There is no RationalWiki without you. We are a small non-profit with no staff – we are hundreds of volunteers who document pseudoscience and crankery around the world every day. We will never allow ads because we must remain independent. We cannot rely on big donors with corresponding big agendas. We are not the largest website around, but we believe we play an important role in defending truth and objectivity.
If everyone who saw this today donated $5, we would meet our goal for 2021.
| Fighting pseudoscience isn't free.|
We are 100% user-supported! Help and donate $5, $20 or whatever you can today with !
Self projection as god
| Preach to the choir|
|Crux of the matter|
|Speak of the devil|
|An act of faith|
“”It has been very well said, that if triangles were to make to themselves gods, they would give them three sides.
|—Montesquieu's Persian Letters|
Self projection as god (SPAG) describes the phenomenon through which believers, when trying to ascribe a personality and wishes to their chosen god, tend to arrive at something that is oddly similar to what they themselves think and feel. Whether the process is conscious, or a concerted effort to invoke a divine mandate in support of their actions, SPAG is a contributing factor to cafeteria Christianity. SPAG has also been called vicarious autotheism.
Origins and adoption
Projection theories of religion
The concept dates back to antiquity and could certainly play a role in the formation and development of religions. Projection theories of religion became increasingly popular during the modern era, especially among thinkers of a materialistic bent. A whole array of philosophers and social scientists has advocated some form of projection theory. Thomas Hobbes and David Hume posited that religion began as the anthropomorphism of natural phenomena. Ludwig Feuerbach argued that god is the projection of humanity's positive attributes and ideals. Marx and Engels, modifying Feuerbach, saw religion as an epiphenomenon of the social structure. Friedrich Nietzsche also came under the influence of Feuerbach. Emile Durkheim similarly saw religion as a projection of social norms and values. Sigmund Freud claimed that god was a heavenly projection of a father-figure. The modern cognitive science of religion also includes ideas similar to earlier projection theories. In this variant, one of the elements of religious cognition is "theory of mind," which allows humans to project agency onto inanimate objects or onto posited supernatural beings. Much like Hobbes and Hume, Stewart Guthrie, a forefather of this cognitivist tradition, views anthropomorphism as central to religion.
Origin of SPAG terminology
The phrase became a meme on the site, and had been further publicized by the now defunct Avangelism Project. The phrase very succinctly sums up what people have known about gods for thousands of years: they may be real or man-made constructs, but either way they're used mostly as a front to push the believer's agenda.
How does SPAG work?
“”You can safely assume you’ve created God in your own image when it turns out that God hates all the same people you do.
- I believe that x is immoral
- God is moral/morality comes from God
- God can't possibly support x
Replace x with racism[note 1]/racial equality, freeing the slaves/slavery, polygamy/monogamy/celibacy, homophobia/homosexuality, genocide/world peace, gender equality/inequality, and pretty much anything else one may wish to justify.
Such a conclusion may have scriptural support, but as is often the case with holy books, contradictory verses are almost certainly found. The believer must either ignore the verses that espouse the disagreeable view, or in more sophisticated theology, will find a way to reinterpret them away.
Perhaps the most chilling approach in addressing moral issues is to accept God as the arbiter of all things moral, thus using a "might makes right" argument to justify pretty nasty behavior.
Can Christians be rich?
Wealth and social justice are areas in which modern-day Christians diverge greatly from Christ's teachings as relayed in the gospels. Christ espoused an outlook that in modern times would have more in common with socialism than the brand of capitalism enthusiastically supported by modern-day conservative Christians of America.
Christ was an apocalyptic preacher whose teachings hinged on the idea that the world was soon coming to an end, and that the true rewards would come in his father's kingdom.[note 2] The gospel accounts vary greatly in how Christ is depicted but the need to live an austere and humble life is overwhelmingly supported by gospel accounts. Despite this, modern-day Christians to varying extents appear to ignore Matthew 19:24.
Jesus taught that the meek and downtrodden would be the most favored in the afterlife, and that his followers should relieve themselves of their wealth if they wish to see Heaven. The charitable works of some Christians are evident, yet most appear to be relying on Jesus not being entirely serious about the whole camel passing through the eye of a needle thing. It seems difficult to reconcile the political and financial aspirations of modern-day conservative Christians with the teachings of Christ. Although it cannot reasonably be considered to be personal wealth, the opulence in which the "Vicar of Christ" and his minions live is more comparable to that of Herod Antipas (Herod Antipas was the Rome-appointed ruler of Galilee and Perea, most commonly known in Christianity for his role in the execution of Christ) than of Christ and his disciples; yet the Catholic Church doesn't see it as a problem.
The wish for Christ to be a gung-ho capitalist reached its zenith in the form of prosperity theology when some Christians somehow reasoned that Jesus wanted his followers to have mansions on Earth — not just in Heaven! This extreme view is in a minority, but is far from being a fringe cult.
Can Christians divorce and re-marry?
