Yemeni Civil War

From RationalWiki
Jump to: navigation, search
Saudi warplanes, part of the ongoing bombing campaign against Yemeni civilians.
It never changes
War
Icon war2.svg
A view to kill

The Yemeni Civil War is, unsurprisingly, an ongoing civil war being fought in Yemen. There are two primary factions involved: the HouthisWikipedia's W.svg supported by Iran, and the internationally-recognized government of President Abdrabbuh Mansour Hadi.Wikipedia's W.svg[1]

Since March 2015, the conflict has resulted in more than 6,800 deaths and 35,000 injuries, most of them caused by airstrikes on densely-populated civilian areas from the Saudi-led coalition in support of the president.[1][2] The Saudi coalition has also imposed a blockade on all but one of Yemen's ports, although this one port city is now the scene of a furious battle.[3] The blockade has resulted in a famine that threatens 13 million people and may become the deadliest in a century.[4]

The players[edit]

Houthi supporters rally in Sana'a.

The Houthis[edit]

Although not all of the rebels are Shiites, the Houthi movement is primarily adherent to the Zaidi sect of Shiite Islam which makes up the majority of Yemen's population and is notable for its theological similarities to Sunni Islam.[5] The movement is also fiercely anti-Western and is opposed to Saudi Arabia and the Gulf States.[6]

However, the root of this conflict cannot be found solely in sectarianism. The Saudi-backed president of Yemen is himself a Zaidi Muslim, as is much of his government's loyalist army.[7] In fact, the conflict seems to be largely political in origin with Yemen's large amount of poverty and economic inequality, and the government's 2014 policy which spiked fuel prices by between 60 and 90%.[8][9]

The Houthis were originally a religiously-affiliated resistance movement against Yemen's tyrannical dictator Ali Abdullah Saleh,Wikipedia's W.svg and they were angry at the Saudis and the United States for supporting him.[10] The American invasion of Iraq in 2003 radicalized them and drove them to seek closer ties with and aid from their ideological brothers Hezbollah.[10]

In 2011, the Houthis were part of the coalition which brought down Yemen's dictator during the Arab Spring; when Saleh was replaced by Sunni President Haidi (who was seen by many in Yemen as a Saudi yes-man), the Houthis were furious and felt that their efforts had backfired.[10] In the wake of this regime change, the Yemeni government, with international assistance, came up with a new federal system whereupon six autonomous provinces would represent the nation's religious and tribal divisions.[10] The Zaidi north got two provinces, both of which were landlocked, and which the Houthis believed were gerrymandered against them.[10] This anger led them to reverse their alliances and collaborate with Yemen's ex-dictator Saleh to overthrow President Haidi's government.[10]

Saudi Arabia and the Gulf States believe and have levied accusations that the Houthis are proxies of Iran.[11] While the Houthis are certainly friendly with Iran[12] and have been receiving a certain amount of smuggled military aid[13] the Houthis are solely concerned with their domestic agenda and have no interest in being a pawn in Iran's squabble with the Saudis.[14] The clearest indicator that Iran does not control the Houthis' decision-making came when they completely ignored Iran's advice to avoid escalating the war by taking Sana'a.[14]

Saudis and pals[edit]

Aftermath of Saudi airstrikes in Sana'a.

Saudi Arabia began a military buildup along its border the moment the Houthi coup began, and the Houthis responded by boasting that they would retaliate against any Saudi aggression by invading the country and not stopping until they've taken the Saudi capital of Riyadh.[15] The Saudis began justifying intervention in Yemen on the (then baseless) claim that the Houthis were an Iranian proxy planning to turn Yemen into a Shiite terror state and attack Saudi Arabia.[16] President Haidi then went to the United Nations Security Council to ask for support for military action by "willing countries" against the Houthis.[17]

