Forum:RationalWiki Atheism FAQ for the Newly Deconverted

< Index | RW Article discussion

I find out that CreationWiki has a response to the article RationalWiki Atheism FAQ for the Newly Deconverted here. But it is important to note that our article was edited as time passed. For example, the second section that once mentioned Argument from Authority now doesn't mention it anymore. Contrary to their claim against us, Argument from Authority is a valid argument if the authority is an expert (biologist) in the field (evolutionary biology). It is invalid only when the authority is popularity or non-expert (engineer and designer). However, theology on the other hand presupposes that god exists then make an invalid form of argument from authority known as Courtier's Reply.

Their response doesn't cover every sections of our article though.