Essay:Oxyaena's Take on Best and Worst US Presidents

From RationalWiki
Jump to: navigation, search
Essay.svg This essay is an original work by Oxyaena.
It does not necessarily reflect the views expressed in RationalWiki's Mission Statement, but we welcome discussion of a broad range of ideas.
Unless otherwise stated, this is original content, released under CC-BY-SA 3.0 or any later version. See RationalWiki:Copyrights.
Feel free to make comments on the talk page, which will probably be far more interesting, and might reflect a broader range of RationalWiki editors' thoughts.

Here is Oxyaena's take on the best and the worst US Presidents of history, in order of appearance of course.

George Washington[edit]

George Washington was actually a pretty decent POTUS, granted he had his bad sides like repeatedly fucking over the Native Americans of the Northwest Territories, but he was human after all. Probably the highlight of his administration was his Farewell Address, wherein he warned Americans of partisanship and of foreign interventionism. He also refused to run indefinitely, and instead established the tradition of term limits, which only had to be codified into the US Constitution due to FDR's antics. Other highlights of his Presidency include pardoning all the participants of the Whiskey RebellionWikipedia's W.svg. He also freed all of his slaves after his death, which is more than can be said for most.

John Adams[edit]

Well, he was an abolitionist, and he limited American involvement in the slave trade, but he also picked a stupid fightWikipedia's W.svg with France over petty fucking bullshit and instated the Alien and Sedition ActsWikipedia's W.svg. In short, mediocre president.

Thomas Jefferson[edit]

Thomas Jefferson was a mixed bag, he did outlaw the slave trade in the US and bought the Louisiana Territory from Napoleon, but he also instated the first policies that would eventually lead to the ethnic cleansing of Native Americans under Andrew Jackson so meh, I guess. Oh yeah, he also kicked the Barbary PiratesWikipedia's W.svg' collective asses and put a stop to their pirating ways. He also owned slaves, and unlike Washington, refused to let them go free after they died. Fuck him.

James Madison[edit]

Kickstarted a war that accomplished nothing except to further fuck over the Native Americans, so boo.

James Monroe[edit]

Little remembered president, but he did some noteworthy things, the Monroe Doctrine probably being the highlight of his career as POTUS. On the other hand, he did support the American Colonization Society, whose role was to ship off newly freed slaves to places like Liberia. So mixed as usual.

John Quincy Adams[edit]

Won the Presidency due to a fuck up with the Electoral College, otherwise was a pretty unremarkable president.

Andrew Jackson[edit]

Whoo boy, where to begin. Andrew Jackson was essentially the 19th century version of Trump, complete with populist underpinnings. Some good things he did were to expand suffrage to universal white male suffrage, so that's progress I guess, previously you had to be a property owner in order to be able to vote. He also fist fucked South Carolina over the Nullification CrisisWikipedia's W.svg, which prevented the American Civil War by another three decades. On the other hand there's the aforementioned ethnic cleansing bit with the Native Americans, so fuck him. Another positive is that he refused to annex Texas, knowing that'd start a war with Mexico, an example his successor Polk should have probably followed. Generally an all around jackass of a president, but he does have his stopped clock moments. He also brought the hammer down hard on political corruption here in the US.

Martinan Buren[edit]

General idiot. So incompetent that his opponents called him "Martin Van Ruin."

Bill Harrison[edit]

Notable for dying a month into office. Fuck him for defeating TecumsehWikipedia's W.svg at the Battle of TippecanoeWikipedia's W.svg.

John Tyler[edit]

Treasonous scumbag who joined the Confederate House of Representatives during the Civil War. Nothing else needs to be said.

James K. Polk[edit]

The good thing about him was that he peacefully settled the Oregon dispute with Great Britain, the end result being Britain (and therefore Canada) got British Columbia, and the US got Oregon. He refused to run a second term since everything he wanted to accomplish he did in his first term. He also basically started a war of conquest using the dispute over the annexation of Texas as a bullshit pretense against Mexico, not so coincidentally a bunch of Californians had just revolted and declared California an independent republic, the so called "Bear Flag RevoltWikipedia's W.svg", so make of it what you will.

