Board elections.

The RationalMedia Foundation board elections are a'happenin'.

  • Nominations will commence on 26 June 2016 and run through 10 July 2016.
  • The voting dates are TBA.

To register to vote: RationalWiki:RationalMedia Foundation/Voter registration

Useful links:

from FuzzyCatPotato (Talk), group Site wide (urgent) at 18:49, 26 June 2016

Bronze-level articleIslam

From RationalWiki
(Redirected from Muslim)
Jump to: navigation, search
Party Like It's 632


Icon islam.svg
Turning towards Mecca
If the people of this religion are asked about the proof for the soundness of their religion, they flare up, get angry and spill the blood of whoever confronts them with this question. They forbid rational speculation, and strive to kill their adversaries. This is why truth became thoroughly silenced and concealed.
—Muhammad ibn Zakariya al-Razi[1]

Islam is the third major monotheistic Abrahamic religion. It was founded between 609 and 640 CE by Muhammad, who is considered the last divine prophet and who relayed the text of the Qur'an, which is considered the authentic and final revelation of God (Arabic: Allah).[note 1] Essentially, if God's Holy Book was a series, then the Qur'an is the Revised, Updated, And Final Edition (following the Torah (Ed. 1) and Bible (Ed. 2)), and Muhammad is its editor.

According to Islam, the religion was founded when God (Arabic: Allah) sent the arch-angel Jibreel (Gabriel) to the Prophet Muhammad. The angel related a series of revelations to him, which Muhammad dictated to his followers. It was these teachings, both written and transmitted orally, that were eventually compiled into the Qur'an. Muhammed is considered to be the chief and final prophet.

Islam was long referred to in English as Mohammadanism or Mahometanism; this is now considered an insult. Mussulman is also an old word for a Muslim; again, this is no longer used in English, but is still common in other European languages, such as Portuguese and French, and in Indic languages, such as Urdu, Hindi, and Gujarati.

The holy text of Islam is the Qur'an, which is held to be the revealed word of Allah. Muslims believe its verses were transmitted through the angel Gabriel to Muhammad, Allah's final prophet. The sunnah, or recorded practices of the Prophet as passed down in books of hadith (lit. "news"), clarify how Islam is supposed to be practiced, and are nearly as important to the practice of the religion as the Qur'an (except for Quranists[wp]). The Sunni hadith collections are called the Kutub al-Sittah (the six books), the Shia hadith collections are called the Kutub al-Arba'a (the four books). Ibadis have their own hadiths, in particular the Jami Sahih. Although Muslims do not believe Jesus Christ to be the Son of Allah, he is an important prophet; he is considered a precursor to Muhammad, helping prepare the world for the "final revelation". Additionally, Muslims believe that Jesus will return at the end of times.

In Arabic, "Islam" means "peace" and "submission" (root word s-l-m; cf. as-salamu alaykum, Arabic greeting) and "peace through submission" (to God, specifically) and descends etymologically from the root word Aslama, meaning "submission"; thus, a Muslim is "one who has submitted to (or made peace with) God." Whether or not violent holy warriors like Osama bin Laden are "true Muslims" is, therefore, a question for Muslim scholars. This is a common problem in many other religions which preach peace and harmony, yet frequently have violent histories. One issue Islam struggles with that other religions do not is that Islam has a policy of abrogation, wherein later revelations can supersede earlier ones.[2] Most of Muhammad's more peaceful pronouncements came from earlier revelations, and the more warlike revelations came after, so unfortunately Salafism and other militant interpretations of the Qur'an are consistent with this policy.


