Information icon.svg Consider taking the RationalWiki Community Survey 2017 or see the results.

Leon Trotsky

From RationalWiki
(Redirected from Trotsky)
Jump to: navigation, search
After Trotsky fell from favor, his image was edited out from official photographs by the Ministry of TruthWikipedia's W.svg party.
Join the party!
Communism
Icon communism.svg
Opiates for the masses
From each
To each
Warning icon orange.svg This page contains too many unsourced statements and needs to be improved.

Leon Trotsky could use some help. Please research the article's assertions. Whatever is credible should be sourced, and what is not should be removed.

A means can be justified only by its end. But the end in its turn needs to be justified, From the Marxist point of view, which expresses the historical interests of the proletariat, the end is justified if it leads to increasing the power of man over nature and to the abolition of the power of man over man.
—Leon Trotsky

Leon Trotsky, born Lev Davidovich Bronshtein, was a communist leader, along with Vladimir Lenin, during the Russian Revolution. A split between Trotsky and Lenin's successor Stalin, however, led to Trotsky's exile from the Soviet Union and eventual assassination (via severe headache) in Mexico in 1940, at the hands of a Stalinist agent named Ramón Mercader.

Revolutionary leader[edit]

Conditions in pre-revolutionary Russia presented unexpected strategic dilemmas for Marxists within the Russian socialist movement. Marxist orthodoxy saw the development of industrial capitalism and a strong proletariat as a prerequisite for socialist revolution. Being a largely agrarian society with a large holdover of feudal relations, the Russian Empire was far from meeting those conditions. The issue of revolutionary strategy gained urgency as unrest leading up to the 1905 revolution indicated that revolutionary conditions were imminent. The Russian Social Democratic Labour PartyWikipedia's W.svg became divided into two camps, the Menshevik (minority) tendency that favored alliance with the rising bourgeoisie to overthrow the feudal aristocracy, and the Bolshevik (majority) tendency led by V. I. Lenin, that was skeptical that the bourgeoisie would align with the proletariat against the aristocracy. The Bolsheviks instead proposed a socialist-led coalition based on the proletariat and the peasant class to compensate for the numerical weakness of the Russian proletariat, which would seize power then oversee the development of capitalism until the requisite level of development for a socialist economy was reached. The Menshevik strategy of seeking alliances within the bourgeoisie to achieve socialist goals became the international foundation of the Social Democrats. The results of the 1905 Russian Revolution lent credence to the Bolshevik position; an alliance of agricultural socialists, Social Democrats, and bourgeois democrats won political concessions from the Tsar that were quickly rolled back and repression of dissidents, including executions, increased to even greater levels in the following years.

The notion of a socialist revolution fostering capitalism didn't sit so well with Trotsky, after 1905 a member of the Menshevik bloc in exile as a leader of the defeated 1905 revolution. His opinion was that managers of socialist-led capitalism would bear the potential to derail a socialist revolution. He instead proposed the doctrine of Permanent Revolution in which a centralized socialist planned economy would be implemented without an intermediate capitalist phase. His ideas didn't fit in so well with the Menshevik bloc either; he became non-aligned between the Bolsheviks and Mensheviks and concentrated instead on promoting his ideas independently of either bloc's doctrines. Trotsky also foresaw an urgent need for socialist revolutions to occur outside Russia in more developed economies, especially Germany, if a revolution in Russia were to survive. To promote that he formed the Mezhraionka (Internationalist) tendency in 1914, a group based around promoting international socialist revolution.

