There is no RationalWiki without you. We are a small non-profit with no staff — we are hundreds of volunteers who document pseudoscience and crankery around the world every day. We will never allow ads because we must remain independent. We cannot rely on big donors with corresponding big agendas. We are not the largest website around, but we believe we play an important role in defending truth and objectivity.
If everyone seeing this today donates $5, we will meet our goal for 2018.
| Fighting pseudoscience isn't free.|
We are 100% user-supported! Help and donate $5, $20 or whatever you can today with !
| It doesn't stop|
at the water's edge
“”"Every national border in Europe," El Eswad added ironically, "marks the place where two gangs of bandits got too exhausted to kill each other anymore and signed a treaty. Patriotism is the delusion that one of these gangs of bandits is better than all the others."
|—Robert Anton Wilson|
Irredentism is to be distinguished from territorial expansionism, in that irredentism claims to advocate taking back land that is "rightfully ours," while expansionism advocates annexation regardless of whether the territory was "ours" in the first place. The name of the hypothetical country resulting from successful annexation frequently contains the word "Greater," such as, for example, in Greater Serbia, Greater Albania, Greater Greece, Greater India, Greater Russia, Greater Hungary, Greater Romania, and Greater Bulgaria. (There is, however, no Greater Switzerland. Oddly enough, Switzerland also hasn't been at war for over 150 years, but that's probably just a coincidence.)
In times of yore
According to the political ideology of ethnolinguistic nationalism, a nation-state must encompass all the speakers of a given language and have only one official language. The nation-states that arose on the basis of these principles were, however, hindered by the fact that completely monolingual regions are more the exception than the rule; consequently, they have historically tended to accomplish these two goals and deal with the "problems" of multilingualism and diversity by annexing territories of neighboring states populated at least in part by speakers of their official language and by pursuing ethnic homogenization of the populations within their own territories, through deportations, population transfers, forced assimilation, or even massacres. Fortunately, irredentism usually does not receive the official support it once did.
Gimme gimme gimme!
“”If the American desires the greatness and prosperity of the States before all nations, and the Englishman desires the same for his nation, and the Russian, Turk, Dutchman, Abyssinian, Venezuelan, Boer, Armenian, Pole, Czech, each have a similar desire; if all are convinced that these desires ought not to be concealed and suppressed, but, on the contrary, are something to be proud of, and to be encouraged in oneself and in others; and if one country's greatness and prosperity can only be obtained at the expense of another, or at times of many other countries and nations; then how can war not be?
|—Leo Tolstoy, Patriotism, or Peace?|
Orredentism often seeks to expand a given country to its maximum historical extent, regardless of whether the irredentists' ethnic group ever actually formed the majority in the territories in question. Examples include the irredentist claims by Hungarian right-wing extremists to the entire Pannonian Basin, ultra-Zionists to Jordan, or irredentist claims by Russian conservatives (including Vladimir Putin) to the Baltic States, Ukraine, Poland (of which they already shaved the eastern third) Finland (see previously listed affair), and Alaska (which they sold at what was considered by some a more than fair price ("Seward's Folly"). In a sense, West Germany had irredentist attitudes in claiming that East Germany was a part of Germany, too.
Irredentists often argue at length that a region rightly belongs to their country, without actually providing any reasons why such transfer of land would in itself be beneficial (and much less whether it would be worth the costs a war would bring). For instance, the territories claimed by irredentists may have no or a negligible presence of their ethnic group (rendering claims of "our brothers are being oppressed" moot), and in some areas (such as the European Union) there may be no barrier to travel, meaning the irredentists can go there any time as if it were in their own country. Not to mention that forcing the population to speak a different official language would probably not ease poverty, lack of access to education or healthcare, or many other real problems that nationalists so often ignore in favor of the much simpler (and pointless) goal of satisfying their urge to get rid of "foreigners".[note 1]
Irredentism in education
“”On this globe there are national boundaries marked, but on photographs of the Earth from space, there are no national boundaries to be seen, which is perhaps a useful lesson for politicians.
One cause of irredentism, both presently and historically, has been educational systems. Education is often used as a means of instilling nationalism, xenophobia, exclusionary ethnic loyalty, irredentist attitudes, and the idea that only one ethnic group has the "right" to live in a certain area.
- Nationalist pseudohistory
- Manifest destiny
- Falkland Islands
- Ethnic cleansing
- See also Lyndon B. Johnson's quote about xenophobic politicians: "If you can convince the lowest white man he's better than the best colored man, he won't notice you're picking his pocket. Hell, give him somebody to look down on, and he'll empty his pockets for you."
- "Searching For Cosmic Intelligence" — interview by Jeffrey Elliot (1980)
- The Way We Were
- "The Silesian Language in the Early 21st Century: A Speech Community on the Rollercoaster of Politics", Tomasz Kamusella, pages 4, 5.
- Irredentism: An Inevitable Tendency of Ethnic Nationalism, Dimostenis Yağcıoğlu
- Los mitos de pérdidas territoriales de los Estados hispanoparlantes de la América meridional
- Russian nationalists want Alaska back — 150 years after it was sold to the US: Czar Alexander II sold the north American territory in 1867 for $7.2 million by Chloe Farand (31 March 2017 13:12 BST) The Indpendent.
- The Hungarian Horseradish
- Christmas Lecture, 1977