Charles III

From RationalWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
A younger Charles admiring himself[1] in 1972
How an Empire ends
U.K. Politics
Icon politics UK.svg
God Save the King?
I think it's something that dawns on you with the most ghastly, inexorable sense. I didn't suddenly wake up in my pram one day and say 'Yippee, I —', you know.
—Charles III[2][3]

Charles III (or Charles Philip Arthur George Mountbatten-Windsor if you're an anti-monarchist) (1948–) is the ruling monarch of the United Kingdom (made up of England, Scotland, Wales and a bit of Ireland) and dependencies (Isle of Man, Channel Islands, Bermuda, Falkland Islands, Gibraltar, Pitcairn Islands, Saint Helena, South Georgia) and the head of state of the following sovereign states that constitute a subset of the Commonwealth of Nations known as the Commonwealth realm:

And that should worry you!


Eldest son of the previously thought to be immortal Elizabeth II, married to the late Princess Diana between 1981 until 1996, and married Camilla Parker Bowles in 2005. He has two sons: William, the Prince of Wales; and Harry, the Duke of Sussex. He finally got his hands on the crown at the age of 73, which makes him the oldest British monarch on accession.

Snake oil and crankery[edit]

Duchy Herbals Detox Tincture: artichoke and piss-a-bed (dandelion)
I happily talk to the plants and trees, and listen to them. I think it's absolutely crucial.[note 1]

Oh yes he does. Though to be fair, those ears could be capable of hearing things most others are not. That or the bit between the ears.

He supports and sold complementary medicines. Professor Edzard Ernst, Britain's first professor of complementary medicine, who spent eighteen years at Exeter University leading a unit that subjects alternative medicines to thorough scientific scrutiny, called Charles a "snake oil salesman"[6] for endorsing the "Duchy Herbals" detox tincture in partnership with Nelsons & Co.[7] The Medicines and Healthcare Products Regulatory Agency subsequently found that the products made false claims and had to have their advertising amended.[8] The products, which included a "detox" seem to have quietly dropped out of existence and are no longer to be found on the Nelsons website.

Charles also "treats" his farm animals with homeopathy.[9] In 2023 Charles appointed Michael DixonWikipedia to the head of the royal medical household. Despite having an actual medical degree, Dixon advocates for a variety of quackeries: homeopathy, "thought field therapy" and "Christian healing".[10] This, despite even the doctor of his ancestor, Queen Victoria, in 1853 calling homeopathy, "an outrage to human reason".[11]

He has promoted coffee enemas,[12] which have no known medical benefit but have numerous risks (burning, rectal perforation, infection and electrolyte imbalance).

As well as lobbying against GM crops,[13] Charles is also a fan of organic farming, which he believes is 'the future' for agriculture.[14] Incidentally, since 1990 he had a company called 'Duchy Original' which sold such products. While it could be lauded that the profits of such are donated to charity, people then recall it's a charity which promotes organic farming and other neo-traditionalist pet projects. It's this charity which amongst other things, took £1m from the Bin Laden family[15] and £2.5m from a former Qatari Prime Minister. This one personally. And in cash.[16] Said charities have also been spotted taking donations from dubious types on occasion.[17] There have also been allegations of 'donations for honours', particularly in regards to a Saudi gentleman who ended up with an CBE.[18]

Architecture and planning has also drawn his ire,[19] such as calling particular buildings 'carbuncles' and using his own influence and contacts to (sometimes) get his way.[20] Now, while some of the points raised are legitimate ones made by 'New Urbanists',Wikipedia it can be said his own alternative is a vaguely creepy, vapid neo-traditionalist edition.[21]

Charles has blamed scientific materialism for the decline of communal identity in Britain.[22]:253-254 He has argued for 'holistic' approaches, along the lines of Carl Jung and James Lovelock's Gaia hypothesis.[22]:307-308 He has said that he supports science-based medicine, but that it should be accompanied with 'healing', going so far as to have a private dinner for both medical practitioners and alternative medicine advocates that ultimately proved inconsequential.[22]:308-310 As Charles continued to promote this 'complementary' approach to medicine, he received pointed and public criticism from both medical practitioners and the press while receiving many personal letters from individuals supporting him.[22]:311,313 In response to the outpouring of letters, Charles was swayed by argumentum ad populum and confirmation bias:[22]:311

"I have never, ever had so many letters. I was riveted by this because while I was pretty sure I was going to stir up a hornet's nest — which I did I think — I also realised there was a great deal more interest in and awareness of this aspect than I'd imagined?" Concluding from this response that "people often remain silent about what they really think … they are terrified of saying something in case 'everyone' should think they are mad", he went on, "I find I feel this about a lot of things."

State interference[edit]

Me, meddle as a king? I'm not that stupid.
Been waiting for this day since about 1965...

As Prince, Charles often wrote to government ministers about matters that interest him. This would not normally be an issue, but he has been known to try to interfere in government policy.[24] The Information Tribunal ruled that the Government should release copies of his controversial "black spider" letters to Ministers in 2012, but the Attorney General vetoed the release, claiming that letting normal people read his views might damage his "ability to perform as King".[25] The ministerial veto enables ministers to ignore Tribunal rulings if they find them to be embarrassing contrary to the national interest. A later ruling by the UK Supreme Court in 2015 required the publication of the letters.[26] The failed battle to keep the black spider letters secret eventually cost the government £400,000 in legal expenses.[27]

In fact, he even has the right to prevent bills being presented to Parliament if they conflict with his business interests.[28] The Government is trying to cover this up,[29] too, as it touches on a wide variety of policy areas that King's ConsentWikipedia doesn't.