[edit] Schisms and denominations

There are many different denominations within Islam, but the two most notable groups within modern Islam are the Sunni and the Shia. The schism between the Sunni and Shia is akin to the schism between the Roman Catholic Church and the Eastern Orthodox Churches - it is interesting that both splits occurred as a result of power struggles, personality clashes and theological differences. Following the death of Muhammad, the prophet and founder of Islam, his cousin Ali was expected by some followers, the party of Ali (Shiat Ali), to be his successor in the fledgling Rashidun Caliphate. In fact, before Ali became Caliph, Muhammad was succeeded by Abu Bakr, Omar and Uthman, until Ali finally became the Caliph. While Sunnis consider all of these Caliphs to be legitimate, Shias only supported Ali.

After that, the murder of Ali's son Husayn solidified the schism.

Within and around these groups there are other subsets of Islam. Among these is Sufism, an ascetic spiritual movement similar in philosophy to Buddhism, and fundamentalist groups such as Salafism and Wahhabism. Druze, Yazidism, and Ba'hai are offshoots of Islam, though not traditionally considered to be included within the Islamic faith but independent belief systems.

  • Nondenominational Muslims are those who do not follow a particular branch and simply call themselves "Muslim".
  • Shia/Shi'ites believe that the prophet Muhammad appointed Ali ibn Abi Talib as his successor. Shia prefer hadiths attributed to the Ahlul Bayt (the prophet's family) and close associates. Shias consider the city of Karbala holy. They make up roughly 10 to 20% of all Muslims.[3]
  • Sunnis consider Abu Bakr to be Muhammad's successor. There are four major schools of legal interpretation among Sunnis; Hanafi, Maliki, Hanbali, and Shafi'i. They make up roughly 75% of the world's Muslims.[4] Sunni beliefs are typically based on the Qur'an and the Kutub al-Sittah (the six books of hadith). The Kutub al-Sittah consists of Sahih Bukhari, Sahih Muslim, Sunan al-Sughra, Sunan Abu Dawood, Jami al-Tirmidhi, and Sunan ibn Majah. Sunnis are sometimes called Bukharists.
  • Sufism is a mystical denomination, which is often subject to persecution among other Muslims. Often-misguided variants of Sufism are sold to western New Agers.
  • Ahmadiyya is a reformist denomination founded by Mirza Ghulam Ahmed, who is considered to be the Mahdi. Their motto is "love for all; hatred for none."
  • Ahle Quran, also known as Quraniyoon, is an Islamic denomination that generally rejects the authoritative nature of hadith collections, and considers the Qur'an to be the only dependable religious text.
  • Ibadi is a branch of Islam that came out of the Kharijites. Its adherents are particularly found in Oman and Algeria.
  • 5-percenters self-identify as Muslims and follow the Five-Percent Nation.
  • Alawites are an off-shoot of the Shia movement. Notable Alawites include the ruling Assad family of Syria.
  • The Nation of Islam is a US based organization which blends elements of Islamic teaching with elements of liberation theology and black nationalism. Originally, the movement held its founder, Wallace D. Fard, as the Mahdi, though since the late 1970s it has largely reintegrated with mainstream Sunni Islam. Louis Farrakhan, a prominent minister within the movement, rejected this reintegration and led a schism of the organization, retaining the Nation of Islam name.

[edit] The Five Pillars

Islam has five core pillars, which are considered to be the most important part of Islam. All Muslims are expected to follow them.

