The 'Reiki' Factor in The Radiance Technique

From RationalWiki
Jump to: navigation, search
Dolphins and money
New Age
Icon new age.svg
Cosmic concepts
Spiritual selections

The 'Reiki' Factor in The Radiance Technique[note 1] is a book by psychic, astrologer, and Latin teacher Barbara Weber Ray describing her version of Reiki, The Radiance Technique® (or TRT®, for short). Quotes by Carl Sagan, Albert Einstein, Arthur C. Clarke,[note 2] and Marilyn Ferguson are sprinkled liberally throughout the book.

About the author[edit]

Barbara Weber Ray, Ph.D, (b. 1941 in Houston, Texas) is a psychic,[note 3] "professional, licensed astrologer", Reiki practitioner, and Latin teacher.[1][2][3] She obtained a BA and MA in the Classics, Ancient Languages and Civilizations, and a Ph.D in Humanities from Florida State University,[3] and is a member of Mensa.[4] In 1973 she started practicing clairvoyancy.[1] She used to have an astrology radio show in Atlanta called "Star-Talk".[1]

Contents[edit]

The book has three parts divided into 18 chapters: a history and description of Reiki; how to use TRT (but only if you've been attuned to the cosmic energy, of course), anecdotes and testimonials (these comprise over half of the book), and some appendices containing quotes relevant to the cause, frequently asked questions, a chapter about the author, and a preface (which is at the end). (One of the quotes is the "Truth goes through three phases" formulation of the Galileo gambit, and it is erroneously[5] attributed to Schopenhauer.)

There's light. And then there's Light.[edit]

Ray tells of John Ott's experiments on the effects of different kinds of light on health and his theory that sunlight is necessary for human health, and quotes him saying that, just as we have food diets now, humans will go on light diets. She compares this to the Light diet supposedly provided by Reiki ("Light" is Ray's way of saying "subtle energy".) People are apparently made both of Light and matter (this will be relevant later on).

History of Reiki[edit]

In chapter 8, Ray says, more or less, that the method now known as TRT was transmitted by word of mouth for centuries, that it came to Asia from some other, unknown, place, and that she was the only scholar who could recognize ancient descriptions of the method for what they really were (that is, TRT).

Spurious Einstein quote[edit]

Einstein's opinion of this quote.

In this context, she says:[6]

When Einstein, himself, in the formula E = MC2 proclaimed that light and matter are interchangeable, he rediscovered what mystics seem to have known for centuries. Now the scientist becomes the mystic. Einstein reveals to the listening ear his inner process with his words, "I did not arrive at my understanding of the fundamental laws of the universe through my rational mind".

Ray doesn't provide a reference for the quote, which seems to have first appeared in the 1971 spirituality book Be Here Now by Hindu spiritual teacher Ram Dass.[7][8] It may be useful to note that all other references to the quote, mostly in New Age- and business-related publications, occur in works published after 1971.[9]

Reiki discovered by extraterrestrial aliens?[edit]

The knowledge of TRT goes back many centuries:[6]

Modern scholars often come upon this inner knowledge but misinterpret it because it was veiled in cryptic languages and symbols designed to give double meanings.
In the East, this knowledge was taken into China and Japan and also put into many other forms, hidden in symbols and buried in ancient, obscure languages.

But here's the interesting part:[6]

In The Sirius Mystery, astronomer [sic][10] Robert Temple gives a scholarly, honest, yet cautious account of an anthropological study of the Dogon tribe in Africa, who have an incredible knowledge of Sirius, known as the Dog Star. In our remote past, has there been some contact with beings of a higher intelligence and consciousness who transmitted this knowledge of activating higher circuits in humans? Indeed, there is strong evidence on this planet that some kind of contact has been made.

