User:Colossal Squid/Deep Adaptation

From RationalWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
It's gettin' hot in here
Global warming
Globalwarming2.svg
Feverish dreams
Hot-headed goons
v - t - e

Deep Adaptation: A Map for Navigating Climate Tragedy[1] is a paper on global warming written by sociologist Jem Bendell. It has gained notorious media attention for being "so depressing it sends people to therapy."[2] It posits that the effects of climate change may be so extreme as to lead to civilizational collapse, and that instead of downplaying this conclusion, we should embrace it. A central theme is the notion of 3 R's: Resilience, Relinquishment, and Restoration. Resilience to keep things we want to keep, Relinquishment of harmful things, and Restoration of approaches and attitudes that oil-based civilization eroded such as rewilding ecosystems.

Science (or lack thereof)[edit]

The paper did not pass peer review, a fact that Bendell proudly advertises,[3] and that should instantly send up red flags to anyone expecting a scientifically rigorous article. Indeed, climate scientist Michael Mann simply dismissed it as "crap,"[4], further elaborating that "The concept of "uncontrollable levels of climate change" is both unscientific and nonsensical..."[5] He also relies on questionable sources for his claims, such as his claim that 5°C was already baked in by the current CO2 concentration being cited from an unpublished paper by a self-described "systems analyst"[6] which relies on the clathrate gun hypothesis that the scientific community has deemed lacking in evidence.[7] He also doesn't cite concrete examples, claiming that civilizational collapse is too complicated and unprecedented a problem, even though there are many real-world case studies of societies adapting to resource collapse.[8][9]

Politics[edit]

Because Bendell doesn't propose solutions beyond a vague framework of the 3 R's, the paper has become a Rorschach inkblot that readers interpret differently depending on their political background. Many people have accused Bendell of encouraging denialism, inaction,[3] racism, or ecofascism.[10] For what it's worth, he supports and has advised Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn,[11] is an active participant in Extinction Rebellion,[12] and is explicit in identifying patriarchy and capitalism as core problems.[13]

References[edit]

  1. ↑ The paper in question
  2. ↑ The climate change paper so depressing it's sending people to therapy
  3. ↑ 3.0 3.1 The study on collapse they thought you should not read – yet
  4. ↑ Mann's Twitter 1
  5. ↑ Mann's Twitter 2
  6. ↑ Deep Adaptation Is - ‘Crap’ - Climate Scientist Michael Mann - This Is The Paper 'So Depressing It Sends People To Therapy'
  7. ↑ Gas Hydrate Breakdown Unlikely to Cause Massive Greenhouse Gas Release
  8. ↑ From Oil Crisis to Energy Revolution – How Nations Once Before Planned to Kick the Oil Habit
  9. ↑ Organic or starve: can Cuba's new farming model provide food security?
  10. ↑ "It’s a racist garbage theory that erases the lives of billions of people whose voices for transformational change have been systematically excluded by the climate community for decades. We must do better than that."
  11. ↑ For the many: what the Corbyn campaign learned from Bernie Sanders
  12. ↑ Nature Doesn’t Do Deals – why we rise on climate
  13. ↑ A quick message to lefty intellectuals about deep adaptation
Retrieved from "https://rationalwiki.org/w/index.php?title=User:Colossal_Squid/Deep_Adaptation&oldid=2121646"