RationalWiki's 2019 Fundraiser

There is no RationalWiki without you. We are a small non-profit with no staff – we are hundreds of volunteers who document pseudoscience and crankery around the world every day. We will never allow ads because we must remain independent. We cannot rely on big donors with corresponding big agendas. We are not the largest website around, but we believe we play an important role in defending truth and objectivity.

If everyone who saw this today donated $5, we would meet our goal for 2019.

Fighting pseudoscience isn't free.
We are 100% user-supported! Help and donate $5, $20 or whatever you can today with PayPal Logo.png!

Donations so far: $6000Goal: $6000
Information icon.svg The 2018 moderator election has started! We are electing 6 moderators and 2 alternatives to serve in 2019. Nominate users here and read their campaign slogans here!

Isaac

From RationalWiki
Jump to: navigation, search
Isaac is saved and old Abe looks disappointed.
Light iron-age reading
The Bible
Icon bible.svg
Gabbin' with God
Analysis
Woo
Figures

Isaac (or Itzhak or Yitzhak) is the son of Abraham and the father to Jacob, the three being known in Jewish circles as the "Patriarchs."[1] He is best known for the myth of the binding of Isaac, in which he was nearly killed by his father.[2]

Binding of Isaac[edit]

According to the Book of Genesis, God instructed Abraham to murder Isaac, as a sacrifice to Him. The spot where the murder was intended to occur is believed to be the most holy site by both Muslims and Jews. Abraham fully intended to carry out this act, but Gabriel, an archangel, controlled a goat ram, or took the form of a ram in pagan fashion, and interrupted the murder. Isaac was probably traumatized by the near sacrifice. Abraham is not regarded as a deranged sociopath, but rather as the great hero and founder of the "Abrahamic" faiths. This is despite the fact that as Jenny Diski wrote it's inconceivable that Abraham would give up the son he had been promised by God and waited so long for:

The test is beyond reason. You can just see why a megalomaniac and jealous god like Yahweh might demand such a sacrifice and negate his own creation through sheer nihilism, but it’s very hard to understand why Abraham would comply with the destruction of the only possibility of God’s promises coming true.[3]

Carol Delaney sees the myth of Abraham and Isaac as summing up the pernicious authoritarianism and misogyny embedded in monotheistic religion: "Authoritarianism is rooted in paternity, and this underlying assumption in monotheistic religions, Delaney argues, helps to justify the marginalisation of women, parental abuse of children and the right of the state to send its children off to war."[3]

One of the most famous analyses of the story is by Søren Kierkegaard in Fear and Trembling; in this analysis, Abraham is asked to reject the ethical (i.e. not murdering people) and embrace a higher goal. Kierkegaard sees it as exemplifying the existentialist principle that each person must choose for themself a commitment to God that goes beyond morality or ethics. However it also functions as a justification for Kierkegaard "sacrificing" his girlfriend Regine by breaking off the engagement because he felt she wasn't good enough for him. [4][5] This again makes the story an example of masculine and patriarchal power and the subjection of the other.

It has been suggested that there may be an older version of the story in which Abraham actually kills Isaac, according to biblical scholar Tzemah Yoreh. This is hinted at by Genesis 22:19, which describes Abraham but not Isaac as returning from the mountain.[6][7]

Later life[edit]

Isaac is the least interesting characters of the three Patriarchs. His biggest claim to fame is being the sacrificial victim of YHWH's test of Abraham. His second biggest claim to fame is being the second name in the praise "Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob".

Isaac, as the son to Sara, is the counter to Ishmael, the son of Hagar. Sara, wanting to reserve her biological son's inheritance, cast Ishmael and Hagar from her sight. The two sons of Abraham held strong animosity for each other, however in the end, they stood side-by-side at their father Abraham's funeral. Isaac's descendants would become the Jews and Christians, Ishmael's descendants would produce Muhammad.

Sons[edit]

Isaac has sons with his wife and cousin Rebekah. He blesses one son, Jacob, and curses the other son, Esau. Jacob only gets the blessing by deception.

When Issac has his own sons, he sets to bestow a blessing on Esau, who as first born, had birthright to Issac's property. Jacob deceives blind old Issac, and receives the blessing and the inheritance instead.

Did he exist?[edit]

The biblical scholar Thomas L. Thompson wrote in 1975, "Not only has archaeology not proven a single event of the patriarchal traditions to be historical, it has not shown any of the traditions to be likely."[8] So probably not.

Other versions[edit]

The story of Abraham and Isaac resembles other myths. In a Classical Greek story, part of the Argonaut epic, King AthamasWikipedia's W.svg was told by a deceptive Oracle to sacrifice his son PhrixusWikipedia's W.svg, but the boy was rescued by a ram whose golden fleece was later the object of Jason and the Argonauts.[9]

Kierkegaard related it to the myth of Agamemnon commanded to kill his daughter Iphigenia to get fair winds; in different versions of the tale she is sacrificed or rescued by the gods.[5]

There's also a 2011 indie video game where the player is Isaac trying to flee from Abraham through a monster-filled dungeon.[10]

References[edit]

  1. Avot in Hebrew.
  2. See the Wikipedia article on binding of Isaac.
  3. 3.0 3.1 "The Will of the Fathers: Review of Abraham on Trial: The Social Legacy of the Biblical Myth by Carol Delaney", Jenny Diski, London Review of Books, Vol. 20 No. 24 · 10 December 1998, pages 24-26
  4. Fear and Trembling, Anthony Storm, sorenkierkegaard.org
  5. 5.0 5.1 See the Wikipedia article on Fear and Trembling.
  6. When Abraham murdered Isaac, Times of Israel, 28 November 2012
  7. See also Wikipedia, Binding of Isaac: Possible child sacrificeWikipedia's W.svg
  8. See the Wikipedia article on The Historicity of the Patriarchal Narratives.
  9. Greek Myths Related to Tales of Abraham, Isaac, Moses and the Promised Land, vridar.org, March 16, 2011
  10. See the Wikipedia article on The Binding of Isaac (video game).