Israel Shamir

From RationalWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
"Middle East Expert"...? Oh, you're so funny, RT!
Parroting squawkbox
Icon pundit.svg
And a dirty dozen more

Israel Shamir, born Izrail Schmerler and known by the pseudonyms Jöran Jermas, Adam Ermash, Vassili Krasevsky, and Robert David, is a blogger involved with the leftist website CounterPunch and the activist group WikiLeaks. Shamir is presumably hawked by left-wing activists for his work with WikiLeaks and his commentary on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, not for his promotion of antisemitism and Holocaust denial or his praise of the Khmer Rouge. In 2010, the progressive blogosphere uncritically repeated Shamir's conspiracy theory that one of Julian Assange's Swedish rape accusers was a CIA plant. Since then, WikiLeaks and Assange's supporters have become very defensive whenever Shamir is brought up.


Ironically enough, Shamir claims to be an Israeli Jew. He claims to have been born in Siberia to Jewish parents, and claims to have emigrated to Israel in 1969, served as a paratrooper in the Israel Defence Force, and fought in the Yom Kippur War. He also claims to have studied law at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem and dropped out of his law studies to pursue a career in journalism. He claims to have worked for the BBC, Israel Radio, the Israeli newspapers Maariv and Haaretz, and the Soviet propaganda organ Pravda.[1] Shamir emigrated to Sweden in 1984 and claimed to divide his time between Sweden, Israel, and Russia. He also claims to have a residence in Jaffa. We keep saying "claims" because there are significant holes in Shamir's life story,[2] enough for pro-Palestinian commentator Norman Finkelstein to declare that Shamir "invented his entire personal history. Nothing he says about himself is true."[3] According to Shamir's account, he converted from Judaism to Orthodox Christianity in 2004.


According to Shamir, the Jews are to blame for pretty much everything. He claims that the mainstream press often takes sides with Israel because the "rich Jews buy media so it will cover up their (and their brethren's) misdeeds. The Jews in the media are giving protection to the rich Jews. ... In the US, even in Western Europe, no view can be proposed to the general public unless approved (after being vetted and corrected) by a Jewish group."[4] He believes a vast Jewish conspiracy exists pushing for global hegemony, writing, "Palestine is not the ultimate goal of the Jews; the world is. Palestine is just the place for world state headquarters; necessary, for otherwise the people of Europe wouldn't be magnetised like a rabbit in the headlights of a car."[5] A Russian-language book by Shamir, published in 2010, hawked The Protocols of the Learned Elders of Zion.

Shamir has written in defense of the Holocaust-denying pseudo-historian David Irving, saying that he was persecuted for his "denial of Jewish superiority", adding that, "Not only is Western Christian civilisation dead, but even its successor, secular European civilisation, has met its demise only a few days after its proud and last celebration by the Danish scribes. It was short-lived: about two hundred years from beginning to the end, the Europeans may once have had the illusion that they can live without an ideological supremacy. Now this illusion is over; and the Jews came in the stead of the old and tired See of St Peter to rule over the minds and souls of Europeans."[6]

Shamir was also booked as a speaker at the International Conference to Review the Global Vision of the Holocaust, the infamous Tehran gathering of antisemites and Holocaust deniers convened by Mahmoud Ahmadinejad's government in 2006. He shared the stage with Horst Mahler, a Neo-Nazi lawyer from Germany.[7] Shamir later spoke glowingly of the conference, saying, "Nobody – and I do mean nobody, including British, French, American, German, Russian leaders – really cares about the victims of a war long past, Jewish or otherwise; they pay tribute to the Holocaust as nations pay tribute to their vanquisher." He also wrote that the official narrative of the Holocaust serves as "a justification of [rich and powerful] minority rights over [oppressed] majority needs."[8] In a 2011 interview the Jewish Tablet magazine, Shamir repeatedly refused to acknowledge the atrocities committed at Auschwitz.[9] Elsewhere, he has described Auschwitz as "an internment facility, attended by the Red Cross."

Katha Pollitt from The Nation describes a visit to Shamir's website like this:

"I spent a few hours on and learned that: 'the Jews' foisted capitalism, advertising and consumerism on harmonious and modest Christian Europe; were behind Stalin's famine in Ukraine; control the banks, the media and many governments; and that 'Palestine is not the ultimate goal of the Jews; the world is.' There are numerous guest articles by Holocaust deniers, aka 'historical revisionists.'"[10]

Even though he has stated that the Jews are a "virus in human form" and that "it's every Muslim and Christian's duty to deny the Holocaust",[11] Shamir insists that he is not antisemitic or a Holocaust denier. When the British newspaper The Guardian and the Swedish tabloid Expressen made light of Shamir's history of ramblings about Jews, he said that the stories were "all lies. And all these lies are old and well-known and refuted years ago." He later stated that he does not deny the Holocaust per se but opposes it as a cultural element of modern Jewish identity that purportedly promotes "the Jewish claim of superiority and exclusivity."

