Information icon.svg Consider taking the RationalWiki Community Survey 2017 or see the results.

Nanny state

From RationalWiki
Jump to: navigation, search
The French Nanny State of 1901.
It doesn't stop
at the water's edge

Politics
Icon politics.svg
Theory
Practice
Philosophies
Terms
As usual
Country sections
Flag of the United States.svg
Flag of the United Kingdom.svg

Nanny state (also known as government paternalism) is a snarl term used by libertarians and sometimes, though hypocritically, by conservatives for perceived over-regulation by the government. The classic example is a requirement to wear a seat-belt, but it could apply to any behavior that risks harm to the self but no one else. A list of potential candidates for accusations of nanny statism would include:

Conservapedia even includes compulsory education, public service announcements encouraging healthy eating, and (why not?) Hillary Clinton's observation and subsequent book title, “It Takes a Village.”[7]

Nannyism or reasonable restrictions on "rights" (like the right to be stupid)?[edit]

As usual, whether the government action qualifies as “nanny statism” depends on whether the person agrees with the action. Sin taxes, at minimum, raise revenue for necessary infrastructure, education, and public services without distorting the economy in harmful ways. Actions that seem to threaten only the well-being of the person who engages in the risky behavior can potentially harm others because others often have to pay for the medical treatment by way of increased hospital costs. Recreational drugs have harmful effects on people other than just the user, notably the neglected children of drug addicts and people who have to deal with drunken/drugged behaviour from others (see Drug Liberalization for more on this topic). And might one be tempted to "assist" his rich, old uncle with "suicide" to end his "suffering"?

See also[edit]

Health and safety

References[edit]

  1. Cato Institute
  2. Conservapedia includes requirements for fire sprinklers in new construction, though fire spreading from house to house is a harm that affects more than just the individual whose “rights” are curtailed. CP
  3. Cato Institute
  4. CP
  5. Notably absent from CP
  6. Ditto
  7. CP