Physics envy

We control what you think with Language

Said and done

Phonics versus whole language Metaphor Irony Mass immigration Latin Crank

Jargon, buzzwords, slogans

Misandry Transgender glossary Elitism South Park Republicans TERF glossary Ideological patrolling v - t - e

“”In the humanities — literary criticism, anthropology and so on — there's a field called Theory; "We're just like the physicists. They talk incomprehensively? We can talk incomprehensively! They have big words? We'll have big words! They draw far-reaching conclusions? We'll draw far-reaching conclusions! We're just as prestigious as they are." Now if [the physicists] say, "Well, look — we're doing real science and you guys aren't", then that's white male/sexist/bourgeois/whatever the answer is.

—Noam Chomsky, a linguist.

Physics envy (cf. "penis envy") is a phrase used to criticize procrustean attempts to make a discipline more "scientific" (or perhaps just more "sciencey") by aping the form of the physical sciences, usually through what is claimed to be excessive use of formal logic or mathematicization.

The term was coined by biologist Joel E. Cohen in a 1971 issue of Science.

A rather literal example of this is the borrowing of equations from contemporary physics by the "marginalist school" of economists during the 19th century.

See also

• Jacques Lacan — the conflation of physics envy with penis envy
• Power plus prejudice
• Scientism
• Sokal affair

Further reading

• Segura, Julio and Carlos Rodríguez Braun (eds.) (2004). An Eponymous Dictionary of Economics — A Guide to Laws and Theorems Named after Economists. Edward Elgar Publishing. 

External links

• Lo, Andrew W. and Mueller, Mark T., Warning: Physics Envy May be Hazardous to Your Wealth! (March 12, 2010).
• Physics vs. Physics Envy

References

This science-related article is a stub.
You can help RationalWiki by expanding it.