  • The Shahadah: An oath of faith which states "There is no god but Allah, Muhammad is the messenger of Allah."[note 2] One who voluntarily takes the oath is considered a Muslim. However the phrase is often spoken into the ear of newborn babies as both a proxy oath for the child, and a blessing. Once a convert has taken the oath, they cannot change their mind without being considered an apostate by the Muslim community. Many Muslim scholars believe that the punishment for apostasy should be death,[5] and such death penalties are imposed in a number of Islamic countries including Pakistan[6] and Saudi Arabia.[7]
  • Salah: Prayer. Prayer must be made five times per day, though this can be suspended depending on illness or travel. Prayer is made facing the Kaaba, a shrine in Mecca held to have been constructed by Abraham. Prior to praying, a Muslim is required to perform a ritual cleansing, or ablution called Wudu. Each prayer consists of a series of prostrations and is divided into a number of sections called Raka'ah. Each Raka'ah includes recitations from the Qur'an including Al-Fatihah, the first Sura. Prayers are made during the dawn, early afternoon, late afternoon, evening, and night-time and are of prescribed lengths. The dawn prayer is 2 Raka'ah, the early afternoon and late afternoon prayers are 4 Raka'ah, the evening prayer is 3 Raka'ah, and the night-time prayer is 4 Raka'ah.
  • Zakat: Giving alms, done by all who can afford it. Typically, a Muslim gives 2.5% of their accumulated wealth (or savings) to charities, often organized through local mosques.
  • Sawm: Fasting during the month of Ramadan. During this month, which rotates throughout the year due to the fact that the Islamic calendar is lunar, Muslims must abstain from food, drink (including water), smoking, and sexual intercourse from sunrise (specifically when a thread of light can be discerned from the darkness) to sunset. The goal of the fast, as with most ascetic pursuits, is to rid oneself of material concerns and to bring oneself closer to God. Women who are pregnant or menstruating, those who are ill or elderly, and pre-pubescent children are exempt from the need to fast. Said fasting has the lovely effects of increasing crime, health problems, and driving accidents.
  • Hajj: A pilgrimage to the holy cities of Mecca and Medina during the month of Dhul-Hijah. Muslims are required to circumambulate the Kaaba, walk seven times between the hills of Safa and Marwah (where Hagar searched for water for her baby Ishmael), travel to Mt. Arafat (where Muhammad delivered his Farewell Sermon), and symbolically stone the devil.

[edit] Social mores

Muslims also adhere to a number of dietary and behavioral rules, including prohibitions on eating pork and consuming alcohol, and maintaining certain standards of cleanliness.

A related concept is Taqiyya, an allowance for Muslims to conceal their religious beliefs during times of persecution, such as the Spanish Inquisition, though it has also been practiced by Shia facing persecution at the hands of Sunni Muslims. Some non-Muslims believe that it really means that you can pretend to have peaceful viewpoints while secretly harboring extremist ones. This has unfortunately been used to validate persecution of Muslims by Islamophobes.

Making images depicting God's creations is seen as a form of idolatry and as such is strictly forbidden by certain Hadith, as well as the Ten Commandments. Hence traditional Islamic art very rarely depicts people, and seldom animals, but focuses instead on geometric patterns, calligraphy and non-pictorial decoration. Not all Muslims believe this due to varying interpretations of the Hadith, while some believe only making 3D models is haram. The vast majority of devout Muslims hold images of the prophet Muhammad to be particularly blasphemous.

Some Muslims, mostly Salafi, believe it is forbidden to play or listen to musical instruments, due to it being a "distraction" or supposedly "Satanic" noises made by instruments. [8] They base this on a hadith, though the hadith's authenticity is widely disputed by Muslim scholars, as is the interpretation. Many believe music with instruments is okay as long as it's not mixed with lewd content. [9] Despite the common viewpoint against it, listening to music with instruments is widely accepted in Islamic countries, even Saudi Arabia to a certain extent. (well, it's not illegal).

[edit] Islam, politics and Arab identity

The fact that Islam arose in the Arabian peninsula and that translations of the Qu'ran are considered to be less faithful than the original Arabic text means that Islam has become largely associated with Arabic culture. This association can lead to nationalistic tendencies within the Arab world being blended with, and indeed disguised as, expressions of Islamic faith; believers are duped, with the promise of a glorious martyrdom, into serving nationalist causes, often violently. This is consistently demonstrated by Al Qaeda and other militant groups; a fundamental reason for their existence is to protest perceived imperialism and aggression by Western governments in the Middle East. Seen as particularly offensive is Western support for the nation of Israel, and to a lesser degree, other non-democratic, secular, corrupt, and oppressive regimes in oil-rich nations, especially pre-revolutionary Iran. Al Qaeda made no objection to the non-democratic and oppressive, but Sharia-based, regime of the Taliban in Afghanistan.

