cognitive scientist man
cognitive scientist man
What's the difference between me, and a robot that behaves exactly like me given the same input?
Are you worried about getting eaten by p-zombies?
The real problem is not in establishing whether you yourself are a p-zombie, but whether everyone else is.
Are you afraid that if you answer me, it'll set a precedent that you do all your cognitive sciencin' for free? Because I can't pay you...
Well, the p-zombie argument generally assumes that you can nail down the fact that you are conscious because you have first-hand experience. (Cogito ergo sum and all that, though you can even doubt that if you want to be a radical skeptic about it.) A zombie would not be self-aware, but would only act like it. The problem then is extrapolating that to other people and/or zombies.
In the sequel, they fight an army of Blockheads.
That's easy: the robot is a figment of your imagination and you are, I suppose, a real entity.
I hope you realise, Ariel, that everybody in that conversation left the site years ago?
ooops...