The factional battle between Bolsheviks and Mensheviks came to the fore in the aftermath of the February Revolution in 1917 - a broad coalition led by the Mensheviks under Alexander Kerensky, who were the dominant faction of the socialist movement at that time, forced the Tsar to cede power, but the path forward became chaotic. Kerensky made too many concessions to the old Russian state apparatus and capitalists for the Bolsheviks' liking and continued the war against Germany over Bolshevik objections. The Bolsheviks saw replacing the old state structures as a matter of urgency for heading off a counterrevolution. The Bolsheviks were expelled from the ruling coalition. Trotsky was arrested along with Bolshevik leaders shortly after his return and while imprisoned became an unequivocal Bolshevik. Meanwhile, the Bolsheviks had formed an alternate power base in the Soviets (Workers' Councils). Kerensky saw the Soviets as illegitimate and sought the help of the Russian Army to suppress them. However, there were signs that Army Generals were taking that opportunity to plan a military coup, leading Kerensky to seek the help of armed Workers' Brigades under the directorship of the Petrograd Soviet to fend it off, freeing Trotsky and other imprisoned Bolsheviks as part of the deal. The balance of power in Petrograd shifted dramatically in favor of the Bolsheviks as a result. Trotsky was soon elected chair of the Petrograd Soviet. With Lenin back from exile in Switzerland as the leader of the Bolsheviks and working alongside Trotsky, and the Workers' Brigades feeding off defections from the Russian Army under Lenin and Trotsky's agitation, Kerensky's position grew so weakened that his government toppled with the first shots of armed rebellion in the name of the Soviets during the October Revolution. Trotsky's role in leading the Petrograd Soviet to seize power was, in fact, vital,[1] but in later years his Menshevik past was used against him as a sign of his untrustworthiness.[2][3]

The travails of the Russian Revolution were far from over, with a Tsarist counterrevolution soon launched with support from the world's most powerful nations. Trotsky's record as Foreign Minister and Commissar of the Red Army during the Russian Civil War contained brilliance, bloopers, and brutality. In an irony of ironies, Trotsky blew the initial negotiations for peace with Germany, leading to extension of the war that had led to the downfall of the Tsar and Kerensky. The Treaty of Brest-Litovsk in 1918 ratified the seizure of large amounts of Russian territory by Germany in the aftermath of the first failed attempt at peace, which was only reversed by the defeat of Germany later that year. Poland's war of eastward expansion against Russia in 1919 (following their war against the Ukrainian People's Republic) was at first brilliantly defended against under the most trying of circumstances at the height of the Russian Civil War, with Russia able to regain all of its lost territories. However, Trotsky extended that battle to the point that Britain and France intervened, providing Poland with air power, armor, and other resources that the Red Army lacked. The result was seizure of the western Ukraine and part of Belarus by Poland, ratified by the Treaty of Riga in 1921. The record of the Red Army with national minorities was mixed, often aligning with nationalist forces in alliance against the Tsarists, who the local populations tended to deeply resent, then engaging local leadership in power struggles that often turned bloody. But the Red Army directed a special repressiveness towards ethnic Russians, in whose Russian Orthodox faith the role of the Tsar in Holy Mother Russia was sanctified, leading to suspicion of Tsarist sympathies particularly among the peasants. Orthodox Priests were often summarily executed, and those who objected to the sacrilege got rubbed out too. The privations of war often led to confrontations over scarce resources; protests over real grievances were often regarded as "counterrevolutionary." Trotsky's violent suppression of the Kronstadt and Makhnovist anarchist movements made him a hated figure in the anti-Bolshevik Left.[4]. The Bolsheviks' greatest political success outside of Russia was in gaining the loyalty of the Ukrainian People's Republic with a territorial reward of the Donbas (which the Red Army had seized from Nestor Makhno's agricultural anarchists after the latter drove out the Tsarist forces). The arrangement was also expedient for the Ukrainians as a security bolster against Poland, who had shown their designs on the Ukrainian territory. However, the international wave of revolution, central to the survival of the Bolshevik Revolution according to Trotsky, clearly was not happening.[5]

Trotsky's leadership of the Red Army and the Russian Civil War's successful conclusion left him in high esteem as a commander who prevailed against great odds, even among military historians not aligned with communism. The nationalities question was resolved with the system of Soviet Socialist Republics that hardwired the interests of national minorities into the central bureaucracy (later instrumental in the rise of the Georgian Stalin and the Ukrainian Kruschev) and lent a measure of stability. But the success of the Red Army owed partly to the fact that their opponents were divided, pursuing their own agendas, and sometimes in conflict with each other.

