Civil union

It's the Law

To punish and protect

Punishment Terri Schiavo case Data Quality Act Heckler's veto Hate crime Child Protective Services Gun control Person John Roberts Percy Schmeiser Illegal schools in the United Kingdom Stephen Breyer v - t - e

A civil union is the joining of two people; however, it is technically not marriage and, depending on the location, may or may not involve the same rights and benefits marriage brings.

Not equal

So if in some countries the rights and entitlements are the same, why have separate ceremonies? Mostly this is to get past those with strong religious objections and who insist that marriage can only be between a man and a woman. This has obvious echoes with the way African-Americans were "separate but equal" in the Jim Crow South. They say a civil union is just as good, though you don't see them lining up to have one.

Politically this may be all that is achievable at the present time. Polls often show more support for civil ceremonies than same sex marriage and, as two New York Republicans found out in 2012, supporting same sex marriage may be electoral death.

With a key portion of the Defense of Marriage Act having been struck down by the US Supreme Court, the door has been opened for advocates to argue that civil unions are not equal to same-sex marriages, as they do not provide the federal benefits that marriage now does.

On the other side, there are some in the UK who support allowing heterosexual couples to get a civil union, on the basis that it provides a secular alternative to marriage, an institution loaded with historical cultural and religious baggage. This was rejected in the government's recent review of civil partnerships. So the UK situation now is that gay couples can get a civil partnership or a marriage or convert their existing civil partnership into a marriage, whilst straight couples only have the option of marriage. In at least some parts of the US, civil unions are open to heterosexual couples, though few opt for them.

Intolerance

However, even with all these differences, there are some groups of people who won't even tolerate civil unions, generally believing that anyone who performs what they call sexual immorality (even if no sex is involved) deserves no rights. Tellingly, many of the people now insisting on this "compromise" fell into the "no rights at all" category before it started to become obvious they their side was losing and it was just making them look like bigots. A rather comical, yet sad event happened in Texas in 2005 when lawmakers tried to ban anything "identicle^[sic] to or similar to marriage". This technically banned marriage for everyone.

Advantages

Civil unions aren't necessarily a bad idea when they're not being used as an excuse to deny gay people rights. If couples want to make sure they're making the right decision before getting married, a "medium" level of legally recognized commitment might be useful.

Civil marriage

There is a concept in some states, and more importantly, nations outside of the grip of the Religious Right that emphasize the legal sense of marriage by establishing "civil marriages" in lieu of or in addition to religious marriages. These should not be confused with civil unions, which are an attempt by the less extreme of the religious bigots to "at least give the gays something".

Civil Partnerships

In the UK, civil partnerships were brought in for same sex couples, offering the same rights as traditional marriage but stopping short of being recognised as marriage. They were also only available to same sex couples. When same sex marriage was legalised in 2013, civil partnerships were still available to same sex couples, while existing civil partnerships could be upgraded to marriage. This presented a rare occurrence of same sex couples having more rights than opposite sex couples as civil partnerships were only an option for same sex couples. This was rectified in 2019 in England and Wales when, after a ruling by the Supreme Court that it was incompatible with the European Convention on Human Rights, civil partnerships were opened up to opposite sex couples. In 2020 Scotland and Northern Ireland followed suit.

External links

• 8 Important Distinctions Between Marriages and Civil Unions by undohate.com, video at YouTube