Kurt Cobain murder conspiracy theories

From RationalWiki
Jump to: navigation, search
Nirvana in 1992 (Cobain in front)
Some dare call it

Conspiracy

Icon conspiracy.svg
What THEY don't want
you to know!
Sheeple wakers
Load up on guns

Bring your friends

It's fun to lose and to pretend
—"Smells like Teen Spirit", Nirvana

Kurt Cobain was lead singer, guitarist, and songwriter for grunge rock band Nirvana. Officially he shot himself dead on April 5, 1994. However, a minority of people believe he was murdered, possibly by his widow Courtney Love. Most of these claims can be traced back to private investigator Tom Grant, who has been involved in the case since shortly after Cobain's death. Rumors were given new life in 1997 when shock-rocker Eldon "El Duce" Hoke took time out from promoting his brand of "rape rock" to claim he knew who was the murderer, and then fell asleep drunk on a train line with fatal results.[1] Meanwhile, Love has come out with her own crazy theories. Almost everybody, including the police and Cobain's bandmates, accept the official verdict, though some of his friends and family have expressed doubts.[2]

Contents

[edit] Brief life

Cobain was born on February 20, 1967 in Aberdeen, Washington and formed Nirvana in 1987. The band was highly influential in 1990s rock music, and Cobain was a role model to and personification of the "slacker" generation or Generation X, those who were young adults in the early 1990s, and an iconic figure for young people in the decades that followed.[3][4]

By 1991, Cobain was abusing alcohol and drugs and was suffering from mysterious stomach pains which he attempted to self-medicate.[3] He is also reported to have been suffering from clinical depression and bipolar disorder.[2] As Nirvana became more successful, he became increasingly uneasy with his media-appointed role as the spokesman for a generation.[3] On April 8, 1994, after several days of being missing from a rehab facility, he was found dead from a gunshot wound in Seattle, leaving his wife, rock musician Courtney Love, and daughter Frances Bean Cobain; he was just 27 years old.[3]

[edit] Death

Kurt's body was found in a greenhouse at his home at 171 Lake Washington Boulevard East, Seattle, Washington, USA, on April 8, 1994 by an electrical contractor.[2] Forensics showed that he had died on April 5 from a shotgun wound, which was initially reported in the press as directly to the head, but later was described in various Cobain biographies as being through the mouth, after taking a large amount of drugs including heroin.[2] A suicide note and pen were found near his body.[2] The gun used had been purchased for Cobain by his friend Dylan Carlson, a member of rock group Earth.[2]

[edit] Official theory

His death is generally believed to have been the result of suicide[5], which might be explained by his health problems, addictions, and unhappiness with the band's fame. The evidence for suicide includes: Cobain's mental health; the suicide note; the nature of his wounds; his collection of guns.

This is the opinion of the Seattle Police Department.[4] The idea that Cobain committed suicide is also accepted by his two Nirvana bandmates Krist Novoselic and Dave Grohl, by his (and Love's) friend the journalist Everett True, and Cobain's father Donald.[2]

It is almost impossible to prove that nobody else killed Cobain, if you start claiming the suicide note was faked, Cobain was drugged, and the crime scene manipulated. But equally, without a clear motive or any evidence of murder, the balance of probabilities clearly points to suicide.

[edit] Conspiracy theory

The general theory advanced by Tom Grant and others appears to be that Love found out that Cobain was planning to divorce her, cut her from his will, and leave her; and as a result she allegedly hired a hitman who rendered him comatose with an injection of heroin and then shot him dead, possibly for his money or to prevent him leaving.[6][7] It is suggested that Seattle police then collaborated to cover up the true murderer.[8]

Claims that Love did it for money are common, and there is evidence that Cobain described her as obsessed with money, possibly as a joke.[9] There is however no evidence that she was short of money, and her band Hole were growing in popularity at the time: a week after Cobain's death their album Live Through This, recorded in October 1993 and taking a more commercial and tuneful direction than their earlier material, was released to excellent reviews.[10] Alternative motives might be love or revenge, but Love's enemies assume she was cold and calculating.[11]