The relative outcomes of the Bolshevik Revolution and the German Revolution of 1918, which was led by Social Democrats who then aligned themselves with the bourgeoisie against the truly socialist Spartacist uprising, established the Bolshevik-aligned faction of the socialist movement internationally as the go-to for revolutionary socialists.

The death of Lenin allowed Stalin and other "centrists" in the party to move against him — Trotsky was portrayed as a splitter for his opposition, rooted in his doctrine of Permanent Revolution, to the then "New Economic Policy" which allowed some small-scale capitalist production. Stalin deftly made common cause with the "right" against Trotsky's "Left Opposition" and by the time the right realised they too were being outmaneuvered, the "United Opposition" to Stalin was facing an invincible enemy. In 1928 Trotsky found himself expelled from the Soviet Union, and refused entry to several countries before he settled in Mexico. He became good friends with Mexican Communist artists Diego Rivera and Selma HayekWikipedia's W.svg Frida Kahlo (whom he had an affair with) prior to his assassination in 1940 by a Soviet agent.

Trotskyism[edit]

At the time of the Stalin-Trotsky split in the 1920s, Stalinist and Trotskyist branches of the world communist movement separated and took different ideological directions. Most of the national Communist Parties took their direction from Moscow and expelled Trotsky's supporters. In the United States the Trotskyists became the Socialist Workers Party. In the UK they united, briefly, in 1944 under the name of the Revolutionary Communist PartyWikipedia's W.svg (distinct from the Revolutionary Communist Party, USA, which is Maoist). In Britain, and elsewhere, much of the divisions in later years came between those who advocated that they were the followers of the "true" Fourth International. Trotskyism took a communist but anti-Stalinist line and advocated political opposition to Stalinism, which they saw as leading to an entrenched bureaucracy and to the development of a new ruling class under the guise of Communist Party leadership.

Trotsky founded the Fourth International in 1938 to counter the Soviet-led Third International (or Comintern). Ironically, Trotsky initially opposed the idea of establishing parallel Communist parties or a parallel international Communist organization that would compete with the Third International, but he changed his mind after the Nazi takeover in Germany (1933) and the Comintern's response to it. The Fourth International proclaimed capitalism was in its "death agony" and the principal barriers to successful workers' revolutions were the leaderships of the (reformist) social democrats and (especially) the orthodox Stalinist Communist Parties. The Fourth International's principal tactic was to be the "Transitional Demand" — a series of slogans that looked quite like the traditional demands of social democratic parties but which were, in fact, so extreme that they could only be achieved through the revolutionary overthrow of the existing order (i.e., as opposed to social democratic reform). This tactic is still central to Trotskyist practice today, where Trotskyists can often be seen mirroring the demands of the mainstream reformists or trade unionists except in an extremely amplified form. Trotskyists often used the communist hammer-and-sickle symbol with the number "4" superimposed on it, a reference to their allegiance to the Fourth International rather than to the Third.

