| Potentially edible!|
Maholtra's views on diet and health have been criticized by the British Heart Foundation as "misleading and wrong" and his criticisms of statins have been described as dangerous to public health. One critic noted that Malhotra's "interpretation of the Pioppi Diet does not reflect what the people of Pioppi eat. It is basically an ultra-low carb version of the Mediterranean diet with a few trendy ingredients, such as coconut oil, thrown in."
Malhotra advises people to eat more saturated fat and recommends that obese people need not bother exercising. Do You Believe That? In 2015, Malhotra co-authored a short editorial with Tim Noakes that claimed "physical activity does not promote weight loss", a dubious opinion that was unsupported by scientific evidence. The poorly referenced editorial became a national news story.
According to Anthony Warner:
Although Malhotra is largely associated with sugar shaming, his lack of understanding of science runs far deeper than that. For many years he has latched on to deluded conspiracy theorists everywhere, cosying up to Angry Chef's favourite Candida quack Zoe Harcombe, and even retweeting articles by the repugnant, anti-vax, bullshit-monger Dr Mercola, a man who claims to be able to cure autism with supplements, and has been repeatedly fined by the FDA in America for making unsubstantiated claims for the products he sells.
In 2017, Malhotra and colleagues published an article which disputed the link between blood cholesterol levels and occurrence of heart disease. The authors also suggested that "stopping statins may paradoxically save more lives". The article was criticized by the medical community. Cardiologist Tim Chico commented that "high cholesterol has been proven beyond all doubt to contribute to coronary artery disease and heart attack […] to say the cholesterol hypothesis is dead is simply incorrect."
In 2017, Malhotra published an editorial with a controversial title "saturated fat does not clog the arteries". Malhotra and colleagues suggested that "coronary artery disease is a chronic inflammatory disease and it can be reduced effectively by walking 22 min a day and eating real food." This opinion was widely criticized by the medical community. Honorary consultant cardiologist Amitava Banerjee commented that editorial was selective and "failed to cite a rigorous Cochrane systematic review which concluded that cutting down dietary saturated fat was associated with a 17% reduction in cardiovascular events including coronary heart disease on the basis of 15 randomised trials."
Criticism of The Lancet
Malhotra has criticized The Lancet, the world's oldest, most prestigious, and best known medical journals.
The EAT–Lancet Commission, a 3-year project that brings together 37 experts from 16 countries led by The Lancet in 2019 released research on January 16 that argued dieting and food production will need to change in order to improve health and avoid damage to the planet.
For health purposes their research suggested for people to cut down on the daily consumption of red meat. Malhotra took offense to this and criticized the journal as "incompetent". He also wrote to the present editor-in-chief of The Lancet on Twitter, "Can you please justify to medics, journalists and the public why we should continue to consider @TheLancet as a credible journal?"
- Mellor, Duane. (2017). "Dietitians like me don't take the Pioppi Diet seriously". The Spectator. Retrieved January 10, 2019.
- Snowdon, Christopher. (2017). "The Pioppi Diet is a superficial lifestyle guide based on distorted evidence". The Spectator. Retrieved January 10, 2019.
- O'Connor, Anahad. (2016). "An Unconventional Cardiologist Promotes a High-Fat Diet". The New York Times. Retrieved January 10, 2019.
- Boseley, S. (2018). "Butter nonsense: the rise of the cholesterol deniers". The Guardian.
- The dodgy science behind the claim that exercise doesn’t help you lose weight
- ‘I stopped exercising and lost weight’
- The Most Powerful Chef in The Universe
- Demasi, M; Lustig R. H; Malhotra A. (2017). "The cholesterol and calorie hypotheses are both dead — it is time to focus on the real culprit: insulin resistance". The Pharmaceutical Journal doi:10.1211/CP.2017.20203046.
- Expert reaction to new report on statins and the cholesterol hypothesis
- Saturated fat does not clog the arteries: coronary heart disease is a chronic inflammatory condition, the risk of which can be effectively reduced from healthy lifestyle interventions.
- Expert reaction to editorial on saturated fat and heart disease
- Food in the Anthropocene: the EAT–Lancet Commission on healthy diets from sustainable food systems
- Expert reaction to the EAT–Lancet Commission report on healthy diets from sustainable food systems’
- The Lancet: Diet and food production must radically change to improve health and avoid potentially catastrophic damage to the planet
- Planetary health diet: Developed countries must cut red meat eating by 80% to protect Earth
- Dr Aseem Malhotra on Twitter
- Dr Aseem Malhotra on Twitter