In September 2012, the British socialist newspaper Morning Star posted a column by Shamir claiming that the international outrage over the Russian government's treatment of Pussy Riot was a "weapon against Putin" engineered by "oligarchs, big business, the media lords, the pro-Western intelligentsia of Moscow, and Western interests which naturally prefer Russia divided against itself." The Morning Star retracted the article hours later, saying it had been reprinted from CounterPunch "in good faith without knowledge of the author's background." Anti-fascist blogger Jim Denham noted that Shamir's original CounterPunch article contained a sentence absent from the Morning Star stating that "Western governments call for more freedom for the anti-Christian Russians, while denying it for holocaust revisionists in their midst." Shamir later accused the Morning Star of caving into "the pressure of the Jewish lobby."[12]

Also, in September, Shamir wrote a column defending Pol Pot and the Khmer Rouge regime, saying "The Pol Pot the Cambodians remember was not a tyrant, but a great patriot and nationalist, a lover of native culture and native way of life." He further claimed, "As for the mass killings, these are just horror stories, averred my Cambodian interlocutors."[13] The Phnom Penh Post sarcastically replied, "We must admit we were swayed when Shamir provided conclusive proof that the KR genocides were either inept or out-and-out fabrications: he alerted us to the fact that the population of Cambodia has doubled since 1970. We eagerly await his next Counterpunch article, 'Population of Europe has increased by a factor of six since 1939, therefore World War II never happened.'"[14]

Work with WikiLeaks[edit]

Assange and Shamir, in a photo published in 2011.

WikiLeaks spokesman Kristinn Hrafnsson confirmed in a Swedish radio interview that Shamir works with the group, along with "a lot of journalists that are working with us all around the world" who "have different roles in working on [the] project."[15] Shamir describes himself as an "accredited" freelancer for WikiLeaks, distributing the group's batch of leaked U.S. cables to Russian news organizations. Daniel Domscheit-Berg, a dissident former member of WikiLeaks, cited Shamir's involvement as one of the reasons he left the group; he described Shamir as a "famous Holocaust denier and anti-Semite" and claimed that Julian Assange wanted him to contribute under a pseudonym as to avoid "unwarranted attention." Shamir's son, a journalist named Johannes Wahlström — who himself has been accused of Anti-Semitism — is one of WikiLeaks' spokespersons in Sweden, producing a documentary on the group that aired on Swedish public television.[16][17]

Shamir has backed Assange in his extradition dispute with the British and Swedish governments. In September 2010, he co-authored an article on CounterPunch suggesting that one of the Swedish women who had accused Assange of rape was involved in a CIA plot to frame him for the alleged crime.[18] Despite Shamir's background and the fact that his story couldn't hold up to plausibility,[19] the article was held up by the likes of Keith Olbermann,[20] Bianca Jagger, and the liberal blog FireDogLake[21] as proof that the US was trying to extradite Assange from Britain through Sweden. Only after the story shot through the Internet like a bullet and potentially libeled the accuser did anybody bother to look into who had written it. Once information about Shamir's Jewish obsession came out, Olbermann sheepishly tweeted, "If the author of that article is a holocaust denier, I repudiate him and what he wrote, and apologize for retweeting the link."

Despite his work with WikiLeaks and reportedly close friendship with Assange, Shamir has done more harm for the group than good — and not just with his antisemitic polemics. Russian journalists have accused Shamir of fabricating some of the cables he distributed to cast Mahmoud Ahmadinejad in a sympathetic light. Others have accused Shamir of passing along sensitive cables to the dictatorial government of Belarus, potentially endangering opposition activists there.[22] Assange reportedly refused to investigate the matter, though a WikiLeaks spokesman said that Shamir's actions were "obviously unapproved." Blogger Richard Bartholomew noted that Shamir's rants against Pussy Riot contrast Assange's support for Pussy Riot.


Of course, other antisemites and Holocaust deniers have leaped to Shamir's defense in times of need. Gilad Atzmon, a saxophonist and extreme anti-Israeli activist, defended Shamir in a letter to the London Times, writing, "I would argue that Shamir’s exposure of some unacceptable Jewish religious perceptions is enormously important. I would argue as well that Jewish people would be the first to benefit from listening and reading Shamir." Also defending Shamir is Bishop Atallah Hanna, an Orthodox priest who apparently presided over Shamir's baptism and once voiced support for Palestinian suicide bombings.[23]



