Silver-level articleBernie Sanders

From RationalWiki
Jump to: navigation, search
Feel the Bern!
Guide to:

U.S. Politics

Icon politics USA.svg
Hail to the Chief?
Persons of interest

Bernard "Bernie" Sanders (born 1941) is the junior senator from Vermont. This political independent has in fact been a part-time Democrat throughout his political career.[1] Sanders was a candidate for the 2016 Democratic Party presidential nomination before he dropped out and endorsed Hillary Clinton for President.[2]

Sanders has become a powerful force in the Democratic Party since 2015.

Contents

[edit] Politics

We should look to countries like Denmark, like Sweden, and Norway, and learn from what they have accomplished for their working people.
—Bernie Sanders at the 2015 CNN Democratic debate in Las Vegas.[3]

Sanders runs as an independent, but caucuses with the Senate Democrats, describing himself as a "democratic socialist".[note 1] He agreed to vote with the party on all procedural matters in exchange for being assigned to committees as though a Democrat,[4] and filibustered for 8½ hours in protest at the renewal of the Bush tax cuts in 2010.[5]

He argues in favor of the Nordic social welfare model[6] and government-funded higher education at public universities.[7] Noted linguist and political activist Noam Chomsky calls Sanders "basically a New Dealer".[8] A committed civil libertarian, Sanders opposes the NSA's domestic surveillance programs[9] and believes Edward Snowden should be treated leniently:

The information disclosed by Edward Snowden has been extremely important in allowing Congress and the American people to understand the degree to which the NSA has abused its authority and violated our constitutional rights...
[10]

Sanders has been less effective than the average member of Congress at getting his legislation through Congress, who passes 1.4 bills a year. By comparison, he has been in the Senate for nine years but has sponsored only one bill that passed. Sanders also successfully amended bills 57 times in nine years. On a year-by-year basis, an average senator passed 7.4 amendments, but for Sanders that number is significantly below the mean, 6.3.[11] However, he had a strong reputation as a bipartisan deal maker when he was Veterans Affairs Committee Chairman.[12]

In February 2017, Sanders and Senator Ted Cruz faced off in a CNN-hosted debate over Obamacare.[13] Sanders won.

[edit] Leftist bona fides

Sanders was active in the civil rights movement and participated in Martin Luther King's March on Washington. As the Chairman of the University of Chicago branch of COREWikipedia's W.svg, he joined a sit-in against the University of Chicago and was arrested for resisting arrest.[14][15] A perennial candidate for leftist fringe parties in the 1970s, he ran as an independent in 1981 and became mayor of Burlington, Vermont, winning a four-way race by ten votes in the recount. He campaigned for Jesse Jackson's unsuccessful bids for the Democratic Party presidential nomination in 1984 and 1988.[16]

In 1990, Sanders defeated the incumbent Republican for Vermont's only seat in the House of Representatives, after a failed attempt two years prior. In 2006, he won his Senate seat in a tight race against the richest person in Vermont and was re-elected in 2012 with 71% of the vote (ironically, he was helped with donations from Hillary Clinton’s PAC). That year, he also argued in vain for Obama to be challenged in the Democratic primaries.[17][18]

Sanders continues to champion many of the same causes as he did in the 1970s and 80s such as income inequality, anti-racism and LGBT rights, currently holds a 100% approval rating with the NAACP and the NHLA (National Hispanic Leadership Agenda). He describes income inequality as the great economic, political and moral issue of our time,[19] and advocates a Scandinavian-style economic model for the US, including free public college tuition, universal healthcare, a higher minimum wage, and breaking up the big banks. Commenting on Pope Francis' call for a "just economy," Sanders said:

That message is also important for those of us living in the United States, the wealthiest nation in the history of the world. Why do the top .1 percent of our population own almost as much wealth as the bottom 90 percent? Why are 20 percent of our children living in poverty, the highest rate of childhood poverty of any major industrialized country on earth? Why do 35 million Americans still lack health insurance, with many more underinsured? Why are 51 percent of African-American high school graduates unemployed or under-employed? Why do we have more people in jail than any other country on earth? Why are millions of Americans working two or three jobs just to survive economically?[20]

Sanders has long criticized many aspects of US foreign policy, particularly the CIA's penchant for overthrowing the democratically elected leaders of other countries. Indeed, he once called for the agency to be abolished, but has demurred a bit on that during his presidential run.[21] In the 1980s, Sanders held a town hall assembly on US foreign policy with Noam Chomsky,[22] and traveled to Cuba to meet Fidel Castro, and to Nicaragua to meet Daniel Ortega, the Sandinistas' leader.[23] He also sent a letter to Margaret Thatcher denouncing her refusal to grant IRA members prisoner-of-war status.[24] In 1988 as Mayor of Burlington he tried to get it to be a sister city of Yaroslavl in the then-Soviet Union.[25]

[edit] Break with orthodoxy on the Israel-Palestine conflict

Sanders supports a two-state solution where both Israel and Palestine have international recognition.[26] He has consistently voted for military funding for the IDF, but — remarkably in US presidential election politics — has also repeatedly spoken out about the suffering of Palestinians. During a primary debate with Clinton in April 2016, Sanders described Israel's 2014 bombardment of Gaza as "disproportionate" and argued:

...if we are ever going to bring peace to that region, which has seen so much hatred and so much war, we are going to have to treat the Palestinian people with respect and dignity. Decimated houses, decimated health care, decimated schools. I believe the United States and the rest of the world have got to work together to help the Palestinian people. That does not make me anti-Israel. That paves the way, I think, to an approach that works in the Middle East.