The military intervention by "willing countries" materialized when the Saudis assembled a coalition to launch a campaign of airstrikes in March 2015 after the Houthis and their allies began to advance south towards Aden.Wikipedia's W.svg The main coalition members[18][19] are the Saudis, the United Arab Emirates, Bahrain, Kuwait, Qatar (previously), Egypt, Jordan, Morocco, Sudan, and Senegal, although they have both direct and indirect support from the United States and the United Kingdom.[20] Warplanes from the main coalition members have taken part in the air campaign, and bombing continues even after the Saudis announced that their campaign had achieved its goals.[21] Saudi Arabia has allegedly also deployed special forces on the ground in Yemen to train loyalist fighters and guide the anti-Houthi resistance[22] although the kingdom has claimed that it has no "formal" troops there.[23]

Support from the United States is essential to the continuation of the coalition's bombing campaign. The US provides aerial refueling that allows Saudi bombers to run longer missions, provides intelligence and logistical support, and provides weaponry including heavy bombs and air-to-ground missiles.[24] The MK-82 bomb which slaughtered 40 children on a schoolbus in 2018 was manufactured by General Dynamics in Texas [25] Meanwhile US and British officials have access to the Saudi command center as well as a complete list of targets.[26] In October 2016, the US directly attacked Houthis in Yemen for the first time, attacking rebel held radar sites in retaliation for an attempt to sink a US destroyer with anti-ship missiles (what, you thought this was goat-herders vs. stealth bombers?)[27]

Unfortunately, support from the United States for its most embarrassing ally's hideous war is unlikely to end anytime soon. President Trump in April 2019 vetoed a resolution passed by Congress which would have called on him to end US military involvement.[28] Trump claimed the resolution was " an unnecessary, dangerous attempt to weaken [his] constitutional authorities".[28]

Coup in Yemen, war begins[edit]

President (?) Haidi

Unhappy with Yemen's proposed six-region federal structure as detailed above, the Houthis invaded Yemen's capital Sana'a in early 2015 and took President Haidi hostage inside his own residence.[29] They promised to withdraw from the presidential palace in exchange for an agreement which would give them greater influence over the government and the ability to appoint officials.[29] However, the increasingly violent situation in Sana'a prompted the Cabinet and the President to resign their posts.[30] With the country in political limbo, the Houthis forcibly dissolved Yemen's parliament and announced that they were putting together an interim ruling committee to manage the nation's affairs.[31] This completed the coup and left the Houthis in charge of Yemen.

However, roughly a month later, President Haidi managed to escape house arrest and delivered a televised speech declaring that the Houthi takeover was illegitimate and that Haidi was still the rightful president of Yemen.[32] Meanwhile, Saleh, his predecessor as the dictator of Yemen, accused Haidi of destroying Yemen and demanded that he go into exile.[33] The situation finally turned violent when a part of Yemen's military still loyal to Saleh invaded the city of Aden, where Haidi was based, and sent planes to bomb the building he was using as his presidential residence.[34] After yet more violent clashes, the Houthis announced that they were going to invade southern Yemen to defeat Haidi, who they also accused of being affiliated with Al-Qaeda.[35]

Humanitarian crisis[edit]

As of late August 2018, the civilian death toll of the war is estimated by the UN to be almost 7,000, although the report concedes that the true figure is probably far higher.[36]

Coalition war crimes[edit]

Both the coalition has committed war crimes.[19] The Saudi coalition has assembled an investigative body, the Joint Incidents Assessment Team (JIAT), to look into incidents of war crimes and attempt to provide redress to victimized civilians.[37] Since the coalition is thus essentially investigating itself, it should come as no surprise that the JIAT true role seems to be organizing and executing coverups.[37] Coalition airstrikes meanwhile, are directed not only at military targets but at funerals, schools, markets, residential areas, and civilian watercraft.[38] One particularly egregious example came in mid-2018 when a Saudi plane bombed a school bus, killing 40 children and 11 adults.[39] The coalition has used cluster munitionsWikipedia's W.svg supplied by the United States in civilian areas. Cluster munitions are banned by 118 countries; however, Saudi Arabia, US and Yemen are not among them.[40]

Yemeni children wait for water shipments.

