Information icon.svg Nominations and campaigning for the RationalWiki 2019 Moderator Election is underway and will end on November 16.

Asexual exclusionism

From RationalWiki
Jump to: navigation, search
We're so glad you came
Sexuality
Icon sex.svg
Reach around the subject
Gay sign.png

Asexual exclusionism (often shortened to ace exclusionism) is a trendy new form of bullying dedicated to pretending to care about the LGBT cause by kicking out those horrible cringey aceys (asexuals) from the those spaces. It began to be popular around 2013, the same time as the rise of TERFs and people who insist "queer is a slur!"[1][2] Ace exclusionism is a manifestation of acephobia (discrimination and negative attitudes toward asexuals).[3]

The bullying from asexual exclusionists has basically destroyed the ace community on Tumblr and pushed people back into the closet.[4]

While ace exclusionists often focus their hatred on asexuals, aromantic people are often targeted too.

Tactics[edit]

hey ace kids! stop scrolling! you deserve to get hit by a bus
—Tumblr user killaces[5] But remember, this is definitely not bullying!

Asexual exclusionists aren't above vicious bullying. A few tools in their box include suicide baiting,[6] voicing violent fantasies,[7] rape wishes,[8] posting graphic content in positivity tags (never mind the existence of minors), and more. They've also discussed ensuring that aces stay in the closet and in the dark.[9]

They'll also deny the fact that asexuals are actually oppressed. Asexual people face dehumanization, sexual harassment, and discrimination if they dare to come out.[10][11] They're at risk for conversion therapy and even "corrective rape".[12]

Many ace exclusionism tactics are taken straight from the TERF and biphobe playbooks.[13]

History denialism[edit]

Asexual people have a rich history.[14][15] Yet according to ace exclusionists, they are only closeted cishet incels who want a piece of the victimhood pie and steal attention from those who are oppressed enough like the rest of the community.

Common arguments[edit]

Here are a few common anti-ace arguments.

RhetoricRationalWiki response
Calling non-asexual people "alloromantic" is lumping us in with our straight oppressors! Calling anyone LGBT is also lumping LGBT people of color, women, disabled people, etc. with their oppressors. It's almost like there are multiple axes of oppression.

Suggesting that children can be asexual is predatory! Teenagers have sexualities, and acknowledging this won't kill us. You know what is harmful to mental health? Marginalizing and dehumanizing ace teens by teaching them heteronormative sex ed and expecting them to blossom into sexual beings. Most ace teens grow up feeling broken and alienated from their communities, exactly like how gays felt when they were expected to love the opposite sex. Perhaps you'd like to do something about the exclusionists putting graphic sexual content in the ace tag and telling asexual kids to kill themselves? Vicious words to aces are far more predatory and damaging to aces as well as potentially turning aces away the very community that can be a valuable source of validation, experience, and sense of belonging, which is supposed to be a paramount goal of the LGBT community.

Aces just want to be oppressed. Who in their right mind wants to be oppressed? This is just invalidating and downplaying their experiences and this argument has common ground with bigotry throughout history. Why do aces go through these lengths detailing their experiences, creating safe and open communities to listen, expressing their feelings including their need to belong to the LGBT community? These are means to avoid or at least prevent oppression (particularly trying to avoid or deal with the pushback that comes when new minority groups start becoming more visible), making this argument more nonsensical.

LGBT organizations only acknowledge them because they feel threatened! Asexual people are a minority in the community.. And also, this argument hugely neglects the efforts of the organizations to include aces as part of the discourse because they want to promote a positive atmosphere of validation, understanding, comfort, love, and acceptance. You do not represent them and you are a disservice to their efforts.