Adultery is forbidden, as is divorce unless it's because of the wife's adultery (no mention of the husband[note 3]), but the popularity of divorce in Red states suggests a certain enthusiasm for having a second, third, or even a fourth chance at love. This runs in direct opposition to Christ's claim that divorcees who remarry are committing adultery. Few Christians appear troubled by this, and certainly do not stone people to death, as required by Deuteronomy 22:22.
SPAG lends an unwarranted air of authority to wishes of a more earthly origin, and can be a useful arbiter of "absolute" morality. Morals are largely determined by biology and societal expectations of what constitutes acceptable behavior. Having an all-powerful creator espousing these morals would give a set of morals more authority in the minds of believers than something put together by a bunch of guys in togas, so in religious societies there is a strong imperative to have God agree with that which society or its ruling classes find to be desirable. To use an example, no country has ever gone to war under the belief that God was going to be on the side of the other guy. If two countries of the same religion ever go to war, each side will believe God to be with them — yet this cannot possibly be true unless God has a very odd sense of humor. In World War II, the German Wehrmacht (the bulk of the German military forces) wore belt buckles emblazoned with the legend "Gott mit uns" (God with us). Hitler concocted a Christ that curiously enough was oddly supportive of his efforts in fighting "international Jewry".
“”My feelings as a Christian points me to my Lord and Savior as a fighter. It points me to the man who once in loneliness, surrounded by a few followers, recognized these Jews for what they were and summoned men to fight against them and who, God's truth! was greatest not as a sufferer but as a fighter.
|—A speech made by Adolf Hitler in April 12, 1922.|
Accepting people as being "on a mission from God" carries with it the risk that morally unacceptable behavior will be tolerated, a prominent example of which is found in the ongoing Catholic sex abuse scandals. A secular organization (or state) found to be undeniably complicit in the ongoing protection of men who rape children would receive short shrift, yet the leader of this organization — despite evidence that it's highly improbable that he was not involved in these activities or at least aware of them — continues to be welcomed as an honored guest. Further evidence of SPAG within the Catholic Church is in its structure. Popes are elected, allegedly with the intervention of God, when the previous one dies. The Pope, as the leader of the church, would obviously set the tone of the church during his papacy. Rather strangely, God's wishes appear to change with each Pope. Under Pope Leo X (Pope from 1513 to 1521), God wanted his church to fund repair work through the sale of indulgences,[note 4] yet in modern times indulgences are used far less crudely (i.e. not just sold for cash). Under Pope Francis, the church issued indulgences as a reward to people who attended World Youth Day in 2013. God has obviously become more subtle as time has passed. Pope Pius XI, the Pope who reigned before World War II, was a staunch critic of the Nazi ideology and regime, yet when God appointed Pope Pius XII as his successor the church's (and presumably God's) position on Nazi Germany became somewhat warmer.
“”Religion is dangerous because it allows human beings who don't have all the answers to think that they do. Most people would think it's wonderful when someone says, I'm willing, Lord. I'll do whatever You want me to do. Except that since there are no gods actually talking to us, that void is filled in by people, with their own corruptions, limitations and agendas.
|—Bill Maher, Religulous|
Prayer is also another topic which exemplifies SPAG. When theists pray, they believe they are praying to God. Since God doesn't actually respond verbally, those that pray fill in God's voice with their own thoughts and desires. This in turn results in religious people giving in to their most base fears and feelings, which is often a bad thing (with wars and what not).
- Cafeteria Christian
- Psychological projection
- Eckhart Tolle, "The God of the Bible is the God that man made in his own image…"
- Why Won't God Heal Amputees
- The early gospel accounts portray Jesus as having come solely for the Jews. See Matthew 15:28.
- In Matthew 16:28 Jesus told his disciples that the kingdom of God would come before they would all be dead. This obviously did not happen.
- It's not like polygamy was forbidden back then, so that usually don't count.
- An indulgence is a remission from penance that must be done on Earth or time to be served in purgatory as punishment for sins that have been forgiven.
- "Projection Theories of Religion", in A New Dictionary of Religions, ed. John R. Hinnells.
- Andy Coghlan. Theory of Mind Could Help Explain Belief in God. New Scientist, Mar. 2009
- Stewart Guthrie. (1995) Faces in the Clouds: A New Theory of Religion. New York: Oxford University Press.
- WhyWontGodHealAmputees.com. See also [Archive copy at the Wayback Machine What is spag?] for a discussion on the same forum regarding the authorship of the phrase.
- All Christianity is Self Projection as God
- Traveling Mercies; on page 22 of Bird by Bird she attributes this to "my priest friend Tom"
- The YouTube user NonStampCollector offers a humorous depiction of reinterpretation in his video: Jesus and the Interpreter. A modern-day christian helps Jesus get started
- Which Jesus: Examining Differences in the Gospel Narratives Jeremy Beahan, of Reasonable Doubts fame, exploring the contradictory biblical accounts of Jesus.
- Jim Bakker should have read Matthew 5:32 before deciding to remarry.
- The Speeches of Adolf Hitler: April 1922-August 1939 edited by Norman H. Baynes (1942) New York: Oxford University Press. pp. 19-20.
- Pope grants indulgences for World Youth Day