Ray doesn't elaborate further, and leaves the reader to interpret this vague paragraph. She refers to The Sirius Mystery, but absent from her summary is the fact that Temple's argument in his book is that the Dogon people obtained their information from technologically advanced aliens thousands of years ago (though the erroneous description of Temple as being an astronomer provides a hint). Then she asks whether Reiki was "transmitted" by beings "of a higher intelligence and consciousness".

This juxtaposition suggests that the beings are, in fact, aliens, and, indeed, "intelligence" doesn't sound like something that would apply to a spirit; however, the phrase "higher consciousness" is so vague that it could be a reference to a supernatural quality.[11]

On the other hand, Ray uses the phrase "on this planet". There are countless things she could have written instead: "on this plane", "on this level of existence", "in this world" (as opposed to the afterlife or spirit world) — but she chose "on this planet", with all its connotations of outer space and the material universe (and note the phrasing: "on this planet" — meaning on Earth, as opposed to, say, Mars or Mercury.)

The entire last sentence is a response to the question of whether Reiki was transmitted by these beings, so it appears she is saying that there is evidence for contact with the specific individuals that brought Reiki to Earth. On the other hand, Ray says there is strong evidence for "some sort of contact", which could mean that the evidence is only for contact with some aliens, not necessarily the ones that supposedly enlightened humanity by bringing this "circuit-activating" technique.

In any case, though we may never know what Ray meant by this mysterious passage, it may be worth noting that Usui himself said:[12]

I’ve never been given this method by anybody nor studied to get psychic power to heal. I accidentally realized that I have received healing power when I felt the air in mysterious way during fasting. So I have a hard time explaining exactly even I am the founder.

Usui, Einstein, and Reiki[edit]

Ray goes on to tell what she admits is the legend of Usui's discovery of Reiki. While in India, he supposedly found Sanskrit inscriptions that had a "formula" with symbols for activating cosmic energy. She then speculates that perhaps future civilizations will rediscover Einstein's E = MC2 and "the instructions on how to use it", just as Usui rediscovered Reiki. Also, E = MC2 is a tool for activating energy, just like Reiki is.

Then Ray claims Reiki can't be self-taught (i.e. that one can only be attuned by another person), just one page after writing about Usui's "discovery" of Reiki. This is strange, given that the story she just told was about Usui teaching himself Reiki.

A New Age Dawns[edit]

Now follows a description of Hawayo Takata's role in disseminating Reiki, and Ray's background in ancient civilizations. A "new age" is dawning, of which TRT is implied to be a very important part. There are no words to describe the wonderful benefits TRT can bring to its users. Like, nothing.

Yup, that'll do nicely.

Anecdotes[edit]

Before discussing some of the anecdotes in the book, it is first worth noting that the placebo effect is known to be very strong and can produce very substantial changes in subjective symptoms such as pain and fatigue by making the body release endorphins and other analgesic substances,[13] for reasons unrelated to supernatural powers. This is a mechanism which has been extensively studied and is very well known.

Yet, despite this, there are quite a number of stories in this book describing how subjective symptoms such as pain and fatigue improved after laying on of hands. But the placebo effect by definition makes people feel better — even dramatically so. There is no way to tell, using only anecdotes, whether the improvement was due to the placebo effect or to the specific effects of the treatment.

Probably the strangest (and weakest) anecdote is one in which Ray describes how she picked up an injured seagull, which she says she "never would have had the courage to do had it not been for Reiki". But is cosmic energy really the only possible explanation for someone gaining confidence?