Trotskyism in the United States split into different tendencies in the aftermath of the Molotov - von Ribbentrop PactWikipedia's W.svg of 1939. One tendency, the Shachtmanites, or followers of Max Shachtman, regarded the Soviet Union as irredeemably corrupt and no longer worthy of support under Marxist solidarity. Some of the Schachtmanites coalesced into their own Trotskyist group, the International Socialist Organization. Others softened their revolutionary Marxism in favor of social democracy and adopted an increasingly anti-Soviet line that led to support for Cold War policies. (And here's where it gets nuts: Shachtmanites are cited as intellectual fathers of neoconservatism.) Going in the opposite direction were the followers of Sam Marcy during the 1950s, for whom worldwide opposition to so-called "U.S. imperialism" took priority over opposition to Stalinism; hence, Marcy's followers defended the Soviet Union's invasions of Hungary and Czechoslovakia, and declared support for any communist government regardless of ideology from the relatively moderate Yugoslavia to the hard-line cranks ruling Albania and the hereditary monarchy in North Korea. In the United States, Marcy's followers became the Workers World Party, who gained a great deal of recent attention due to their leadership role within A.N.S.W.E.R. (Act Now to Stop War and End Racism). One of the strangest and richest of (former?) Trotskyists, Lyndon LaRouche, went the same direction as the Shachtmanites with a anti-Soviet line while taking his followers into the lunatic world of conspiracy theories and cult status. More recently, LaRouche identified the British Royal Family as the world's #1 bogey.[citation needed] In the midst of all these deviations, the Socialist Workers Party kept its status as the "main" Trotskyist party, although they are decidedly irrelevant and mostly like to sell books and newspaper subscriptions.

In the UK, they are often called "Trots" and are often a fixture at left-wing and labour events, distinguishing themselves by their abrasive tendentiousness. The most popular of these iterations is usually found to be an heir to the teachings and platform of Israeli-British immigrant Tony Cliff, in which Christopher Hitchens launched his writing career before moving to America. In the USA, the International Socialist Organization is one of these, though Cliff expelled them from his fold over a dispute over large sums of money.

During the 1990s, the International Committee of the Fourth International launched a drive to revive the moribund Trotskyist movement with the founding of Socialist Equality Parties and the World Socialist Website. American Trotskyists founded the Socialist Equality Party (USA) in 2008.[citation needed]

Obligatory George Orwell reference[edit]

George Orwell was somewhat sympathetic to Trotsky, possibly because he fought alongside the POUM militia in the Spanish Civil War, many of whose members were Trotskyists. In Animal Farm, the role of Trotsky is given to Snowball. In Nineteen Eighty-Four, it is Emmanuel Goldstein.

But even with that being said, he is still well known for his rather insightful quote: "The fact that Trotskyists are everywhere a persecuted minority, and that the accusation usually made against them, i.e. of collaborating with the Fascists, is obviously false, creates an impression that Trotskyism is intellectually and morally superior to Communism; but it is doubtful whether there is much difference."[6]

Testament[edit]

In addition to the happiness of being a fighter for the cause of socialism, fate gave me the happiness of being [Natalia's] husband. During the almost forty years of our life together she remained an inexhaustible source of love, magnanimity, and tenderness. She underwent great sufferings, especially in the last period of our lives. But I find some comfort in the fact that she also knew days of happiness.

For forty-three years of my conscious life I have remained a revolutionist; for forty-two of them I have fought under the banner of Marxism. If I had to begin all over again I would of course try to avoid this or that mistake, but the main course of my life would remain unchanged. I shall die a proletarian revolutionist, a Marxist, a dialectical materialist, and, consequently, an irreconcilable atheist. My faith in the communist future of mankind is not less ardent, indeed it is firmer today, than it was in the days of my youth.

Natasha has just come up to the window from the courtyard and opened it wider so that the air may enter more freely into my room. I can see the bright green strip of grass beneath the wall, and the clear blue sky above the wall, and sunlight everywhere. Life is beautiful. Let the future generations cleanse it of all evil, oppression and violence, and enjoy it to the full.
—"Trotsky's Testament" - 27 February 1940; Coyoacan, Mexico

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. cf. Jack Reed, Ten Days That Shook The World.
  2. cf. Isaac Deutscher, The Prophet Unarmed.
  3. cf. Any copy of Reed's book published after 1930 purged Trotsky from the narrative, despite the fact he is a main protagonist in the story.
  4. cf. Voline, The Unknown Revolution.
  5. cf. Deutscher.
  6. http://www.orwell.ru/library/essays/nationalism/english/e_nat