Zachary Taylor[edit]


Millard Fillmore[edit]

A president so hilariously incompetent he demolished his own party, enabling the rise of the so-called Radical RepublicansWikipedia's W.svg. He forced Japan to open itself to foreign markets, causing a decade or three of chaos and the end of the long period of peace that the Tokugawa shogunate oversaw. He managed to win only one state in his reelection bid, should show you how popular he was.

Franklin Pierce[edit]

Utter dumbass who thought it was a good idea to let the citizens of Kansas to duke it out over whether or not Kansas would be a free or slave state. The whole shenanigan is known as "Bleeding KansasWikipedia's W.svg", and can essentially be seen as a foreshadowing of things to come.

James Buchanan[edit]

Another shitty president in a long list of them leading up to the Civil War. Endorsed the horrible and atrocious SCOTUS case Dred Scott v. Sandford (1857) and his handling of the secession crisis that would lead to the Civil War was so mindbogglingly incompetent that he himself refused to run for reelection, knowing he was a shit president.

Abraham Lincoln[edit]

Lincoln was one of the greatest, if not the greatest, President of all time. He personally abolished slavery here in the US and saved the Union, in fact he also ordered the Union Army to help protect escaped slaves, and his finest moment was either delivering the Gettysburg AddressWikipedia's W.svg or ramming the Thirteenth Amendment through Congress' throat, abolishing slavery entirely. However, there was that little incident in Maryland involving the suspension of habeus corpus, but my take is that he was perfectly justified to do so given that the whole nation was literally tearing itself apart. He also defused a potential war with the UK, preserving trans-Atlantic peace and preventing the European powers from intervening on the side of the Confederacy.

Andrew Johnson[edit]

Weak willed salamander who bent over backwards for Southern interests, essentially gutting Reconstruction. He's notable for surviving impeachment by only one vote.

Ulysses S. Grant[edit]

Ulysses S Grant was another mixed bag, he was an overall okay president but his reputation has been tarnished by Southern racists. Some positive things include him telling France to get the fuck out of Mexico, and coming down hard on the South during Reconstruction. The bad things are he oversaw one of the most corrupt presidential administrations in history and allowed for the Great Sioux Nation to be illegally overrun by gold prospectors and rabid, genocidal warmongers.

Rutherford B. Hayes[edit]

Another incompetent shitbag, ended Reconstruction. Move along, people, nothing to see here.

James Garfield[edit]

Well he helped lessen corruption in the US, and he shares a name with Garfield the cat. He's probably "most remembered for being shot," as the Head Chef so bluntly put it.

Chester A. Arthur[edit]

Signed the Pendleton Civil Service Act, essentially ending the Spoils systemWikipedia's W.svg pioneered by Jackson, but he also signed the "Chinese Exclusion Act" essentially legalizing discrimination against Chinese immigrants. So basically another run of the mill 19th century president,

Grover Cleveland[edit]

Run of the mill Gilded Age president, sent the National Guard in to violently crush some random railroad strikeWikipedia's W.svg.

William McKinley[edit]

Imperialist scum, started the Spanish-American WarWikipedia's W.svg because the US was now apparently having delusions of imperial grandeur, and violently crushed an insurgency in the Philippines. Best part of his Presidency was probably him getting shot.

Theodore Roosevelt[edit]

Yes it's the trust busting, cougar wrestling bull moose himself, Teddy Roosevelt, the most badass president to have ever lived. Strong contender for one of the greatest too. He helped broker peace between Russia and Japan after the disastrous (for the Russians) Russo-Japanese War of 1904-1905, tremendously helped the conservation movement by ensuring millions of acres of land would become public and receive the protection of the US Government. His finest moment? Getting shot in the chest while giving a speech, but only Teddy Roosevelt could honestly go on to continue the speech for another hour before getting the wound checked. Bad. Ass. He also lifted restrictions on Japanese immigration to the States and passed the Pure Food and Drugs Act and the Meat Inspection Act. On the other hand he did violently crush the Philippine Insurgency after the US Conquest of the Philippines, and he also fucked over Colombia by helping Panama gain independence so he could construct the Panama CanalWikipedia's W.svg.

