RationalWiki's Q4 2016 Fundraiser
We are 100% user-supported!
Without you, there is no RationalWiki!
Goal: $5000 Donations so far: $2890

Fighting pseudoscience isn't free.
Help and donate today!

Dennis Markuze

From RationalWiki
Jump to: navigation, search
Pictured here moments before storming off after a failed attempt to gatecrash the 2010 AAI convention in Montreal.
Someone is wrong on

The Internet

Icon internet.svg
Log in:
Some dare call it


Icon conspiracy.svg
What THEY don't want
you to know!
Sheeple wakers
—Yes, he actually spammed this in 2009[1]

Dennis Markuze (aka "David Mabus," etc.) is a notorious, prolific religious crank and serial cyberstalker from Montréal, Québec. He first became notorious for writing harassing letters to James Randi claiming that he'd somehow won the Million-dollar challenge, and has since taken up a life of stalking atheist bloggers such as PZ Myers[2] (and anyone even remotely connected to them), including trying to spam links on this very page.[3]

"Mabus" is apparently a reference to an Antichrist figure purportedly predicted by Nostradamus.[4] Aside from Markuze, the main modern-day pusher of the Nostradamian "Mabus" is the unimitatably nutty John Hogue.


[edit] Online threats

According to PZ Myers, Markuze began harassing him in 1993, starting with what Myers describes as "deranged messages" on Usenet and progressing to death threats over the years.[2] PZ Myers claims to have notified the Montreal police of Markuze's death threats several times to no effect. Markuze has also been active for over a decade spamming hundreds of atheist related websites, Twitter pages, online forums, and email inboxes, including making hundreds of death threats to other atheists with online presences. His rants also regularly show up in Usenet archives dating back as early as 1993.[4]

[edit] Modus operandi

Quite frankly if he were to go set up a blog and post his stuff on his own blog and have a twitter account to publicize it, a lot of skeptics would go read it. The thing that annoys us about it is that he is not content to post on his own site.
—Testimony from an IT security specialist at Markuzes' trial[5]

Markuze's modus operandi tends to involve persistently posting threatening, incoherent and weirdly formatted anti-atheist rants (including links to random Depeche Mode videos)[6] to any blog that strikes his fancy, rapidly morphing IDs (whenever possible including "mab" in the name) when he gets banned. His rants are often incoherent word salad (for example, "Atheist fuckers killed Mickey Mouse!"). His favorite targets include Richard Dawkins, Amanda Marcotte, Jen McCreight, Myers and Randi; he actually physically stalked Myers once at a conference in Canada - suddenly appearing in the hallway, ranting and raging incoherently with a few of the attendees, to then literally run away from the scene (all of this the exact moment after someone had falsely pulled the fire alarm).[7] He wasted no time going online to brag about what had happened.[8] This resulted in Myers reporting him to the police in September 2009.[9]

[edit] Arrest, psychiatric evaluation and trial

After an August 2011 online petition[4] attracted more than 5000 signatures,[10] each resulting in an e-mail to the Montreal police,[11] the police took action and announced they were finally investigating years of complaints[12] (after pleading with people to stop sending them emails[13]) and arrested Markuze on August 16.[14] Markuze was charged with 16 counts of criminal harassment on August 15 and August 17, 2011.[15] To the relief of many concerned for his well-being, the criminal court ordered him to undergo a 30 days psychological evaluation. After being diagnosed with bipolar disorder, compounded by alcohol and substance abuse, Markuze was sent to rehab while awaiting the next court date[16] but later released.[17] After pleading guilty to issuing threats, in 2012 he received a suspended sentence of 18 months,[18] which required him to abstain from internet discussions and forums.

[edit] Arrested again

Less than two months later, Markuze violated those terms and began harassing people via Twitter,[19] under the name Operation Archangel (@OperationArche, @Operati51436400 and variants).[20] He was re-arrested in November 2012[21] and released after a court hearing on 19 November, after agreeing to a number of conditions.[22] As of February 2013, he has violated those conditions first covertly and latterly overtly, sending threatening emails signed Mabus.

[edit] Mabus returns

On August 13, 2013, Mabus resumed harassing PZ Myers.[23] We await the next arrest.

As of January 24, 2014, Mabus was still at it, enlisting the help of an alleged "friend" to harass PZ Myers and others.[24] His "friend" posted similar rants on other atheism and freethought-related message boards, which, after others' responses, quickly devolved into rants very transparently written by Mabus himself, thereby casting further doubt, as if any were needed, on the idea that someone as clearly deranged as Mabus could have friends.[25]

By May 2014, Markuze was through with the pretence of "friends" and had resumed posting under the Mabus pseudonym, in violation of his court order once again.[26] Markuze still believed that he had committed no crime, citing Freedom of speech:

The charges laid on me are based on hearsay and conjecture. I am being charged for my controversial ideas, not for any offence... The condition to not debate on forums is a direct violation of my fundamental human rights. This condition must be removed. I’m a writer who engages in debate with the power of words, not force of arms.[27]

[edit] End of an Era (hopefully)

In June 2015, Markuze was finally sentenced to three years of probation with mandatory psychiatric treatment.[28] Hopefully, this is the end of Markuze's story, with him receiving the help he clearly needs.

[edit] Footnotes

  1. ScienceBlogs.com: Pharyngula - GOATS ON FIRE!
  2. 2.0 2.1 Time to institutionalize Dennis Markuze
  3. Markuze's attempts to change this page
  4. 4.0 4.1 4.2 Case Study: How a notorious spammer was brought down via Twitter
  5. Patheos.com - Dennis Markuze, Who Threatened Atheists Online for Years, Will Be Sentenced Tomorrow
  6. ScienceBlogs.com: Pharyngula - Dennis Markuze exposed
  7. Pharyngula - Dennis Markuze Exposed
  8. http://www.skepticfriends.org/forum/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=13526&whichpage=2#185044
  9. Pharyngula - Update on Dennis Markuze
  10. VICTORY! Montreal Police Begin Formal Investigation of “David Mabus”
  11. Montreal police investigating alleged threats made against atheists
  12. Tag Archive for Dennis Markuze at Doubtful News
  13. Montreal police deluged by thousands of Internet complaints about local man
  14. Montreal police make arrest in "Mabus" case on online death threats
  15. Montreal's 'Mabus' faces 16 charges for online threats
  16. Two tweets by Stephane C Giroux
  17. Mabus/Markuze Out and Back in Business
  18. Man who made online threats to be sentenced Thursday
  19. http://freethoughtblogs.com/axp/2012/07/26/is-dennis-markuze-already-violating-the-terms-of-his-suspended-sentence/
  20. http://skeptools.wordpress.com/2012/11/20/operation-archangel-david-mabus-dennis-markuze-montreal-arrested/
  21. https://twitter.com/spvm/status/270625482049998849
  22. http://doubtfulnews.com/2012/11/dennis-markuze-aka-david-mabus-arrested-again/
  23. Comment on Pharyngula
  24. PZ Myers: "No sympathy. None at all."
  25. "The Mabus Case" at Freethought Forum
  26. "How we won the James Randi $1,000,000 Paranormal Challenge" - disappointingly, he doesn't actually explain how...
  27. http://montrealgazette.com/news/local-news/man-who-continues-to-makes-online-threats-to-be-sentence-thursday Man who made online threats to be sentenced Thursday]
  28. Man who made threats over social networks ordered to follow treatment with psychiatrist
Personal tools