This philosophy has translated even to non-Arab Muslim extremists, such as those active in Kashmir, southeast Asia, and sub-Saharan Africa. Almost invariably, statements from "Islamic militants" are in Arabic, regardless of their background. Perhaps because of this, being "Muslim" is often viewed as no different from being "Arab" in the mindsets of many people throughout the (non-Arab) world despite the fact that the largest Muslim populations in the world are not ethnically Arabs. Interestingly, Heinrich Himmler of the Nazi SS was a supporter of Islam -- particularly extreme Islam as he thought it engendered a warrior spirit -- and he recruited Bosnian Muslims, Arabs, and Indians into the 'racially pure' SS.

Since Mohammad's day Islam retains a strong element of tribalism, particularly the use of loyalty oaths to living persons.

[edit] Islamic law and statehood

An increasing number of nations[10] use Islamic law as the entire or partial basis of their legal systems; states governed entirely by religion in this way are known as theocracies. Indonesia is the world's largest Muslim-majority country.[11] Islamic theocracies such as Saudi Arabia and Iran have been sharply criticized by human-rights advocates for their illiberal treatment of women, homosexuals, and apostates.

Sharia is Islamic law, based on the teachings of the Qu'ran and other texts regarded as sacred, such as the hadith. Most Sharia deals with aspects of the social contract, though treatment of crime and punishment is also covered. Interpretations of Sharia vary widely, and some of the stricter variants, enforced in the fundamentalist Islamic states of the Middle East can involve brutal punishments for crimes such as sodomy (homosexuality), adultery and fornication (premarital sex). In some countries, including Pakistan and Saudi Arabia, victims of rape have been punished as adulterers or fornicators when they have been unable to prove rape charges.

Muslims also follow rulings from various schools of Islamic jurisprudence called fatwas. Though the term fatwa has come to be synonymous with declarations of war by some extremists within Islam (leading to a certain amount of envy from fundamentalist Christians who wish they could pronounce death sentences on anyone they dislike), a fatwa can be issued by Islamic scholars on issues as simple as questions regarding conduct in daily life. Fatwas are not legally enforced and can be simply refuting another fatwa or Islamic viewpoint.

[edit] Jihad: Crusade and/or Puritanism

Another commonly misunderstood term is "Jihad" which has come to be synonymous with the concept of war waged by Muslims against the West. Historically, Jihad has had two meanings. The greater Jihad is the struggle to improve one's self and one's society and to be a better Muslim. The lesser Jihad is the struggle to defend Islam and one's home against aggression. In this sense, the term jihad is similar to the English word "crusade", which can refer to any noble or altruistic endeavor, or it can mean, well, Crusade.

[edit] Treatment of nonMuslims

Historically, some Islamic states required that Jews and Christians pay the jizya, a tax levied exclusively against non-Muslims which was of a higher amount than zakat.[12][13]

The free practice of religion in Muslim countries is a source of controversy. The Qur'an guarantees the free practice of religion for Jews and Christians (although adherents to these religions are expected to pay tribute and to acknowledge Muslim rule if in certain Islamic states). Regardless the reality is sometimes quite the opposite. In some countries, such as Saudi Arabia, other religions are banned from open practice and apostasy can be a capital offense. Other states, such as Iran, nominally allow other religions to exist, though those religions (including the Ba'hai and Zoroastrian faiths) are typically persecuted. Some states including Egypt, Turkey, Indonesia, and Pakistan have significant non-Muslim minorities which are treated with varying degrees of persecution, though the rise of fundamentalism in these countries has led to an increase in outbreaks of violence.

[edit] Critics and criticism

[edit] Anti-free speech

The most famous recent case of free expression vs. the right to murder people you disagree with religious values is that of the Charlie Hebdo massacre, which echoed the controversy regarding the Danish cartoons, only with a considerably higher body count. Both instances involved unflattering depictions of Muhammed, which violates Islamic teachings regarding both blasphemy and idolatry.

