Information icon.svg

Campaigning for the RationalMedia Foundation 2021 board of trustees election is underway!

Humans are herbivores

From RationalWiki
Jump to: navigation, search
Potentially edible!
Food woo
Icon food.svg
Fabulous food!
Delectable diets!
Bodacious bods!

"Humans are herbivores" is an idea that has cropped up in fringe sections of the vegan community. It is often used as an argument by vegans but can exist as an idea on its own.

Proponents[edit]

Arguments[edit]

Most of the arguments in support of this idea are based on comparative anatomy and physiology, as well as supposedly "common sense" speculations about human evolution. They include the following:

  • The argument that our teeth are similar to animals such as cows. Aside from being inaccurate, this ignores that bonobos, despite having similar teeth, are omnivores.
A Bonobo taking pride in being different from humans
  • Similarly, the argument that human beings couldn't possibly have torn apart and eaten prey due to their puny teeth, jaws, and nails.[3] This ignores that hominins have had stone tools for at least 2.6 million years, and it would be difficult to find evidence today if they had other, less-durable tools (like sharpened sticks) even before then.[4] Butchery marks made by sharp tools on bones from that time period indicate that these tools were used by hominins for stripping and breaking bones and extracting marrow.[5] The evolution of many distinctively human features (such as our brains) happened since we began eating meat.[6] Homo erectus and other primitive humans had larger teeth than present-day humans; it has been hypothesized that a reduction in tooth and jaw size occurred in our ancestors after they developed cooking, as cooking makes food much easier to break down
  • The argument that our colons are longer than those of other omnivorous mammals. This ignores that our colons are shorter than those of specialized herbivores, and that chimps have even longer colons,[7] despite being omnivores — although their diet is overwhelmingly plant-based.[8]
  • The argument that there is no way early hominids could have hunted down animals ourselves. This is fractally wrong; ironically enough, vegans saying this are subscribing to the widespread view in "meat-eating" Western culture that "meat" equals large mammals. Humans eat many kinds of animals: small game, poultry, fish, insects, shellfish, and so on, to say nothing of eggs, honey, or carrion. Chimpanzees and some other primates eat many of these as well. Early humans may have also scavenged,[9] and while predators such as lions would be unable to easily break open bones, early hominids could use rocks to smash open skulls and large bones to access the brain and bone-marrow.

These also ignore that the only natural source of Vitamin B12 is meat or other animal products, such as milk and eggs. B12 deficiency causes pernicious anemia which, as the name suggests, if left untreated will kill you. Indeed, a few vegetarians and vegans every year either die or get seriously sick from improperly managing their diets. Groups such as the American Dietetic Association state that all vegetarians or vegans need to consume supplemental B12 or foods fortified with it.[10] Most primates are able to get B12 from their gut bacteria and absorb it in their large intestine, but human beings have different intestines which can only absorb B12 in the small intestine, even though bacteria still produce it in our large intestines, and we then poop it out unabsorbed. It's not certain exactly when this change in our ancestors' digestive systems occurred, but logically it must have happened when there was already a substantial external source of B12 in our diets, i.e. after we started to eat meat.[11]

Furthermore, it ignores that most larger herbivores aren't themselves strictly herbivores, gnawing on bones and even occasionally meat.[12][13] Deer, for instance, will eat carrion (and even engage in cannibalism), and to acquire the nutrients needed to grow their antlers every breeding season, the males will search out bird nests and devour the eggs and chicks. If given the opportunity, a deer will eat your corpse.[14]

Fact[edit]

The mainstream view of human evolution is that until around 4 million years ago, the ancestors of humans lived in the jungle eating fruits and other soft plants. Around 4 million years ago, Australopithecus moved into the savannah and began eating harder foods, including seeds, nuts, roots, arthropods, small mammals, and possibly carrion or food left by larger predators.[15] Around 2.6 million years ago, australopithecines developed tools, and probably somewhere between 1.7m and 1m years ago, early humans began to control fire, both of which allowed them to consume a greater range of foods, including the meat of large animals.[4] Through all this, humans continued to evolve and change in their ability to catch and consume different types of food, and anatomically modern humans did not appear until 200,000 years ago.

Overall the argument that humans are naturally herbivores argument is a pseudoscientific appeal to nature that doesn't even correctly understand "nature". This takes away from the more legitimate arguments for veganism and vegetarianism, such as ethical and environmental reasons. In assuming the choice is between plants and large mammals (bovids, deer, ovids, etc.), it also shows an ignorance of the wide range of non-vegan foods eaten by humans today.

External links[edit]

References[edit]

  1. Is It Really Natural? The Truth About Humans and Eating Meat. PETA, January 28, 2018.
  2. Vegan Gains. Joe Rogan Says Vegan Diets Are Bad. YouTube.
  3. Is It Really Natural? The Truth About Humans and Eating Meat, PETA, accessed 18 Feb 2020
  4. 4.0 4.1 Ancient Tools, Smithsonian
  5. Evidence for Meat-Eating by Early Humans, Pobiner, B., Nature Education Knowledge 4(6):1 (2013)
  6. The Evolution of Diet, Ann Gibbons, National Geographic
  7. Mu, Kevin. What are chimpanzee digestive systems like compared to humans’ (answer). Quora.
  8. Watts, David P., Kevin B. Potts, Jeremiah S. Lwanga, and John C. Mitani. "Diet of chimpanzees (Pan troglodytes schweinfurthii) at Ngogo, Kibale National Park, Uganda, 1. Diet composition and diversity." American Journal of Primatology 74, no. 2 (2012): 114-129.
  9. McLarren, Dan. Study Lends New Support to Theory that Early Humans were Scavengers. March 3, 2015.
  10. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5188422/
  11. The Evolutionary Quirk That Made Vitamin B12 Part of Our Diet, Nathan Lents, Discover Magazine, August 13, 2018
  12. Osteophagia and bone modifications by giraffe and other large ungulates, Jarod M.Hutson, Chrissina C. Burke, Gary Haynes, Journal of Archaeological Science, Volume 40, Issue 12, December 2013, Pages 4139-4149
  13. This Poor Chicken Got Eaten by a Cow, Smithsonian Magazine, April 15, 2014
  14. You have been warned
  15. How Ancient Teeth Reveal the Roots of Humankind, Smithsonian Magazine, July 2, 2018