Norman Finkelstein

From RationalWiki
Jump to: navigation, search
Finkelstein in 2005
Tomorrow is a mystery,
but yesterday is

History
Icon history.svg
Wie es eigentlich gewesen

Norman Finkelstein is a political scientist and historian whose work focuses on the history of the Palestinians and Zionism. He also a well known advocate of Hezbolah,[1] a Shi'ite Islamic militant group and political party based in Lebanon.[2] His work is extremely controversial as it challenges ideas considered conventional in the United States about Israeli policy towards the Palestinians.[3] Finkelstein has written a series of books about Israeli-Palestinian relations with titles that were confrontational and caustic, such as Beyond Chutzpah and The Holocaust Industry. As a result, his work is often quote mined by neo-Nazi and white supremacist groups; Finkelstein's detractors use this to paint him as a self-hating Jew, an anti-Semite, a Holocaust denier, and a supporter of terrorism.[4] Finkelstein is currently teaching at a university in Turkey,[5] following a controversial rejection of his tenure bid at DePaul University, which led to an out-of-court settlement, but he continues to make speeches and offer news commentary.[6] Around the time of his tenure bid at DePaul, Mr. Fikelstein declared his support for Hezbollah at an anti-Israel rally, where he exclaimed: "We are all Hezbollah".[7]

Biography[edit]

Finkelstein was raised in New York's Coney Island neighborhood by Maryla Husyt Finkelstein and Zacharias Finkelstein, both Polish Jews who survived the Nazi Holocaust. His mother was almost fanatic in her views on pacifism,[8] making an impact on him at a young age. He traveled to the Palestinian Territories and wrote a memoir about the First Intifada after completing his thesis on Zionism and the portrayals of the Israeli-Palestine Conflict. His thesis was based around the deconstruction of a hodge-podged woo history of Israel, From Time Immemorial by Joan Peters, which was declared the best book ever written by the mainstream literary press before Finkelstein made clear it was less than tenable in its basic premise, that the idea of native indigenous Palestinians was a fiction foisted by anti-Semitic Arab terrorists upon the Israelis in 1948.[9]

In 2003, he called Alan Dershowitz a plagiarist on international radio,[10] a move which culminated with the absolute atomization of any career it could be said Finkelstein had. The charge is that the inaccuracies in Dershowitz's book The Case for Israel are practically identical to the inaccuracies in Joan Peters's book and that The Case for Israel contains twenty such examples. Within the year, Dershowitz had sent an inflammatory package of woo through the internets, alleging all sorts of obscenities, including the idea that Finkelstein's mother was a collaborating kapoWikipedia's W.svg in a concentration camp.[11] The fact that then-Harvard Law School Dean and now-Supreme Court Justice Elena Kagan let such a gross breach of academic freedom and slander be posted on the Harvard Law School's web server and web page elevates the deeply disturbing fact to a whole other level.[12][13] DePaul University in Chicago then rejected his tenure bid despite a majority vote in favor. As such, Finkelstein is, in academic terms, relegated to the equivalent of Limbo, un-tenured but not so much disgraced (as is the case with Creationist geologists) as much as disenfranchised at this intersection between academia and politics.

Recently, Finkelstein has condemned BDS because he sees the movement as being opposed to Israel’s right to exist as clearly cited in international law. This opposition to BDS is a(nother) stance Finkelstein shares with his friend and mentor Noam Chomsky. Both view the BDS movement as quasi-religious and impractical with Finkelstein drawing parallels to his own, youthful, fervent Maoism (from which he became thoroughly disillusioned). [14]

The Holocaust Industry[edit]

In 2000, his book The Holocaust Industry raised hackles because, well, the title seems pretty obvious. Finkelstein claims that Israeli propaganda and aligned Western Zionist groups, such as AIPACWikipedia's W.svg, manipulate public opinion of Israeli policy towards the Palestinians by invoking the Holocaust.[15] The book catalogs abuse of the memory of the Holocaust for crude political and financial gain, including an investigation of the Swiss banking industry for alleged Nazi collaboration and the invocation and equation of Israeli political opponents with Nazis, as with the bitter political campaigns between Benjamin Netanyahu and Yitzhak Rabin. He also dedicates a good section to making Elie WieselWikipedia's W.svg out to be some sort of charlatan and faux-priest shaman of mystical Holocaust woo.[16]

