RationalWiki's 2018 Fundraiser

There is no RationalWiki without you. We are a small non-profit with no staff — we are hundreds of volunteers who document pseudoscience and crankery around the world every day. We will never allow ads because we must remain independent. We cannot rely on big donors with corresponding big agendas. We are not the largest website around, but we believe we play an important role in defending truth and objectivity.

If everyone seeing this today donates $5, we will meet our goal for 2018.

Fighting pseudoscience isn't free.
We are 100% user-supported! Help and donate $5, $20 or whatever you can today with PayPal Logo.png!

Donations so far: $2951Goal: $5000
Bronze-level article

Bielefeld conspiracy

From RationalWiki
Jump to: navigation, search
Some dare call it
Conspiracy
Icon conspiracy.svg
What THEY don't want
you to know!
Sheeple wakers

The Bielefeld conspiracy (German: Bielefeldverschwörung) is a German spoof of conspiracy theories.[1] It asserts that the city of Bielefeld does not exist.

It is a popular meme in German-speaking countries and has broken beyond the confines of the internet.

Despite (or because of) its absurdity, it has achieved popularity by being a classic model of a conspiracy theory, as well as giving a rather unloved city an undeserved kicking.

Reality[edit]

An obviously mocked-up image of a non-descript bit of the city that doesn't exist.

Bielefeld is a city in the north-western German state of North Rhine-Westphalia with a population of 330,000.[2] The state of North Rhine-Westphalia is the most populous German state, incorporating the industrial Ruhr area, but Bielefeld is something of an island, isolated from other towns and cities. Bielefeld is also the biggest city in the region of Eastern Westphalia, or as it is known in German Ost-Westfalen, a patently absurd name.

Heavily bombed in World War II, the city was rebuilt, with anodyne modern buildings replacing the destroyed historic buildings.[3] The industry in the city, once identified with the linen trade, has diversified to such an extent that it is hard to connect the city with any product or company.

Simply because it doesn't stand out in any way, despite being a sizeable city, Bielefeld became the target for the spoof. Alledgedly at the time the hoax was created there were no members identifying as being from Bielefeld in the Usenet group that came up with this. Soon thereafter a member of said group noticed the name "Bielefeld" being crossed out on an Autobahn sign due to roadwork and one thing led to another.

Conspiracy[edit]

The Bielefeld conspiracy originated as a joke in a Usenet post. It posits the existence of a shadowy organisation, referred to only as "THEY", that wants to propagate the existence of the city.

Why they should want to do this is unclear. Fortunately, the existence of the conspiracy is rather more important than any actual rational reason for it. Possible reasons for the conspiracy include:

In short, an exaggerated mix of the usual suspects. If the theory were to be invented today, no doubt it would be to hide the existence of a FEMA concentration camp in Germany.

"But I've been there"[edit]

This is a common assertion to try to refute the Bielefeld conspiracy. However, like any good conspiracy theory, such simple arguments do not hold water. Simple refutations generally involve such points:

  • Bielefeld railway station is a major interchange in the region. It is also on the edge of the city, and travellers see nothing more than a few buildings. Most people who have "been" to Bielefeld have only changed trains there, which is hardly evidence of the city.
  • The stadium of the football club Arminia Bielefeld is also out of town. It is possible to travel to "Bielefeld", see a football match and go home without actually seeing the city. Arminia Bielefeld is actually perceived as a clever move on behalf of the conspiracy to make the existence of the city seem plausible.
  • A few years ago, there were roadworks on the Autobahn to Bielefeld, involving diversions. After going through the diversions, there is no good reason to suppose that you actually have arrived in Bielefeld.

Another tactic of sceptics is to point out evidence such as the city's website. However, the carefully cropped and otherwise anonymous photos could actually belong to any city. Similar, but more unkind, comments could be applied to the University of Bielefeld.

Telephone numbers and postcodes for Bielefeld are proof that the Telekom and Post are part of the conspiracy.

Ultimately, anybody who can provide more convincing evidence of the existence of the city (e.g. being born there) can safely be dismissed as delusional, a dupe or part of the conspiracy itself.

Impact[edit]

Well, it's just for lulz really. Bielefeld council and tourist service have got pretty bored with the "you don't exist" letters and emails, suggesting that the joke is past its best.

That said, as an amusing educational device, it has some merit. Its absurd proposition and painful logic is no different to any other conspiracy theories you might care to mention. Indeed, it serves as a template for any number of similar conspiracies.

Footnotes[edit]

  1. The Bielefeld conspiracy was invented by Achim Held. His description of the conspiracy is available in German [1]. This page contains a summary of the contents, with additional information as necessary.
  2. http://www.bielefeld.de/en/index.html
  3. http://www.bielefeld.de/en/ti1/history/ — more information on this subject on the German version of the page.