A businesswoman attended a Reiki session. She was tired and nauseated and originally thought Reiki was just a "metaphysical placebo" that couldn't possibly be of any use to her, but after one hour of Reiki, she felt better, and concluded that Reiki "works". However, it seems she was unaware of what a placebo actually is, since the placebo effect is perfectly capable of relieving nausea. In one classic study,[14] nauseous subjects were given a powerful nausea-inducing substance, which they were told would relieve their symptoms. The placebo effect was so strong that instead of feeling worse, the patients felt relief. In other words, the placebo effect overpowered the physical effects of the medicine! Had the businesswoman known this, she probably would have come to a different conclusion. It may be objected that since she didn't originally believe in Reiki, the placebo effect couldn't possibly have worked. But if the businesswoman had really been convinced that Reiki did not work, she wouldn't have gone to the Reiki session in the first place. That she went at all is evidence that she may have had some belief in it, or that she was sufficiently curious to be susceptible to the placebo effect. And, of course, there's always the possibility that her nausea would have gotten better anyway; it is not unreasonable to think that a person's nausea could improve in one hour.

The implicit assumption of these anecdotes is that the improvements must have been due to some supernatural power entering the person's body, and that they cannot have been coincidences or the result of the placebo effect (many of these Reiki "conversions" involve people who are probably unaware of the extent to which the mind can affect the body). A passage from chapter four of Mark Twain's 1907 book Christian Science could be illustrative (emphasis added):[15]

When I was a boy a farmer's wife who lived five miles from our village had great fame as a faith-doctor—that was what she called herself. Sufferers came to her from all around, and she laid her hand upon them and said, "Have faith—it is all that is necessary," and they went away well of their ailments. She was not a religious woman, and pretended to no occult powers. She said that the patient's faith in her did the work. Several times I saw her make immediate cures of severe toothaches. My mother was the patient. In Austria there is a peasant who drives a great trade in this sort of industry, and has both the high and the low for patients. He gets into prison every now and then for practising without a diploma, but his business is as brisk as ever when he gets out, for his work is unquestionably successful and keeps his reputation high. In Bavaria there is a man who performed so many great cures that he had to retire from his profession of stage-carpentering in order to meet the demand of his constantly increasing body of customers. He goes on from year to year doing his miracles, and has become very rich. He pretends to no religious helps, no supernatural aids, but thinks there is something in his make-up which inspires the confidence of his patients, and that it is this confidence which does the work, and not some mysterious power issuing from himself.[16]

Is it more likely that the symptomatic changes in TRFiTRT are the result of the well known and scientifically proven "power of the mind", or that they are the result of some vaguely defined, supernatural "force"? Occam's razor would suggest the former.

In Ray's book, there are a number of anecdotes with objective improvements, but, as with all anecdotes, it is impossible to tell whether the improvements were really due to Reiki or just coincidences.

Someone had a kidney stone which, Ray says, wouldn't dissolve with medication. Some acquaintances of the person used Reiki on her, and advised her to get an X-ray (a second one) to see if the kidney stone changed, which she did, the next day. The kidney stone was smaller. The problem with this anecdote is that there is very little information about the case. How long did she have the stone? How much time elapsed between the patient's first X-ray and the Reiki treatment? It's possible that a few weeks had passed between the first X-ray and the Reiki treatment, in which case there could have been plenty of time for the kidney stone to dissolve.

Ray says she was contacted by the family of a person whose cancer allegedly disappeared because of Reiki. Besides the fact that this is a second-hand story, and that cases of cancers "disappearing" are often either due to misdiagnosis or spontaneous improvement, this anecdote is rather disappointing given that it's not even a first-hand story and that the pool of people who have at some point experienced TRT is quite large. It's relatively easy to get many cases of spontaneous remission or misdiagnosis. (Think about it: out of 100 people diagnosed with cancer, how many will be misdiagnosed? Or 1,000? Or 10,000?)

