Kashmir

From RationalWiki
Jump to: navigation, search
Kashmir region and the various zones of occupation. Note that many people in each occupation zone would prefer to be occupied by someone else.
It never changes
War
Icon war2.svg
A view to kill
"That India is on Siachen [glacier], and in control if it, is a sign that we can be a superpower."
— Lt. Col. J.S. Pundir, bragging about occupying an inhospitable and useless wasteland.

Kashmir is the northernmost region of the Indian subcontinent, where the world's first-, second-, and sixth-most populous countries are all wedged into each other. It is currently occupied by three nations. Jammu and Kashmir is controlled by India, Azad Kashmir and Gilgit-Baltistan are administered by Pakistan, and Aksai Chin and the Trans-Karakoram Tract are occupied by China.[1] Being a large and diverse region, India has several hot spots, but none is so persistent as the disputes over Kashmir.

After having spent centuries being tossed around like a football between Hindu, Muslim, and Buddhist rulers, Kashmir was annexed by the Sikhs. The Sikhs in turn came under the rule of the British Empire, becoming one of the princely states which comprised the Raj. This lasted until 1947, when the British Raj was divided between Muslim and Hindu majority areas. India and Pakistan both claimed Kashmir. The region is still disputed, and it's a big part of why India and Pakistan hate each other. Unfortunately, both countries have nuclear weapons.

A brief, sad history[edit]

Fighting over Kashmir[edit]

Siachin

When India and Pakistan won independence in 1947, Muslims and Hindus largely went their own ways into their respective countries. However, areas with religiously diverse populations had to actually pick a team. One of those princely states was called Jammu and Kashmir, which had been annexed by the British after the First Anglo-Sikh War.Wikipedia's W.svg The state's ruler, Maharajah Hari Singh, preferred to take a stab at remaining independent of both, and to this end he played the diplomacy game to bounce the big boys off of one another.[2] This didn't work out as he hoped. Kashmir's Islamic majority rose up in rebellion almost immediately, and Pakistan's Pashtun tribesmen decided to settle the issue by hopping across the border to take that shit for themselves.[3] Singh asked India to save him, and the Indians only responded on the condition that he join their country. India sent the troops, and the world got the First Kashmir War.[4] A little over a year (and five thousand corpses) later, the UN managed to mediate a truce which created a "Line of Control" between Indian and Pakistani forces.[5] Having come away with two-thirds of Kashmir, India decided they won.[6] No one claimed the Siachen glacier, because why the fuck would anyone want a useless chunk of ice at an altitude where no one can breathe? Just wait.

Fighting over Tibet[edit]

After the Chinese Civil War, Mao focused on stomping into Tibet.[7] Tibet had previously claimed part of Kashmir, called Aksai Chin, and the Chinese decided they'd like to have that bit too, thank you very much. After India granted asylum to the Dalai Lama, tensions flared,[8] and the lack of a settlement over the territory led to the Sino-Indian WarWikipedia's W.svg in 1962. After another five thousand dead people, China declared a unilateral cease-fire. India still claims Aksai Chin, but they seem prepared to accept the loss,[9] probably because Aksai Chin is an arid goddamn salt flat.[10] Just to screw them a bit more, India's two enemies signed the Sino-Pakistan Agreement.Wikipedia's W.svg where the two countries traded some land and did a high five.

Fighting over Kashmir, again[edit]

Still coveting that sweet, sweet land in Kashmir, Pakistan took a shot at sending spies and soldiers to infiltrate the Indian zone and attempt to spark a Muslim uprising.[11] This naturally sparked yet another goddamn war in the region in 1965 when India retaliated by invading the Pakistan zone. With the world powers no longer distracted by other affairs, the conflict evolved into another Cold War proxy fight between the USA and the USSR. Despite the modern American opinion of the two countries, the USA ended up supplying aid to Pakistan, which at the time was a relatively moderate Muslim state and anti-communist to boot.[12] The UN once again mandated a cease-fire. Kashmir fell back into geopolitical limbo.

Fighting over Bangladesh[edit]

In 1971, India and Pakistan decided to go for round three. This time, the war had its roots outside Kashmir. A disputed election in Pakistan resulted in East Pakistan declaring independence and calling itself Bangladesh. The war also involved the 1971 Bangladesh genocideWikipedia's W.svg where Pakistani forces slaughtered between 300,000 and 3,000,000 Bengalis and raped hundreds of thousands more. When the Bengalis asked for Indian assistance, India gladly took the chance to screw over their longtime foe by training and arming Bengali fighters. Pakistan retaliated by launching an air attack against a number of Indian airfields.[13] Fought mostly between navies and air forces, the war resulted in a military Indian victory,[14] forcing Pakistan to concede Bangladesh. Despite the loss of East Pakistan, it was not a victory for India because the Kashmir issue remained unsettled. Pakistan's leader warned the Indian diplomats that chaos and a "Versailles Syndrome" would result if India treated his country too harshly.[15] Once again, Kashmir fell into political limbo.