Many fans of Cobain are extremely hostile towards Love, which has doubtless sustained their campaign to prove she killed him. It is not unusual for obsessive fans of a musician to be jealous of or hostile to their idol's partner; fans' hatred of Love is compared to the negative reaction that Yoko Ono has faced ever since she began her relationship with John Lennon.[7] Cobain's ex-girlfriend Mary Lou Lord has accused Love of being a "sociopath" and a fake; of failing to use her fame for humanitarian purposes; and of spreading lies about Lord including that Lord killed Love's cat.[11] Love's capacity for murder is demonstrated by evidence such as her reported heroin use while pregnant.[12]

It's obvious that Love did not fulfil expectations of the dutiful rock wife before Cobain's death or grieving widow afterwards. Even before Cobain's death, Love was controversial for her sexualised style of dressing and her "post-feminist" stance[13], and to this was added accusations that she had slept her way to the top through a succession of rock stars, and claims that Cobain had secretly written her best songs.[14] With Live Through This released just after his death, she went on tour to promote it rather than staying at home and grieving.[15] This was followed by a series of relationships with famous men (and possibly women)[16]; work in music and acting; reckless drug abuse[17]; trouble with the law[17]; lawsuits over Cobain's estate and unreleased Nirvana tracks[18][19]; and custody battles with Cobain's family over their child.[7] But none of this is evidence of murder.

[edit] Theorists

[edit] Richard Lee

Lee was a Seattle public access TV presenter who produced a series called Kurt Cobain was murdered in 1994.[2] He was still pushing conspiracy theories in 2016.[4]

[edit] Tom Grant

Private investigator Tom Grant was hired by Courtney Love to find Cobain after he went missing from a rehab facility, and then to investigate Cobain's death. He came to believe that Cobain was murdered by Love, based on factors including heroin levels in Cobain's blood; handwriting evidence that purportedly showed Love had added to the bottom of Cobain's letter references to suicide; Love's claims about Cobain's earlier suicide attempt; Carroll's information about Cobain's plans to change his will; and other circumstantial details.[2][6]

[edit] Nick Broomfield

Broomfield in 2005

British documentarist Nick Broomfield made a 1998 film Kurt & Courtney, which set out to investigate whether Courtney murdered Kurt. Despite including the testimony of Eldon "El Duce" Hoke, who claimed Love had Cobain killed, the film did not find clear evidence of murder. Broomfield concluded that it was probably suicide, but Broomfield was critical of people around Cobain for failing to support him, and particularly of Love for the way she behaved after the death, including her control over Cobain's legacy and her refusal to licence any of Nirvana's music to Broomfield.[2][20][21]

[edit] Eldon "El Duce" Hoke

El Duce

Broomfield recorded an interview with Eldon "El Duce" Hoke of the band The Mentors, who claimed that Courtney Love offered him $50,000 to kill Cobain. El Duce died a few days after the interview on April 19, 1997 when he was hit by a train while drunk, ruled "misadventure".[2][22] This naturally looks very suspicious to conspiracy theorists, despite El Duce's history of alcohol abuse, misogyny, and numerous attempts to be as outrageous as possible.[1] Hoke implicated someone called Allen,[22] identified by some fans as Allen Wrench of the band Road Whore,[23] although there is absolutely no evidence for this and Hoke is perhaps the least trustworthy witness imaginable.

[edit] Hank Harrison

Love's estranged father is reported as saying, "No doubt she was capable. I can’t prove she pulled the trigger, but I can prove her involvement to a high degree of certainty."[9]

[edit] Ian Halperin and Max Wallace

They wrote 2 books, Who Killed Kurt Cobain? (1999) and Love and Death: The Murder of Kurt Cobain (2004), the latter with Grant's help.[2]

[edit] Soaked in Bleach

A 2015 docu-drama directed by Benjamin Statler and again made with the help of Tom Grant.[24]

[edit] Gus van Sant's Last Days

This 2005 movie is a fictionalised imagining of the last few days in the life of a fictional rock musician called Blake who somewhat resembles Kurt Cobain, made by a director closely linked to the same Pacific northwest area. It is not a documentary or a biopic.[25]

[edit] Other doubters

Other people have expressed skepticism about Kurt killing himself, particularly in such a violent way. This includes Kim Gordon and Thurston Moore of Sonic Youth, who were friends of Cobain; and Cobain's grandfather, Leland Cobain.[2] These doubts might be a common reaction in cases of suicide, and it is not clear when someone is quoted whether their words represent a settled belief.