Near the end of the book, there is a foreword to the first edition of The Reiki Factor written by a psychotherapist and Reiki user. Among other things, she describes how her knee became very swollen after a fall, and how, throughout the day, the swelling diminished significantly, supposedly due to Reiki (in the evening, she was treated by four other practitioners simultaneously). But it cannot be definitively said that Reiki, rather than natural recovery, made the swelling go away. (A doctor who saw the injury right after the fall said she would be on crutches for weeks. But since when are doctors infallible?) It is also described how the person's mother underwent chemotherapy for colon cancer without experiencing baldness, and the lack of hair loss is likewise attributed to Reiki. What medicines were used isn't specified, but some colon cancer drugs (such as oxaliplatin) do not cause alopecia.[17]

Ray has attuned many people (possibly hundreds or thousands) to Reiki, and the book includes second- or third-hand testimonials sent to her by TRT users she (presumably) doesn't know. The total number of cases worldwide involving TRT users likely numbers in the hundreds of thousands, or even millions. Improbable things happen, and with this enormous pool of anecdotes involving TRT to choose from, it would be practically impossible for there not to be "miraculous" statistical flukes occurring sometime after the use of Reiki. ("Sometime" being arbitrary and possibly extending to months, maximizing the possibility of natural improvement.) Yet even the most mundane events[note 4] are attributed to Reiki. There are so many things besides Reiki which could be responsible: Regression to the mean, spontaneous improvement, the placebo effect, misdiagnosis, or factors not mentioned in the anecdote (such as therapies undertaken alongside Reiki), among others.

All anecdotes and testimonials are necessarily self-selected, subject to cognitive biases, and ultimately not useful. Mary Baker Eddy's Health and Science, the founding text of Christian Science, also contains many testimonials describing "miraculous" recoveries, and some of its "cured" diseases include cancer, tuberculosis, heart disease, and various others.[18] Christian Science, the many different varieties of Reiki (including supposedly "inauthentic" ones), therapeutic touch, quantum touch (which, unlike Reiki, is claimed to consist of techniques that can be self-taught), and the irreligious laying on of hands of Mark Twain's "faith-doctor" are based on "miraculous" anecdotes, yet many of these systems contradict each other. They can't all be simultaneously right.

See also[edit]

Notes[edit]

  1. Why the word "Reiki" is between "quotation" marks "is" a "mystery".
  2. Ray tells an anecdote about a boy who said "Mommy, now you have magic hands" when his mother's Reiki made his forehead stop hurting. Ray then quotes Clarke's "Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic."
  3. Or clairvoyant, as she prefers to call herself.
  4. Cf. the seagull incident at the beginning of this section.

References[edit]

  1. 1.0 1.1 1.2 The 'Reiki' Factor in The Radiance Technique, back cover
  2. Unnaturalistic Methods: QR, under The Radiance Technique.
  3. 3.0 3.1 The Authentic Seven Level System
  4. The Expanded Reference Manual of The Radiance Technique(R), Authentic Reiki(R), Amazon.com.
  5. Science, Pseudoscience, and The Three Stages of Truth, Jeffrey Shallit.
  6. 6.0 6.1 6.2 Ray, page 49.
  7. Google Books Search for einstein "rational mind" understanding ram dass universe be here now
  8. Talk page of Albert Einstein in Wikiquotes
  9. Google Books search for "I did not arrive at my understanding of the fundamental laws of the universe through my rational mind"
  10. Temple is not actually an astronomer; he has an undergraduate degree in Oriental Studies and Sanskrit — the confusion probably stems from that fact that Temple is (or was?) a member of the Royal Astronomical Society, which lets anyone willing to pay become a fellow of the organization.
  11. Though since the word "beings" is lowercase and plural, we can safely ignore the possibility of the entities in question being deities.
  12. [1]
  13. Brain's Own Pain Relievers At Work in Placebo Effect, Study Suggests, Scientific American, Sarah Graham, Aug 24, 2005.
  14. Wolf S. Effects of suggestions and conditioning on the action of chemical agents in human subjects - the pharmacology of placebos. J Clin Invest 1950;29:100-9. PMCID PMC439730
  15. Christian Science
  16. Christian Science, Mark Twain, Chapter IV.
  17. Oxaliplatin as single agent in previously untreated colorectal carcinoma patients: A phase II multicentric study.
  18. CHAPTER XVIII - FRUITAGE