Fighting over a glacier[edit]

The sexiest goddamn glacier in the world, apparently.

Now the Siachen glacier enters the story. Through all of this madness, the glacier wasn't handed to either country, because again, who would want it? However, US maps put it in Pakistan's territory for convenience, and mountain climbers tended to ask their government for permission to explore.[16] However, in the late 1970s, India decided to go poking around Siachen, and Pakistan noticed. Then Pakistan shat a brick. Both countries decided that a glacier three miles high was a vital military victory point. The Pakistanis flew a permanent military garrison, and India found out when their military ordered winter clothing from the same British store where Pakistan was buying their stuff. No, really.[17] The two countries have been skirmishing over the glacier for years, but more soldiers have died from avalanches, exposure, and oxygen deprivation. The death toll is estimated to be between three and five thousand people.[18] This is all for a glacier where soldiers can't climb three feet without stopping to catch their breath due to the atmospheric conditions. This is all for a glacier where the soldiers can't touch their gun's trigger for more than a handful of seconds without risking frostbite. While the fighting has mostly stopped, both countries maintain garrisons there just in case, to an annual cost of about half a billion dollars per year.[19]

Kashmir today[edit]

Who wouldn't fight multiple wars over scenery like this?

Various insurgencies have also sprung up in Kashmir seeking a merger with Pakistan, a merger with India, and outright independence.[20] Both India and Pakistan have suffered terrorist attacks, and both nations maintain a heavy military presence in the area. Despite skirmishes and attacks continuing into the 21st Century and tens of thousands of deaths due to terrorism, relations between the countries have begun to thaw slightly, beginning with the opening of trade routes across the Line of Control.[21] Terrorism still continues to this day, with groups recruiting from the disgruntled populace.[22] Even Al-Qaeda has gotten involved.[23] Narendra Modi's government has recently opened talks with Pakistan and separatist groups as of October 2017, so hope for a settlement is now very dim but real.[24]

Of course, neither India or Pakistan will get the whole cake; they're gonna have to slice it in some fashion. Independence seems to be just another recipe for a civil war between Hindus and Muslims. That solution would also validate separatist movements across both countries, ultimately leading to more terrorism. And finally, neither India nor Pakistan can be perceived as giving too much away to the other side.

That would be bad, too.

Modi recently moved to remove Kashmir's autonomous status, part of the very agreement that led Kashmir to join India in the first place, and is currently conducting a war on India's own citizens, with numerous atrocities occurring.[25]

Insurgency[edit]

The UN implemented truce in 1948, had come with a resolution telling India to carry out a referendum in Kashmir Valley. India did not do so. In 1953, India charged the Chief Minister of Jammu and Kashmir, Sheikh Abdullah with treason and collaboration with Pakistan. The case was dumped in 1964, when Nehru died. [26]. Pakistan meanwhile could stoke anger among the people of Kashmir. In 1955, Mirza Afzal Beg, with the help of Pakistan and patronship of the wife of then jailed Sheikh Abdullah established Plebiscite Front. In 1965, during the Second Kashmir War, a man named Maqbool Bhat called for armed struggle and established National Liberation Front. In 1971, an Indian plane was hijacked and flown to Pakistan. [27] The hijackers thought that just having the plane is enough, and they released the hostages. They wanted release of 36 of their guys in Indian prisons. Pakistan then arrested hundreds of activists. In 1976, one Amanullah Khan established Jammu and Kashmir Liberation Front in Birmingham. [28] In 1984, they kidnapped an Indian diplomat in Birmingham, asking for Maqbool Bhat's release. But the kidnappers shot the hostage, and India killed Maqbool Bhat.

In 1984, Amanullah Khan and Hashim Qureshi travelled to Pakistan where military dictator Zia ul-Haq wanted to unleash insurgency in Kashmir Valley. With the help of ISI, the insurgency started in 1987. They accused the election had been rigged against United Muslim Front, an Islamic coalition. Thousands of youth travelled to Pakistan and received arms training. JKLF got a new leader in the form of Yasin Malik.
In 1989, JKLF began liquidating large number of Kashmiri Hindus who were a small minority. Hundreds were killed. In January 1990, JKLF put posters across the Kashmir Valley telling Hindus to leave. As a result 300000-600000 Hindus left the area leading only a few thousand behind. [29]
In 1990, Indian Army began to enter Kashmir Valley to crush the militancy. Between 1990 and 1992 nearly 2000 militants were killed. In 1992, Yasin Malik was arrested. In 1994, JKLF left the insurgency.[30] Lashkar e Taiba (LeT), a group created during the Afghan Jihad entered the struggle in 1991. Since its leader Hafeez Saeed, Abdullah Azzam etc. were not Kashmiri, the organization did not fight for independence. They only touted Pakistan's line. [31] UN has found the organization to be collaborating with Al-Qaeda. It is one of the most prominent rebel groups in Kashmir. [32] In December 2001, there was a terror attack in Delhi. A group of 5 militants tried to enter the Parliament. They were killed but at the cost of 8 security personnel and a gardener. [33] Indian government accused Pakistan of the attack and mobilized half a million troops at the border.[34] India planned to invade Pakistan twice in 2002, once in January and then in June. Both time, USA and other countries interfered. But massive artillery bombing continues. Till the demobilization in October 2002, up to 1800 Indian troops were dead. Unknown number of Pakistani troops were dead. A large number of civilians died due to mines and shelling. In 2008, Lashkar e Toiba attacked multiple locations in Mumbai killing 157 civilians including a large number of Muslims. [35] [36] The 9/11 conspiracy theorist Elias Davidsson wrote a 900-page book on the attacks known as 'The Betrayal of India' and theorised that RAW (India's intelligence agency) had carried out the attack. [37]