Coalition blockade[edit]

The Saudi coalition has also maintained a naval and air blockade against Yemen under the pretense that they're upholding a UN-imposed arms embargo against the Houthis.[38] However, the coalition ships are not only preventing weapons from reaching Houthi-controlled areas, but water and food and medicine as well.[41] This is a clear indicator that Saudi Arabia's strategy in Yemen is now based on strangling Houthi-controlled Yemen of all supplies necessary for human life, critically endangering not just their foes but civilians as well.[41]

Yemen was already heavily dependent on food imports and food aid before the war, and now more than 22 million Yemeni civilians are in desperate straits.[42] The blockade and the resulting famine have also exacerbated a cholera epidemic which began sweeping through the nation in 2017.[43] As of November 2017, more than 16 million people were already without access to clean water.[44] Almost every child in Yemen is malnourished and in need of food aid.[45]

Houthi war crimes[edit]

Despite what is explained above, it's not like the Houthis have clean assholes on the issue of war crimes either. They're guilty of firing wide-area munitions indiscriminately into civilian areas.[38] They are also recruiting and using child soldiers on the front lines.[38] The UN also alleges that the Houthis have been using snipers to kill women and children leaving their homes to fetch essential supplies.[46] Refugees are wary of returning to their homes as the Houthis have been allegedly planting landmines in civilian areas during their retreats from coalition forces.[47]

The Houthis have also been firing rockets indiscriminately into Saudi Arabia.[48]

See also[edit]

Further reading[edit]

References[edit]