Finkelstein's claims about Swiss banks being extorted (in other words, the semi-governmental Jewish Agency falsely accused them of stealing Eastern European Jews' money) are not a figment of his imagination. He has been backed up by Raul HilbergWikipedia's W.svg, one of the world's foremost scholars on the Holocaust, and by Avi ShlaimWikipedia's W.svg, a highly respected, and perhaps revolutionary, scholar on the State of Israel's early history.[17] In fact, the book is one of debunking. Swiss banks are for rich global customers, as well as domestic customers of any class; the Jews of Eastern Europe were very poor. Even if there were a few exceptions to this (there were), how is it possible that Swiss banks have kept over one billion dollars from holocaust survivors and their descendants (the full size of the settlement that the banks paid being $1.25 billion)? Furthermore, there were probably no Swiss Jews who endured the Holocaust[citation needed] (excluding maybe a few dual citizens, if there were any) because the Axis never invaded Switzerland due to Swiss neutrality, so it is unlikely those banks would have gotten away with stealing money from Jews living in Switzerland at that point in time either, except perhaps those who came to Switzerland as refugees and were later placed in internment (not death) camps.[18]

What really irks Finkelstein, and anyone in their right mind, was that the money from the $1.25 billion settlement didn't make it into the hands of Holocaust survivors or their heirs or heirs of those who perished[citation needed], even though that's whose name the case was brought for in the first place.[19]

Tone[edit]

One consistent complaint about Finkelstein is the fact he is prone to making some truly biting and all-around smart-ass remarks in his books.[20] This does not impact his research or conclusions, but it is a hook for those trying to discredit him as a charlatan.[citation needed]

Bibliography[edit]

  • 2012: Knowing Too Much: Why the American Jewish Romance with Israel is Coming to an End, OR Books, New York: 2012., ISBN 978-1-935928-77-5
  • 2012: What Gandhi Says About Nonviolence, Resistance and Courage, OR Books, New York: 2012., ISBN 978-1-935928-79-9
  • 2011: Goldstone Recants. Richard Goldstone renews Israel’s license to kill, OR Books, New York: 2011., ISBN 978-1-935928-51-5
  • 2010: This Time We Went Too Far: Truth and Consequences of the Gaza Invasion. OR Books, New York: 2010., ISBN 978-1-935928-43-0
  • 2005: Beyond Chutzpah: On the Misuse of Anti-Semitism and the Abuse of History. U of California P, ISBN 0-520-24598-9. 2nd updated edition, U of Cal. P. June 2008, ISBN 0-520-24989-5, contains an appendix written by Frank J. Menetrez, Dershowitz vs Finkelstein. Who's Right and Who's Wrong?, p. 363-394,
  • 2000: The Holocaust Industry: Reflections on the Exploitation of Jewish Suffering, Verso, ISBN 1-85984-488-X.
  • 1998: A Nation on Trial: The Goldhagen Thesis and Historical Truth (Co-author with Ruth Bettina Birn) Henry Holt and Co., ISBN 0-8050-5872-9.
  • 1996: The Rise and Fall of Palestine: A Personal Account of the Intifada Years. Minneapolis: U of Minnesota P, ISBN 0-8166-2859-9.
  • 1995: Image and Reality of the Israel-Palestine Conflict, Verso, ISBN 1-85984-442-1
  • 1987: From the Jewish Question to the Jewish State: An Essay on the Theory of Zionism, thesis, Princeton University.

External links[edit]

References[edit]

  1. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XpFmxnwQ9Bw
  2. Hezbollah. The Encyclopedia Britannica.
  3. http://www.chomsky.info/books/power01.htm Noam Chomsky is a personal friend and mentor.
  4. http://garyfouse.blogspot.com/2010/05/norman-finklestein-at-uc-irvine.html Typical woo.
  5. The biography page on his website
  6. cf. American Radical: The Trails of Norman Finkelstein, dirs. David Ridgen, Nicolas Rossier.
  7. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XpFmxnwQ9Bw
  8. cf. David Ridgen, Nicolas Rossier
  9. Edward Said and Christopher Hitchens, eds. Blaming the Victims: Spurious Scholarship And The Palestinian Question, pp. 23-31, 1988.
  10. http://youtu.be/DeTpKASahAc
  11. Wayback Machine capture
  12. Finkelstein's perspective on the matter in writing
  13. Finkelstein's perspective on the matter in video
  14. An Unpopular Man: Norman Finkelstein comes out against BDS movement, by Jordan Michael Smith, The New Republic, July 8, 2015
  15. cf. Finkelstein, The Holocaust Industry.
  16. http://www.salon.com/2000/08/30/finkelstein_2/
  17. Shlaim and Hilberg in their own words
  18. "Switzerland". Yad Vashem. Includes info on interned refugees in Switzerland
  19. Page 2 of the report in the "external links" section of this article.
  20. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mSwVz7JTRCA Michael Coren obviously makes it clear he is totally uncomfortable doing this television interview.