From RationalWiki
(Redirected from Comets)
Jump to navigation Jump to search
It's not rocket science, it's...
The Final Frontier
The abyss stares back

Comets are a specific kind of minor Solar System body that shed gas and particles when they get close to the Sun. As a result, a comet gets enveloped with an expanding hazy cloud (called a coma) and grows a tail pointing away from the Sun, driven by the solar wind. This increases its brightness several times, as the coma and the tail are much larger and reflect sunlight better than the comet nucleus (core) — the actual solid body of the comet.

As comets are thought to be composed of rock, dust, and ice (not only water, but also methane, ammonia, and other compounds), they are sometimes called "dirty snowballs" in popular-science media, though this may be misleading. The exact composition probably varies from comet to comet and "snowy dirtballs" may be a better description.


Most comets never become bright enough to be visible to the naked eye.

Most comets move on orbits with a very high eccentricity — either a very elongated ellipse, or a parabola or hyperbola.

Halley's Comet in 1910.
The string of Shoemaker-Levy fragments in May 1994.
Shoemaker-Levy impact sites on Jupiter.
Comet Hale-Bopp in 1997
Composite photo showing the path and expansion of Comet Holmes between October 2007 and March 2008

Comet woo[edit]


Young Earth creationists challenge Old Earth estimates of the age of the Solar System by arguing that as comets lose material when they approach the Sun, all comets must have disappeared by now if the Solar System was old.[1][2] This is partially true; comets do lose material and old comets have lost their volatile material and no longer produce a tail, but the number of comets that cross into the inner Solar System is constantly replenished from "stores" in the Kuiper Belt and the Oort Cloud at its edge. (This, of course, has prompted creationists to challenge the existence of these swarms.[3])

Harbingers of doom[edit]

Comets have a long history of being misinterpreted as portents of doom sent from the gods. In the Middle Ages scholars viewed comets as warnings from the Heavens that an "Act of God" (also known to the reality-based community as a "natural disaster") was about to take place, up to and including a plague epidemic.[4] The Medieval English scholar BedeWikipedia wrote in his treatise on natural philosophy De Rerum Natura that comets were like "stars with flames like hair. They are born suddenly, portending a change of royal power or plague or wars or winds or heat."[4]

According to legend, the AztecWikipedia emperor MontezumaWikipedia observed eight omens that supposedly heralded the coming of the Spaniards and the fall of the Aztec Empire.Wikipedia One of these portents of doom[note 1] was a "fire plume" that appeared suddenly in the night sky. The appearance of the fire plume was apparently a cause of great distress among the people of Mesoamerica.Wikipedia[note 2][5]

As there is no known physical process that can lead to comets millions of miles out into space affecting things here on Earth[note 3]; any claim that random chunks of space debris popping up in the night sky will lead to you getting sick can be safely dismissed.


Nostradamus directly mentions a comet once in his Prophecies, in quatrain 2:62:

Mabus puis tost alors mourra viendra,
De gens & bestes vne horrible deffaite,
Puis tout à coup la vengeance on verra,
Cent, main, soif, faim, quand courra la comette.

Mabus then will soon die, there will come
Of people and beasts a horrible rout:
Then suddenly one will see vengeance,
Hundred, hand, thirst, hunger when the comet will run.[6]

Expect this quote to be dug out every time a comet catches the attention of the conspiracy crowd. Nobody knows who "Mabus" is, though we're pretty sure it's not Dennis Markuze.

Notable comets[edit]


Halley's Comet (formally 1P/Halley) is probably the most well-known comet, as it is the only one visible with the naked eye that appears with some regularity. Its orbital period — about 76 years — is short enough to allow people to see it twice in their lifetime. There are records of its appearances since the third century BCE. During the spectacularly close approach in 1910, the Earth passed through its tail, sparking an end-of-the-world scare, as spectroscopy was applied for the first time to a comet and found cyanogen, a poisonous gas, in the tail. Some entrepreneurs took advantage of the situation and started selling "comet pills" and other comet counter-measures.[7]

Shoemaker-Levy 9[edit]

Comet D/1993 F2 (Shoemaker-Levy) broke up and collided with Jupiter in July 1994, leaving several spectacular "bruises" on its cloud layers. This was widely reported and raised some awareness about the possibility of a comet impacting Earth and may have been the inspiration for the Deep Impact/Armageddon movie pair a few years later.


Comet C/1995 O1 (Hale–Bopp) was a bright, spectacular comet that reached perihelion in 1997 and was widely observed around the world. It is notoriously connected to the Heaven's Gate UFO cult suicides. Two years earlier, Nancy Lieder claimed that the comet was a hoax to distract the attention from the incoming Planet X.[8]

C/2010 X1 (Elenin)[edit]

See the main article on this topic: Comet Elenin

An otherwise unremarkable comet that for some reason attracted the attention of the Planet X/Nibiru/2012 apocalypse crowd. After generating several terabytes of bullshit on conspiracy websites and YouTube videos, it made a lot of people look dumb even dumber when it didn't survive its close approach to the Sun. Rest in Pieces, you little comet!

C/2012 S1 (ISON)[edit]

Discovered in 2012, this comet attracted the attention of doom-mongers with the possibility that it might become extremely bright. (According to some scientific predictions, at one point as bright as the full Moon, if it survived perihelion.[9] This ultimately didn't happen, but as we know, comets are notoriously fickle.) Its perihelion was in November 2013, and people like James McCanney began piling on nice and early[10] and it looked like there would be a repeat of the Elenin hysteria. ISON mostly broke up at perihelion, and though a tiny remnant dragged on a bit longer, it eventually faded out.[11]


A run-of-the-mill comet of special interest just because it has been the destination of the European Rosetta missionWikipedia composed of an orbiter (Rosetta) and a lander (Philae) that landed on it in November 2014 (the first man made object that has landed on a comet). The mission was ended in September 2016, crashing Rosetta into the bone-shaped comet (no woo so far on this one).[12]

See also[edit]


  1. The earliest one in fact, occurring a full ten years before the Spaniards made landfall in 1519.
  2. If only they knew how right they were...
  3. At least without an asteroid impact.


  1. Old Comets -
  2. How good are those young earth arguments: Hovind's 'proofs' -
  3. Reality of Kuiper Belt and Oort Cloud -
  4. 4.0 4.1 "Comets, omens and fear: understanding plague in the Middle Ages" - The Conversation. Published June 24, 2020 at 4:59 PM (BST).
  5. "The Eight Omens of Montezuma and the End of the Aztec Empire" - Mexico Unexplained
  6. Text from here, no name of the English translator
  7. Fantastically Wrong: That Time People Thought a Comet Would Gas Us All to Death by Matt Simon (01.07.15 6:30 am) Wired.
  8. The relevant pages in the Zeta Talk website has been edited, but Google Groups has archived e-mails citing it.[1]
  9. Newly spotted comet may outshine the full moon, Short Sharp Science, New Scientist Blogs, 25 September 2012
  10. Comet C/2012 S1 (ISON) Sub- page,
  11. Comet ISON post-mortem - Bad Astronomy
  12. In Depth: Rosetta and Philae - NASA