It's rare that reading the Chicken Coop makes me do anything but bang my head against my desk
Anything before Tom Baker's Doctor is physically painful to watch. Rarely do shows get better with age, but Doctor Who (not "Dr Who") has accomplished just that. New Who is just as good if not better than late-70's Who (80's Who has its moments, but isn't great on the whole).
I haven't seen all New Who (series 1, 2, 5, 6) and no Old Who (or do we say classic?) at all, but Moffat makes me go "Fuck Yeah!!!" every few episodes which is pretty much what I want out of Science-Fiction show. Torchwood on the other hand makes me sick, actually physically sick. For my own health I have given up on it.
Really? I like Torchwood. It's really compelling. Makes you wonder.
Star Trek, Red Dwarf, Babylon 5. That's it, tried SGU and Dr. Who, stopped the former after 7 episodes, watched the three of the latter the library had. Radar Men from the Moon, Undersea Kingdom and Lost in Space were good for riffing, but that's all.
If I had to answer, it's everything about the show: characters, cinematography, villains, style, way the people talk. Well, the intro was ok. But to be fair I only have seen two and half episodes. The pilot, the last episode of series 2 and the the first half hour of … whatever that third season was called. I have no problem with other people being fans, but I don't want to see it anymore...