Salman Rushdie's 1988 novel The Satanic Verses provoked outrage among many Muslims. The book was banned in India and protests in which the book was burned were held in London, England. Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini, then-Supreme Leader of Iran, issued a fatwa against Rushdie, calling on all good Muslims everywhere to do their best to kill him. Guess what? He had to go into hiding too. Even worse, governments that should know better, like the UK and the US, shunned him instead of coming to his aid and defending his right to free speech.

This event inspired the late noted journalist Christopher Hitchens to examine closely the Western Left's lackadaisical attitude towards Islamic extremism. The sympathy which he perceived among his colleagues for Islamic extremism caused him to adopt a firmer stance against what he calls "Islamofascism", or "Fascism with an Islamic face". This has become the criticism named, regressive left.

[edit] Antifeminism

Islam is decidedly antifeminist, against all attempts to argue that it "supports" women.[14]

Perhaps the most obvious point here is the forced wearing of the burqa and sister garments by many in the Middle East. These women must dress in a conservative fashion at all times to avoid anger from Muslim fundamentalists.

However, there are open feminists who are practicing and devout Muslims, such as Amina Wudud and Irshad Manji.

[edit] Homophobia

Homosexuals are severely punished in Islamic states such as Iran or Saudi Arabia (except that Iran doesn't have any). Punishments can include flogging, beatings, mutilation of the genitals, and in some cases, execution. Gays being thrown off roofs and then stoned (not in the good way) is the common punishment in ISIS-controlled parts of Syria and Iraq.

[edit] Children's Treatment in Religious Schools

This is a notable problem in certain Islamic regions. This has been known to even take place in certain madrassas (religious schools) in the United Kingdom. [15][16]

[edit] Sharia as applying to non-Muslims

The notion that non-Muslims should also be subject to Islamic jurisprudence is a key tenet of Islamism, and both instances brought Islamists scurrying out of the woodwork. Such individuals, like any religious fanatics, lack a sense of humor, and provoked a seemingly endless and quite unnecessary series of debates across the Western world. Should we allow this? Well, we allow jokes about Christians and Jews? Why not? Should we exercise restraint when using our right to freedom of speech? Are we refusing to show the cartoons on national news because we don't want to offend Muslims, or because we're scared of offending Muslims? The answer to those questions, in order, is: Yes, Yes, and the news networks were scared of being blown up or something equally horrid. In our eyes, the cartoons' only real crime were being unfunny. And no violence is needed to make that point. Yet the extremist Muslim position survives and thrives in the latest South Park episode which parent companies Comedy Central and Viacom heavily censored in order not to offend the already infantilized sensibilities of many Muslims. Appropriately for South Park, however, the images of Muhammad were so cartoonishly over-censored (especially Kyle's speech at the end, of which only a few words—mostly pronouns and conjunctions—can be heard) that the censorship itself has the feeling of satire.

People can be assaulted or even murdered because a militant Muslim or lynch mob believes they have broken Sharia in some way.[17] In Bangladesh 3,000 people have been arrested following attacks and killing of atheist and other bloggers. As of June 2016 it is unclear whether this will make a difference.[18]

[edit] Promotion of creationism and pseudoscience

The Qur'an in several places concurs with the outline of the Creation story in Genesis. Specifically, Adam is taken to be the first human, formed by God in an act of creation out of clay. Unlike the Bible, the Qur'an explicitly claims to be the actual word of God, and so it is unusual for Muslims to believe that the Qur'an contains errors. However, the Islamic text is somewhat vaguer than Genesis, leaving some room for interpretation, and it is not impossible to find Muslims who accept evolution as fact.