References[edit]

  1. Kashmir Region Britannica. ND.
  2. Mehr Chand Mahajan (1963). Looking Back. Bombay: Asia Publishing House (Digitalized by Google at the University of Michigan). p. 162. ISBN 978-81-241-0194-0. ISBN 81-241-0194-9.
  3. Marin, Steve (2011). Alexander Mikaberidze, ed. Conflict and Conquest in the Islamic World: A Historical Encyclopedia, Volume 1. ABC-CLIO. p. 394. ISBN 978-1598843361.
  4. Indo-Pakistani Conflict of 1947-48 Globalsecurity.org. ND.
  5. Prasad, S.N.; Dharm Pal (1987). History of Operations in Jammu and Kashmir 1947–1948. New Delhi: History Department, Ministry of Defence, Government of India. (printed at Thomson Press (India) Limited). p. 418.
  6. Wilcox, Wayne Ayres (1963), Pakistan: The Consolidation of a Nation, Columbia University Press, p. 66, ISBN 978-0-231-02589-8, The war for states had not only ended in Indian military victory but had given its leaders enormous self-confidence and satisfaction over a job well done.
  7. Tibet through Chinese Eyes The Atlantic.PETER HESSLER FEB 1, 1999 .
  8. India China War of 1962 Times of India. Nov 21, 2016.
  9. India 'ready to let China keep Aksai Chin' if neighbour country drops claim to Arunachal Pradesh Daily Mail. SAURABH SHUKLA, 28 November 2013
  10. Lost in Dispute: 7 Beautiful Places near India-China Border
  11. Riedel, Bruce O. (29 January 2013), Avoiding Armageddon: America, India, and Pakistan to the Brink and Back, Brookings Institution Press, pp. 67–, ISBN 0-8157-2409-8
  12. The India-Pakistan War of 1965 Office of the Historian, US Dept. of State. ND.
  13. Indo-Pak War of 1971Globalsecurity.org. ND.
  14. Lyon, Peter (2008). Conflict between India and Pakistan: An Encyclopedia. ABC-CLIO. p. 166. ISBN 978-1-57607-712-2. Pakistan's defeat in the 1971 war and emergence of independent Bangladesh dramatically transformed the power balance of South Asia
  15. The collapse of the Shimla Accord The Indian Express. Inder Malhotra. June 9, 2014.
  16. Bob Harris. Who Hates Whom. 2007. page 108.
  17. Harris. page 108.
  18. [1]
  19. Harris. page 109.
  20. [2] Britannica. ND.
  21. Kashmir territories profile BBC. 3 October 2017
  22. Why Intel Sources Believe Jaish-e-Mohammed Is Surging In Kashmir Valley
  23. Kashmir militant leader announced as head of new al-Qaida-linked cell Michael Safi The Guardian. 27 July 2017
  24. India to open talks with all parties in disputed Jammu and Kashmir Michael Safi. The Guardian. 23 October 2017
  25. "Mourning and Resistance to the Loss of Kashmir's Special Autonomy" - The Intercept
  26. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kashmir_Conspiracy_Case
  27. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1971_Indian_Airlines_hijacking
  28. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jammu_Kashmir_Liberation_Front
  29. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exodus_of_Kashmiri_Hindus
  30. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_Army_operations_in_Jammu_and_Kashmir
  31. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lashkar-e-Taiba
  32. https://www.google.com/amp/s/m.economictimes.com/news/defence/al-qaeda-remains-resilient-continues-to-cooperate-closely-with-let-un/amp_articleshow/70445882.cms
  33. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/2001_Indian_Parliament_attack
  34. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/2001%E2%80%9302_India%E2%80%93Pakistan_standoff
  35. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2008_Mumbai_attacks
  36. https://www.indiatoday.in/india/story/tathagata-roy-mumbai-attacks-muslims-tweet-1396404-2018-11-26
  37. https://www.geopolitica.ru/en/article/interview-elias-davidson-author-betrayal-india