Asexuals dating non-asexual people is inherently abusive! This argument seems to claim that asexuals deny their lovers sex and therefore, it is inherently abusive. Typical of exclusionary bigotry, this is a huge naïve misunderstanding of how aces work with allosexuals and also just seem to be coming from those that never had a relationship ever. It is flawed in several ways: sex, while a common part of allosexual relationship, is not the only activity that makes a relationship, and it may not even be the most important. This depends on the needs of each party, as sex drive does indeed fall in a spectrum for everyone. This argument also assumes that asexuals cannot accept sex, though this stereotypes asexuals. Asexuality's only common trait is that aces are not interested in sex and they do not suffer if they do not pursue it. Asexuality is also a type of attraction; there are multiple factors how a person is attractive, and how well someone does in bed is only one of them. Within, there are aces that can enjoy the activity, aces that satisfy their allosexual partner, or aces that simply do not enjoy it and their partner can either withhold sex all together or find sexual pleasure through other means. The central idea rings true in all relationships, that open communication is important, boundaries should be explored and negotiated, and compromises should be made. Ace exclusionists should be well aware of basic relationshipping before they start disparaging aces in their blind hatred and just assuming aces don't know how to relationship.

A few of their many, many problems[edit]

Racism[edit]

Exclusionists love to paint asexual people as white teenagers who want to pretend to be oppressed. They ignore and speak over asexual people of color.[16]

TERF connections[edit]

Many people have pointed out that ace exclusionism is a lot like TERF rhetoric,[17] and that many people who start as ace exclusionists become TERFs as well.[18] Ace exclusionism normalizes TERF ideas and brings them into the popular lexicon.

Anti-autistic ableism[edit]

you guys get REAL fuckin nervous when i highlight that the majority of your jeering about aces' perceived awkwardness, missed social cues, infantilization/dehumanization, or "unfuckability"/"cringey-ness" are repackaged ableism, especially considering that a good percentage of the ace community is also autistic
—Metapianycist on Tumblr[4]

Many of the bullying tactics used against asexuals are the same things used against autistic people.

Of course, ace exclusionists flip it around and claim that asexuals, actually, are the ones hurting autistics. Ace exclusionists have tried to say that asexuals are somehow harming autistic people. When asexuals use "a-spec" to describe the asexual and aromantic spectrum, exclusionists claim that "a-spec" is a word for the autism spectrum. (It isn't. Autistic people have said that it isn't.[19][20] But exclusionists are too busy "defending" autistics from the evil aceys to pay attention or care.)

External links[edit]

References[edit]

  1. Tumblr user sabertoothwalrus found a correlation between TERFs, ace exclusionists, and hatred of queer people
  2. Google trends timeline of "is queer a slur", "are asexuals lgbt" and "trans exclusionary radical feminism"
  3. Parmenter, Joshua Glenn. The Culture of Sexuality: Identification, Conceptualization, and Acculturation Processes Within Sexual Minority and Heterosexual Cultures, p. 96. Utah State University, August 2018.
  4. 4.0 4.1 Tumblr post on ace discourse destroying the community
  5. Tumblr post by killaces
  6. Tumblr user fucking-deactivated encouraging asexual minors to kill themselves
  7. Tumblr user moe-amethyst talking about the desire to murder asexuals
  8. Tumblr post showing suicide baiting and rape wishes directed at asexuals
  9. Screenshot of a Tumblr post about deleting asexuality from Wikipedia
  10. Prejudice Against "Group X" (Asexuals) - Psychology Today
  11. Queer But Not Deemed Queer Enough – The Battle For Asexual Inclusion
  12. Battling Asexual Discrimination, Sexual Violence And ‘Corrective’ Rape - Huffington Post
  13. Tumblr post discussing how aphobes and biphobes are similar
  14. See the Wikipedia article on Timeline of asexual history.
  15. The Tumblr bloggers building a canon of asexual history
  16. Tumblr post on the agency of asexual women of color
  17. A Tumblr post on ace exclusionism being a gateway ideology for TERFs
  18. A Tumblr post showing ace exclusionists who became TERFs
  19. Tumblr post on how a-spec is NOT about autism, and autistics would really appreciate it if exclusionists would stop
  20. Tumblr post with many screenshots of autistics saying that a-spec is not a word about autism