  1. 1.0 1.1 Yemen crisis: Who is fighting whom?, BBC News
  2. Yemen: Bloody trail of civilian death and destruction paved with evidence of war crimes Amnesty Press Amnesty International. 18 August 2015
  3. Saudi Arabia And Its Allies Strike Yemen's Main Port City Domonoske, Camila. NPR. June 13, 2018
  4. Yemen on brink of 'world's worst famine in 100 years' if war continues Summers, Hannah. The Guardian. 15 Oct 2018
  5. Debunking Media Myths About the Houthis in War-Torn Yemen Global Voices. 1 April 2015
  6. As the Houthis Rise in Yemen, it is Worth Remembering that Zaydi Islam Was Not Historically Radical Arab News Blog. January 22nd, 2015
  7. Yemen's Scorched Earth Campaign: A Word About Zaydism Middle East Institute: Editor's Blog, August 24, 2009.
  8. It's not a Sunni- Shi’a Conflict, dummy! Woman from Yemen, blog. January 28, 2015
  9. Yemen protests erupt after fuel price doubled Al Jazeera. 30 Jul 2014
  10. 10.0 10.1 10.2 10.3 10.4 10.5 Who are the Houthis, and why are we at war with them? Bruce Riedel, Brookings Institute. December 18, 2017
  11. Yemen crisis: Why is there a war? BBC.
  12. Yemen war: Who are the Houthis and why is Saudi Arabia fighting them? The Independent. 10 November 2018
  13. Exclusive: Iran steps up weapons supply to Yemen's Houthis via Oman - officials Yara Bayoumy, Phil Stewart. Reuters. Oct 20, 2016
  14. 14.0 14.1 The Houthis Are Not Hezbollah Joost Hiltermann and April Longley Alley. Foreign Policy. Feb 27, 2017
  15. Yemen’s Houthi Militants Extend Push Southward Hakim Almasmari. Wall Street Journal. March 24, 2015.
  16. If Yemen's Houthis weren't Iranian proxies before, they could be soon Snyder, Stephen. Public Radio International. March 25, 2017
  17. Yemen's President Hadi asks UN to back intervention BBC News. 25 March 2015
  18. See the Wikipedia article on Saudi Arabian-led intervention in Yemen.
  19. 19.0 19.1 Yemen: Events of 2015, reliefweb
  20. British support of Saudi Arabian military should shame us all, says SNP MP Iain Smith. The Herald. 27th November 2017
  21. Yemen conflict: Saudis launch new air strikes on rebels BBC News. 23 April 2015
  22. Saudi special forces help oppose Houthi rebels in Yemen Nic Robertson and Hakim Almasmari. CNN. April 3, 2015
  23. Saudi-led airstrikes drive Houthis from Aden Al Jazeera. 3 Apr 2015
  24. Obama Could End The Slaughter In Yemen Within Hours Huffington Post. Akbar Shahid Ahmed. 10/08/2016
  25. The bomb that killed 40 children on a school bus in Yemen last week was manufactured in the US, and the strike executed according to British targeting processes., Amity Underground
  26. British and US military 'in command room' for Saudi strikes on Yemen Emma Graham-Harrison. The Guardian. 15 Jan 2016
  27. U.S. Enters Yemen War Directly for the First Time With Attack on Houthis, The Intercept
  28. 28.0 28.1 Trump vetoes measure ending US support for Saudi-led war in Yemen The Hill. 04.16.19
  29. 29.0 29.1 Instability in Yemen: Held hostage The Economist. Jan 24th 2015. Archived.
  30. Cabinet and Haidi Resign Ahlam Mohsen and Ali Ibrahim Al-Moshki. Yemen Times. 22 January 2015. Archived.
  31. Yemen's Houthis dissolve parliament, assume power: televised statement Mohammed Ghobari. Reuters. Feb 6, 2015.
  32. Yemen's Hadi declares Houthi power grab illegal Al Jazeera. 21 Feb 2015
  33. Ex-Yemen leader asks President Hadi to go into exile Al Jazeera. 10 Mar 2015. Archived.
  34. Warplanes Bomb Presidential Palace In Yemen's Aden Hendawi, Hamza. Huffington Post. 03/19/2015. Archived.
  35. Southerners prepare for Houthi invasion. Khalid Al-Karimi. Yemen Times. 23 March 2015. Archived.
  36. Yemen: United Nations Experts point to possible war crimes by parties to the conflict United Nations Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights. 28 August 2018
  37. 37.0 37.1 Yemen: Coalition Fails to Curb Violations Human Rights Watch. August 24, 2018
  38. 38.0 38.1 38.2 38.3 YEMEN 2017/2018 Amnesty International.
  39. Yemen school bus bombing 'one of 50 strikes on civilian vehicles this year Julian Borger and Saeed Kamali Dehghan. The Guardian. 16 Aug 2018
  40. Yemen: Cluster Munitions Wounding Civilians Human Rights Watchs
  41. 41.0 41.1 Yemen: Coalition Blockade Imperils Civilians Human Rights Watch. December 7, 2017.
  42. The Yemen Civil War and Saudi Arabia’s Unlawful Blockade Kefi, Dalya. Human Rights Brief. April 5, 2018
  43. How the Saudis Turned the Yemen War Into a Humanitarian Crisis Glen Carey and Sarah Algethami. Bloomberg. October 19, 2018
  44. Millions of Yemenis days away from losing clean running water Reliefweb. 25 Nov 2017
  45. UNICEF press conference: Geert Cappelaere, Regional Director for the Middle East and North Africa, on the humanitarian situation of children in Yemen UNICEF. 26 November 2017
  46. Yemen conflict: UN experts detail possible war crimes by all parties BBC. 28 August 2018
  47. Fearing landmines, displaced Yemenis wary of return Ali Aboluhom & Ali Al-Moshki. Al Jazeera. 21 Aug 2015
  48. Yemen Houthi Rocket Attack Kills Two Girls in Saudi Arabia Ahmed al Omran, The Wall Street Journal, 28 August 2016.