[edit] Evidence against the official theory

People who believe Cobain was murdered point to a number of inconsistencies in the official account.

[edit] Heroin levels

Cobain had taken heroin shortly before killing himself: drug paraphernalia was found next to his body.[8] Post-mortem tests found a very high level of the drug in his body, 1.52 mg per liter of blood.[2] It is hypothesised that this would be so much that Cobain would be unable to hold the gun and pull the trigger.[6] However other experts say this would depend on how habituated Cobain was to heroin; and he had been using it for a few years.[2]

[edit] The gun

Cobain killed himself with a long-barrelled shotgun, which it is suggested would be hard to use to shoot oneself in the head. However the police seemed to accept this was possible. For comparison, Ernest Hemingway killed himself with a long-barrelled pigeon gun.[26] Seattle police reportedly released photos showing a police officer posing with the gun in various positions.[8] It was also later determined that the entry wound was through the mouth, very easy to do with a shotgun and using one's thumb or forefinger.

[edit] Lost or missing evidence

There were theories that the gun had been melted down as part of a conspiracy, but police released a series of photographs in 2016.[8] This misapprehension may have arisen because Love declared an intention to have Cobain's other guns melted down, while the suicide weapon remained with police.[8] There were also a number of rolls of film taken by the police which were not released until long after the death; and a note by Cobain was not released until 2014; this drip-drip-drip of information fueled conspiracy theories.[8] Tom Grant claimed that Seattle police either botched the investigation or deliberately lied to cover up the true culprit.[8]

[edit] Suicide note(s)

It has been asserted either that Cobain did not write the note, or that the note did not refer to suicide but to Cobain's plans to leave Courtney Love, or that Cobain only wrote a part of the note and somebody added to the end references to suicide.[2] The last four lines are written much less neatly, which could mean they were added by Love (although it would be a terrible forgery) or could have been written after he took some of the drugs just prior to his suicide.[2]

Tom Grant, a leading proponent of murder theories, claims to have found a "handwriting practice sheet" from Love's handbag which shows Love had been practicing faking Cobain's handwriting.[27]

A second note was released by police in 2014: sometimes incorrectly described as a suicide note, it contains criticisms by Cobain of Love: he calls her a bitch and complains about her being obsessed with money. There is no indication of when the note was written. Even the Daily Mail, always keen to bash Love, conceded it could be taken more than one way: "Was the note written in anger by a resentful Cobain, desperate to escape his unhappy marriage? Or was it a play on words penned with the knowledge of Love, that the musician carried around to remind him of their unconventional bond?"[9]

[edit] Claims that Courtney Love lied about an earlier suicide attempt

Cobain took an overdose of painkillers in March 1994 and was hospitalized in Rome, Italy. At the time Love said that Cobain had attempted suicide, while a doctor who treated him reportedly said that it did not look like suicide. This could be seen as an attempt by Love to promote the idea that Cobain was suicidal.[2] However, it is only circumstantial evidence at best, and if you believe Love planned to kill Cobain because he announced he was leaving her (the most plausible motive), you would have to construct a timeline that includes Love finding out about his plans well in advance, dropping hints of suicide, then waiting a month before killing him.

[edit] Cobain's will

PI Tom Grant claimed that Cobain's lawyer Rosemary Carroll told him that Cobain was planning to change his will to exclude Love, as part of plans to leave and divorce her. This could be a motive for Love to murder him. However, Carroll has since refused to comment, so it is hard to know what weight to attach to this.[2]

[edit] Other evidence

There is a variety of other circumstantial evidence that is contested by various people, which does not prove murder but may cast doubt on official accounts.