Many Muslims (such as Liberal Muslims) are theistic evolutionists and support the idea that Muslim religious teachings are compatible with evolution. For example, Shaikh Nuh Ha Mim Keller, an American Muslim and specialist in Islamic law has argued in Islam and Evolution that a belief in macroevolution is not incompatible with Islam, as long as it is accepted that "God is the Creator of everything" (Qur'an 13:16) and that God specifically created humanity (in the person of Adam; Qur'an 38:71-76).[19] However other Muslims feel that evolution contradicts Muslim teachings and take a position similar to the position of Christian creationists.

In modern times, anti-science attitudes are a serious problem in some Islamic states; although creationism is more usually associated with fundamentalist Christianity. While some Muslims, such as Zakir Naik, tacitly promote creationism and pseduoscience by defending the inaccuracy of the Qur'an, people like Harun Yahya actively promote creationism and pseudoscience and attack evolution.

By contrast, medieval Islam was at least relatively pro-science, with early scientists such as Ibn al-Haytham and Avicenna[wp] significantly advancing their fields and paving the way for similar movements in Europe in the centuries to follow.[20]

[edit] Ayaan Hirsi Ali

  • Ayaan Hirsi Ali is a former Muslim, victim of female genital mutilation, and prominent feminist and critic of Islam. Until her mid-teens, she obeyed the stricter codes of Islam before gradually adopting more liberal positions. She supported the fatwa against Salman Rushdie during her fundamentalist years, but as she studied the Western philosophers of the Enlightenment upon her escape to the Netherlands, her stance became more open-minded, to the point where she is now a staunch supporter of everyone's right to freedom of expression. In 2004, she wrote the screenplay for the short film Submission, a film examining the treatment of women in Islam. On November 2, Theo van Gogh, the director of the film, was murdered by Muslim extremist Mohammed Bouyeri. A dagger stabbed into Van Gogh pinned a note to the body attributing the assassination to the film. Ali was forced into hiding, and to this day is not able to appear in public without armed guards.

[edit] Islamophobia

See the main article on this topic: Islamophobia

Islamophobia is a form of bigotry defined as "an irrational fear of Islam or Muslims." The term is controversial, with some arguing that it is a label used to delegitimize and silence criticism of the religion or of governments in the Middle East, and others saying it describes the pattern of fear-mongering and ignorance that leads to hate crimes against minorities and the restriction of their rights.

[edit] See also

[edit] External links

Academic resources
Online resources

[edit] Notes

  1. Islam's god is the same Abrahamic god as the one in Judaism and Christianity; Allah is merely the Arabic word for 'God'. It should be noted that it is considered blasphemy for Allah to be placed in a human or animal sexual gender category; see Qur'an 112:3-4.
  2. This is the shortest version of the Shahadah and is translated from the Arabic phrase لَا إِلٰهَ إِلَّا الله مُحَمَّدٌ رَسُولُ الله

[edit] Footnotes

  1. Butterworth, Charles E. (1992). The Political Aspects of Islamic Philosophy. Harvard University Press. ISBN 9780932885074
  3. religions retrieved 7 June 2013
  4. world factbook; religions
  5. Death to the apostate!
  6. Pakistan death penalty law
  7. Apostasy killing in Saudi Arabia
  11. Islam in Indonesia: Contrasting Images and Interpretations, p 68, ‎Kees van Dijk - 2013
  12. A. Ben Shemesh, Taxation in Islam Volume II, Qudama b. Ja'far's Kitab Al-Kharaj. Leiden, E.J. Brill, 1965, p. 14
  13. K.S. Lal, Theory and Practice of Muslim State in India, Delhi, 1999, pp. 139-140.
  14. "Muslim Feminism Destroyed In 2 Minutes" uploaded by IntrovertedSmiles on May 1, 2016
  17. Man Is Attacked With Machetes By Muslim Boys Who Were Upset He Wasn’t Fasting
  18. Bangladeshi Police Arrest More Than 3,000 People To Prevent Further Attacks on Atheists and Others
  20. Science and Islam, three-part BBC documentary
Personal tools