east. It was difficult for a short-range supersonic interceptor, such as the Su-15, to follow and identify a much slower-moving commercial jet. Even a reported attempt to fire warning shots[2] would probably not have been noticed by the Boeing's pilots, due to armor-piercing bullets being small and dark. Transcripts of communications within the Soviet Far East District Air Defense Forces point to an eagerness to shoot down anything vaguely suspicious.

The disappearance of the bodies and luggage are more mysterious. No bodies were found on the surface of the sea, and none of the plane's hold baggage was recovered, just a few clothes and personal items from the cabin. Divers found wreckage along with some of one human torso and a few other human body parts, all of which may have been from the same individual. It is possible that the Soviets removed corpses and luggage from the crash site, as part of the disinformation and cover-up that involved an initial denial of the shooting and hiding the black boxes for several years. It is also possible that the bodies were sucked or blown out of the plane while still in flight, stripped of their clothes by the force, scattered far from the wreckage, and never found. Other explanations are more far-fetched.

[edit] Communist perfidy?

Part of the Soviet salvage operation of KAL 007 on August 30, 1983

One of the passengers was Representative Larry McDonald, a conservative Democrat from Georgia's 7th District, and the second highest figure in the John Birch Society, a rabidly anti-communist organisation, and therefore not popular in the rabidly communist USSR. McDonald was travelling to Seoul officially for a commemoration of 30 years of the US-South Korea Mutual Defense Treaty, and a number of other American politicians made the same journey on a slightly later flight, KAL 015. It is rumored that they would also be attending secret meetings on Cold War topics while in Seoul. Less credible sources say Richard Nixon was originally booked on KAL 007 before being warned to change flights. Did the Russians deliberately shoot down a civilian jet because of who was on board?

Such theories require that the Soviet authorities had some method of diverting the flight. They may have been able to use fake navigation beacons, although there is no evidence of this. Such theories also require believing that at a time of high international tension the Russians felt it was worthwhile bringing down a plane and risking nuclear war just to kill an eccentric Southerner, whose rabid anti-communism probably made most reasonable people more sympathetic to Russia.

Kal 007 flight data after missile detonation

Black box data shows the plane survived for a few minutes after the missile impact, though it was severely damaged and could not have gone far. As with Malaysia Airlines Flight 370, some of the wilder theories hold that the plane may have landed safely in a secret location: Russians may have captured the plane and its passengers and imprisoned them in secret labor camps. Although such a theory was initially popular with relatives for offering some hope that their loved ones were still alive, none of the passengers have ever re-emerged, and nor has any evidence of their imprisonment, or their luggage.

It is however more credible that the Russians misdirected rescue efforts, and they may well have tampered with the wreckage. They seem to have recovered the voice and data recorders quickly but kept them secret, to have interfered with American salvage efforts, and to have misled others about the location of the crash. That the Russians deliberately removed the wreckage, the passengers' bodies, or luggage, and/or replaced them in different locations, is possible but unproven. That there were no passengers on board is much less likely, as their relatives will attest.

[edit] American perfidy?

Was the plane on a spying mission? (Hey, check out the flight numberWikipedia's W.svg!) Did the USA deliberately and secretly redirect the jet into Soviet airspace to test their air defenses or even to provoke World War III? Did the American government really hate Larry McDonald that much? And why did Washington halt the investigation by the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) and instead hand responsibility to the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO), which had little experience in investigating air crashes and no powers to subpoena evidence?

Theories of American involvement divide on the question of whether the Korean pilots knew what was happening or were unconscious dupes. When the cockpit voice recorders were finally recovered, they showed that the crew were unaware of any abnormality and were joking, discussing the important topic of airport bureau de change exchange rates, and generally not behaving as if hopelessly lost or risking their lives on a top secret mission. This certainly makes it unlikely that they were deliberately guiding the plane into Soviet airspace; it does not rule out them being unwitting victims of American tampering, but equally there is no evidence of this.

While conspiracy theorists condemn the ICAO's involvement, it had previously investigated Israel's 1973 shooting down of a Libyan passenger jet, Libyan Arab Airlines Flight 114, so it was either master of the politically-motivated cover-up, or had some expertise in similar events.

[edit] Giant crabs?

A man holding a large Japanese spider crab (Macrocheira kaempferi)

The disappearance of the bodies is one of the stranger and harder-to-explain aspects of the crash (unless South Park was on to something with its crab people). The Pacific Ocean is known for its large size and Siberia is also big and sparsely populated, but divers found wreckage from the plane, the US search was very intensive, and it would be expected that something would wash up sooner or later. Russian writer Andrey Illesh suggested the bodies were eaten by giant crabs found in the seas off Sakhalin. However crabs are not known for eating suitcases, or even human bones. And the mere mention of giant crabs instantly raises a giant flashing sign saying DISINFORMATION.

[edit] Conspiracy theorists

There have been many books, articles, tv programs, and at least 2 feature films about the incident.

  • David Pearson in KAL 007: the Cover-up (1987) suggests the plane was intentionally flown over the USSR by the Korean pilots.
  • Andrey Illesh in "The Mystery of Korean Boeing 747" in Izvestia (1992) blames giant crabs.
  • Robert W Allardyce and James Gollin in Desired Track: The Tragic Flight of KAL Flight 007 (1994) also suggest it was a deliberate spy mission.
  • Michel Brun in Incident at Sakhalin: The True Mission of KAL Flight 007 (1995) claims the plane strayed into a pitched battle between American and Soviet ships and planes, and may have been accidentally hit by an American missile.
  • Gennadi Osipovich, the Soviet pilot who shot the 747 down, has insisted in interviews that the flight was a spy-plane with no civilians on board.[3]

[edit] Not to blame

Nobody seems to hold everybody's favorite sharp-dressed villains North Korea to be in any way responsible.

[edit] See also

[edit] External links

[edit] References

  1. "Korean Air Lines Flight 007: Lessons From the Past and Insights for the Future". Asaf Degani. NASA Ames Research Center.
  2. A NEW U.S. TRANSCRIPT INDICATES SOVIET PILOT FIRED 'CANNON BURSTS', Bernard Gwertzman, New York Times, September 12, 1983
  3. "Ex-Soviet Pilot Still Insists KAL 007 Was Spying", Michael R. Gordon, New York Times, December 9, 1996
Personal tools
Namespaces

Variants
Actions
Navigation
support
Community
Tools