  • Путешествие в Египет, Тель-Авив (A Travel to Egypt, in Russian) Tel-Aviv, 1981.
  • Сосна и Олива, (Pine and Olive, in Russian), Wahlstrom Publications, Jerusalem – Stockholm 1987
  • Rasszista Allam? (Racist State, in Hungarian) Kairosz, Budapest 2004 ISBN 963-9484-90-3.
  • Flowers of Galilee (in English), Dandelion Books[24] 2004, ISBN 1-893302-78-4;
    • L’autre Visage d’Israël: Fleurs de Galilée, Éditions Al-Qalam, Paris 2004, ISBN 2-909469-43-3
    • Galilee Flowers (in English) BookSurge US 2005 ISBN 978-1-4196-1351-7
    • Galilee Flowers (in English, UK edition) Four O'Clock Press[25] 2007 ISBN 978-1-906146-43-6
    • Blommor i Galiléen: collected essays (in Swedish), translated by Ingvar Rydberg, Alhambra Publishing. ISBN 978-91-88992-52-9
    • Blumen aus Galiläa, (in German), Promedia Verlag, Vienna 2005, ISBN 3-85371-231-2.[26]
  • Our Lady of Sorrows, BookSurge US 2005 ISBN 1-4196-0835-5.
  • Проклятие избранного народа (The Curse of Chosen People, in Russian) Algoritm, Moscow 2006 ISBN 5-9265-0259-4
  • Cabbala of Power, Four O'Clock Press UK 2007, ISBN 978-1-906146-58-0
  • Masters of Discourse, BookSurge 2008 ISBN 978-1-4196-9243-7
    • La Bataille Du Discours, (in French) BookSurge 2008 ISBN 978-1-4392-1143-4
  • Сорвать заговор сионских мудрецов (Elders of Zion's conspiracy derailed, in Russian) Eksmo and Algoritm, Moscow 2010 ISBN 978-5-699-39520-0


  • S.Y.Agnon, Collected Stories, Gesharim, Jerusalem 2004 ISBN 5-93273-148-6.
  • James Joyce “Sirens”, “Cyclops” (chapters from Ulysses), “Raduga”, Moscow, 2000 ISBN 5-05-005113-4.
  • Herzog, Chaim (1982). The Arab-Israeli wars : War and peace in the Middle East. Random House. ISBN 978-0-394-50379-0. [27] republished Moscow 2004 ISBN 978-5-699-29953-9
  • Abraham Zacuto, The Book of Lineage, 608 pages, Zacuto Foundation 2006; ISBN 1-4196-1893-8 English annotated translation of medieval Hebrew chronicles.

See also[edit]


  1. Israel Shamir,, 15 January 2011, Royal Hunt of Julian Assange
  2. Israel Shamir exposed! A fake or a plant? 26.04.2005 Independent Media Center
  3. "His Jewish Problem - by Will Yakowicz > Tablet Magazine - A New Read on Jewish Life". Retrieved 2011-05-23. 
  4. Pardes, BookSurge LLC, 2005, ISBN 978-1-4196-0601-4, p. 31-32
  5. Pardes, BookSurge LLC, 2005, ISBN 978-1-4196-0601-4, p. 87
  7. Deutsche Welle, "Iran's Holocaust Conference Plan Prompts Anger". December 6, 2006. Retrieved November 10, 2010. 
  8. Israel Shamir. "'They Met In Tehran'". Retrieved November 4, 2010. 
  9. Will Yakowicz, Tablet Magazine, 17 May 2011, His Jewish Problem
  10. Katha Pollitt (22 December 2010). "The Case of Julius Assange". The Nation. Retrieved 16 February 2011. 
  11. ”Förintelsen är en avgud” – intervju med Israel Shamir, 11 August 2009
  12. Email Suggests Morning Star Asked Israel Shamir Personally for Permission to Publish anti-Pussy Riot Article. Bartholomew, Richard. 1 October 2012
  13. Pol Pot Revisited. Shamir, Israel. 18 September 2012.
  14. I see your counterpunch and raise you several shots to the foot. Phnom Penh Post. 21 September 2012.
  15. Michael C. Moynihan (December 14, 2010). "Assange's Extremist Employees". Reason magazine. 
  16. Magnus Ljunggren (10 December 2010). "Pappas pojke?". Expressen.
  17. Michael C. Moynihan (December 14, 2010). "Assange's Extremist Employees". Reason magazine.
  18. Assange Beseiged. Shamir, Israel and Bennett, Paul. CounterPunch. 14 September 2010
  19. WikiLeak founder's accuser probably did not work for the CIA. Elfrink, Tim. Miami New Times. 23 December 2010
  20. RT @BiancaJagger '#Assange “rape” accuser has #CIA ties'. 5 December 2010
  21. Assange Accuser Worked with US-Funded, CIA-Tied Anti-Castro Group. Murphy, Kirk James. FireDogLake. 4 December 2010
  22. Wikileaks, Belarus and Israel Shamir. Index of Censorship. 5 February 2011.
  23. Bishop Atallah Hanna on Israel Shamir, “Great Russian Thinker and Writer”. Bartholomew, Richard. 20 October 2012
  24. an "online publishing company". Dandelion Books, Online Book Publishing from Dandelion Books
  25. a defunct print-on-demand brand of Callio Press/Bookforce UK, not to be confused with the children's book publisher of the same name)
  26. (in German) Promedia Verlag, Shamir, Israel - Blumen aus Galiläa - vergriffen
  27. "Bibliography" (in Russian). The Russian Open University. Retrieved August 19, 2010.