A spokesman for the (then) Prince said: "In modern times, the Prince of Wales has never refused to consent to any bill affecting Duchy of Cornwall interests, unless advised to do so by ministers. Every instance of the prince's consent having been sought and given to legislation is a matter of public record."[29]

Unsurprisingly, much worry has been (quietly) aired regarding whether Charles will effectively 'know his place' as a constitutional monarch[30]. However, as of 2024 it can be said at least publicly, he has 'behaved' as King[31] and has managed to 'steady the ship' somewhat during the transition between Elizabeth to himself[32], though the slide towards tacit republicanism (or perhaps more correctly described as 'monarchist apathy') continues[33], which to be fair might not be his fault, personally.


The Monarch is the formal head of the Church of England, with the title "Defender of the Faith", although administrative power resides with the Archbishop of Canterbury, who also crowns the monarch. Charles has spoken of being a "defender of faiths" who stands up for all religious people rather than purely defending Anglicanism against Popery (which was the historical role going back to the Protestant Reformation).[34] No mention of whether this includes atheism, though.

Other stuff[edit]

Is not-so-well known for his hauteur. Mainly due to his pretty controlling manner regarding his relationship with the press[35] which means the average British pleb never gets just how distorted the public image is. Veteran correspondent Jonathan Dimbleby once reported that the Prince "has accumulated a number of certainties about the state of the world and does not relish contradiction." Um, great.

See also[edit]

External links[edit]


  1. Talking to plants and expecting it to have some effect is a form of paranormal belief.[4]


  1. Charles III, Britain's conflicted new monarch (September 8, 2022) Reuters. "To detractors, the new king is weak, vain, interfering, and ill-equipped for the role of sovereign."
  2. I think it's something that dawns on you with the most ghastly, inexorable sense. I didn't suddenly wake up in my pram one day and say "Yippee," you know. (June 27, 1969) Time.
  3. "The Prince of Wales: Full text of replies in radio debut", The Times, 3 March 1969, p. 3.
  4. See the Wikipedia article on Plant perception (paranormal).
  5. Prince Charles Eavesdrops on Tourists, Speaks to Plants by Lee Ferran (September 20, 2010, 4:31 AM) ABC News.
  6. Professor calls Prince Charles, others "snake-oil salesmen", Reuters
  7. Latest News: Nelsons Manufactures New Duchy Herbals Range Of Traditional Natural Herbal Tinctures Nelsons (archived from February 18, 2009).
  8. Prince's firm told to amend ads by Aidan Jones (20 Mar 2009 20.01 EDT) The Guardian.
  9. Prince Charles: I use homeopathy in animals to cut antibiotic use by Sarah Boseley (12 May 2016 14.46 EDT) The Guardian.
  10. King Charles has appointed a homeopath. Why do the elite put their faith in snake oil? The aristocracy and celebrities are in thrall to medical quackery that while useless can be far from harmless by Martha Gill (17 Dec 2023 04.30 EST) The Guardian.
  11. Homoeopathy: BMJ Debates Homeopathy: 1990s or 1840s? (1999) BMJ 319:1115. doi:10.1136/bmj.319.7217.1115.
  12. Now Charles backs coffee cure for cancer: Angry doctors warn of dangers as Prince of Wales lends support to controversial alternative treatment by Jo Revill (26 June 2004 20.07 EDT) The Guardian.
  14. Prince Charles says the ‘very future of humanity’ may depend on organic farming as he warns ‘fertilizers and pesticides mean the world has only sixty harvests left’ by Rebecca English (22 June 2017) Daily Mail.
  15. Prince Charles accepted £1m from Osama Bin Laden's family (31 July 2022) BBC.
  16. Prince Charles: No inquiry into £2.5m cash donation to his charity (20 July 2022) BBC.
  21. Local History: Poundbury, BBC
  22. 22.0 22.1 22.2 22.3 22.4 The Prince of Wales: A Biography by Jonathan Dimbleby (1994) William Morrow and Company. ISBN 068812996X.
  23. Prince Charles: 'Me, meddle as a king? I'm not that stupid'. Heir to throne tells BBC 70th birthday interview he will desist from his hobbyhorses if sovereign by Caroline Davies (7 Nov 2018 19.01 EST) The Guardian.
  24. Prince Charles's letters to ministers should be disclosed, judges rule, The Guardian
  25. Attorney general blocks disclosure of Prince Charles letters to ministers, The Guardian
  26. UK Supreme Court require government to release Prince Charles 'black spider' letters
  27. 'Black spider memos': Second batch of Prince. Heir to the throne lobbied about homeopathy, rainforests and hospital food in 17 letters to ministers including Alan Johnson and Andy Burnham by Rob Evans & Robert Booth (4 Jun 2015 09.54 EDT) The Guardian.
  28. Prince Charles has been offered a veto over 12 government bills since 2005, The Guardian
  29. 29.0 29.1 Secret papers show extent of senior royals' veto over bills
  34. Prince Charles is "alarmed" by the radicalisation of young Muslim men, The Journal, Ireland, 8 Feb 2015