William H. Taft[edit]

Taft was a good Supreme Court justice, but a lousy President.

Woodrow Wilson[edit]

Oh god we have another Andrew Jackson here. Oh boy, where to begin. First let's get the good things out of the way, Wilson created a proto-UN, which failed horribly because of American isolationist tendencies. He also introduced a progressive income tax and it was during his administration the 19th Amendment granting women the right to vote was passed. Now that's out of the way, we can focus on the ugly. Wilson was a huge racist, even by the standards of that day and age, it's said that when Birth of a Nation was screened at the White House Wilson remarked that "it is so terrible, only because it's so true." Wilson segregated the federal government, oversaw the nation's first Red Scare, jailed thousands of political dissidents, initiated the greatest attack on free speech this nation has ever known, and jailed Eugene V. Debs, in other words, he was completely shit. His administration also oversaw the 18th Amendment which outlawed alcohol, thereby leading to the Prohibition era, which saw the rise of the "classic" mob bosses such as Al CaponeWikipedia's W.svg and Lucky LucianoWikipedia's W.svg, so more incompetence on his record. Great.

Calvin Coolidge[edit]

Really not much to be said for him, although he gets points for releasing Wilson's political prisoners. Next!

Herbert Hoover[edit]

Oh boy, almost nothing good can be said about this man as a president. He was a hard-line laissez-faire free market kind of guy, which unfortunately didn't do much to help stop the Great Depression, and in fact only made it worse. He was a great humanitarian though, bottom line is he was a terrible president but a good person, so meh.


DRUM ROLE, PLEASE!!! This man here was the greatest POTUS of all time! He singlehandedly reversed the Great Depression with his New Deal, helped restore American Indian tribal sovereignty, whooped Imperial Japan's and Nazi Germany's ass, introduced the social security program in these here United States, built the Hoover Dam, created the Tennessee Valley AuthorityWikipedia's W.svg and more. The only true blemish on his record was the internment of Japanese Americans, which while a tragedy must be held in context to the times and also with how much good this man has done. Also bonus points for being Teddy's cousin. However he had an authoritarian streak as well, such as his attempted court-packing to get his agenda through and the excessive term limits, but there's no denying the good he has done overall for this country.

Harry Truman[edit]

Truman is kind of a complicated case to me, on one hand he committed the atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, on the other he desegregated the military, he also enacted the lead up to the Cold War by being unnecessarily confrontational with Stalin, so I guess he's more bad than good? He also instituted TerminationWikipedia's W.svg, which was a disaster for Native Americans, so he was definitely a bastard.

Ike Eisenhower[edit]

Eisenhower was probably one of the greater presidents of the 20th century, he oversaw the war effort in Europe for one, so that's a starting point, he also handed PattonWikipedia's W.svg his ass whenever the "cowboy general" got out of hand, so that's another. On the domestic front he oversaw the creation of the federal interstate highway system, which was revolutionary for its day, he sent the National Guard out to kick some racist ass in Little Rock, his administration had the highest tax rates on the wealthy in American history, wealth inequality was much less of a problem then than it is now, among other things, but he also continued Termination and he deported hundreds of thousands of Hispanic-Americans, many of whom were US citizens. On the foreign front he slapped some sense into Britain and France during the Suez CrisisWikipedia's W.svg, but his administration propped up numerous dictators throughout the world because of those dirty commies, the ultimate verdict being he was an excellent president for his time.


You know, I don't really know much about the late and great John F Kennedy tbh, other than that he nearly brought the world to the brink of nuclear holocaust during the Cuban Missile CrisisWikipedia's W.svg, and he initiated the disastrous Bay of Pigs invasion of Cuba. On the other hand, he did create the Peace Corps, so.... yay, I guess?


LBJ was another mixed bag, domestically he was a welcome relief, especially with his so-called "War on Poverty" that led to the introductions of programs like MedicaidWikipedia's W.svg for instance. On the other hand he escalated the Vietnam War , so "yay" I guess?