  1. Could the door of the outbuilding where Cobain was found be locked from the outside, or must Cobain have locked it from the inside?
  2. The absence of fingerprints from the gun, suicide note or pen: they could have been washed or rubbed off in the moist environment.
  3. Claims one of Cobain's credit cards was allegedly used between his death and the discovery of his body.[6] This might suggest robbery and murder.
  4. Love (or anyone else) has never sued anybody for claiming Cobain was murdered.[6]
  5. Why did Cobain get the gun? Grant claims he was scared for his life[6], although the evidence for this is not strong. But Cobain also had a number of other guns in his home[8] and it would not be unusual for a young man from a small town in Washington state to have an interest in guns.

[edit] Even crazier stuff

[edit] The CIA did it!

Love reportedly told Hollywood Inquirer in 2016 that Kurt Cobain was killed by the CIA because of his anti-establishment political views. She claimed that for years she believed government surveillance had harried Cobain to suicide, but she had recently received CIA files proving murder.[28]

[edit] See also

  • Tupac Shakur, the other '90s music legend whose violent end spawned a cottage industry of conspiracy theories.

[edit] References

  1. 1.0 1.1 Death By Misadventure: El Duce, Dirt City Chronicles, April 2012
  2. 2.00 2.01 2.02 2.03 2.04 2.05 2.06 2.07 2.08 2.09 2.10 2.11 2.12 2.13 2.14 2.15 2.16 2.17 2.18 See the Wikipedia article on Suicide of Kurt Cobain.
  3. 3.0 3.1 3.2 3.3 Obituary: Kurt Cobain, The Independent, 10 April 1994
  4. 4.0 4.1 4.2 The “Kurt Cobain was murdered” brigade is back: Photos of his suicide gun reignite conspiracy theories, Mary Elizabeth Williams, Salon, 18 March 2016
  5. Kurt Cobain, Adam Sweeting, Guardian, 9 April 1994
  6. 6.0 6.1 6.2 6.3 6.4 6.5 Case Outline, Tom Grant, The Kurt Cobain Murder Investigation
  7. 7.0 7.1 7.2 Love Me Do: Courtney Love talks to Laura Barton, Laura Barton, The Guardian, 11 Dec 2006
  8. 8.0 8.1 8.2 8.3 8.4 8.5 8.6 8.7 Kurt Cobain case: New photos show suicide gun, police say, CBS, Mar 17, 2016
  9. 9.0 9.1 9.2 Courtney Love's father claims he can prove SHE was responsible for Kurt Cobain's death, Daily Mail, 1 2014
  10. See the Wikipedia article on Live Through This.
  11. 11.0 11.1 Kurt Cobain's Ex Girlfriend Goes After Courtney Love, Graham Hartmann, Loudwire, February 4, 2016
  12. Courtney Love admits she took heroin while pregnant with Francis Bean Cobain, Independent, Jan 29, 2015
  13. Strange Love: The Story of Kurt Cobain and Courtney Love, Lynn Hirschberg, Vanity Fair, Sep 1992 (reprinted Mar 2016)
  14. You Will Ache Like I Ache: The Oral History of Hole's 'Live Through This', Spin, April 2014
  15. From Despair To Here, The Quietus, April 16, 2014
  16. Kate Moss Courtney's Lover?, Sydney Morning Herald, May 21, 2010
  17. 17.0 17.1 See the Wikipedia article on Courtney Love.
  18. Courtney Love Looks to Sue Ex-Attorney Over Bizarre Kurt Cobain Estate Fraud Claims, Hollywood Reporter, Sep 17, 2013
  19. Courtney Love and Nirvana in Lawsuit, ABC
  20. See the Wikipedia article on Kurt & Courtney.
  21. Courtney Love and the film that can't be shown, Independent, Jan 18, 1998
  22. 22.0 22.1 See the Wikipedia article on Eldon Hoke.
  23. Untitled, anonymous poster, kurt4ever.zzn.com and vblah.tripod.com
  24. Soaked in Bleach, IMDb
  25. Last Days (2005), IMDb
  26. Hemingway's Suicide Gun, Garden and Gun
  27. Was Kurt Cobain murdered?, Daily Mail, 13 October 2015
  28. “Kurt Cobain was killed by the CIA" says ex-wife Courtney Love, World News Daily Report, Nov 29, 2016
Personal tools
Namespaces

Variants
Actions
Navigation
support
Community
Tools