As The New Yorker observed, such talk "represent[s] a striking departure from political orthodoxy" in a presidential campaign.[27]

[edit] But he's a Jew! He can't be pro-Palestine!

Despite Sanders' break with political orthodoxy on Israel, this hasn't stopped some, such as Black Lives Matter activist Marissa JohnsonWikipedia's W.svg, from criticizing Sanders over his relation to the Gaza crisis. Palestinian-American and journalist, Ali Abunimah, says Sanders isn't "very radical" in his views on Gaza and that his history on the issue is a mixed bag, but he currently is willing to reject the carnage Netanyahu inflicts on Gaza.[28]


Despite reports to the contrary, Sanders is not a citizen of Israel. However, lists which name Sanders as an Israeli citizen have originated among the far-right antisemitic side of the Internet for a while yet in order to play into the "dual loyalty" myth, which has led to some unintentional consequences with regards to a Diane Rehm interview with Sanders.[29]

[edit] LGBT rights

In 1972 and 1976, when Bernie first ran for office in Vermont, he was an outspoken ally of the LGBTQ community; as a plank of his platform, he proposed the abolishment of all discriminatory laws pertaining to sexuality.[30] In 1983, after he was elected to be mayor of Burlington, Bernie backed the city's first-ever pride march, saying that "in the state of Vermont, people have the right to exercise their lifestyles".[31] In light of Sanders' pro-gay record, the Human Rights Campaign have him a 100% approval rating in the 113th Congress[32] – an organisation which later supported Hillary Clinton for the Democratic nominee, and that Sanders later claimed (not without merit) was part of "the Establisment".[33]

Sanders generally opposed measures to ban gay marriage. He voted against the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA), one of only 57 people to vote against the measure in Congress – compared with 342 voting in favor in 1996.[34][35] However, Sanders' reasoning for opposing DOMA does appear to have changed over the years: his reasoning at the time was that the bill imposed on states' rights, a contrast to his later support for same-sex marriage nationwide.[36]

As both a congressman and later a junior senator from Vermont, he supported that state's 2000 civil union law and 2009 law legalizing same-sex marriage, the first time Sanders publicly spoke in favour of marriage equality for same-sex couples.[37] In 2011, Sanders said to the Advocate that: "I hope the president and all Americans join in supporting marriage equality", alongside a number of Democratic senators.[38]

In 2013, he co-sponsored the Uniting Families Act;Wikipedia's W.svg this bill was primarily intended to allow LGBT residents and citizens of the United States to bring their partners into America, just as members of opposite sex couples are able to do.[32] When the Supreme Court overturned DOMA in June 2015, Sanders ob praised the historic ruling that legalized same-sex marriage across the country.

[Same-sex marriage] is a victory for same-sex couples across our country as well as all those seeking to live in a nation where every citizen is afforded equal rights [...] I am very glad the Court has finally caught up to the American people.
—Sanders on the 2015 Supreme Court ruling legalising same-sex marriage.[39]

Sanders also voted against "Don't ask, don't tell" in 1993[40] and has been a vocal advocate for its repeal for a number of years,[41] voting to repeal the policy in 2010.[42] A video of Sanders defending people whom Republican Senator Duke Cunningham referred to as "homos in the military" has also gone viral.[43]

In 2009, Sanders also voted against an amendment prohibiting same-sex couples from adopting children.[44]

As somebody who has consistently voted to end discrimination in all forms — who voted against DOMA way back in the 1990s — I will do all that I can to continue our efforts to make this a nondiscriminatory society, whether those being discriminated against are transgender, gay, black or Hispanic.[45]

[edit] 2016 presidential bid

See the main article on this topic: 2016 Democratic Party presidential nomination

On 30 April, 2015, Sanders announced that he would seek the Democratic Party's nomination for president, running against Hillary Clinton. On the first day of his primary campaign, he raised more than $1.5 million from 35,000 people, and had 100,000 people register as supporters.[46] He pledged not to accept any money from super PACs or corporations, a pledge he kept.

The strength of Sanders' grassroots donor base was evident when a pro-Hillary super PAC ran a smear piece against him.[47] In response, Sanders emailed his supporters to ask for a $3 donation. He raised more than a million dollars in two days.[48][49] Sanders repeated the trick when his record on guns was attacked in an ad run by a Martin O'Malley super PAC. This time he raised $800,000.[50]

His campaign message largely focused on economic inequality, the corrupting influence of money in politics, and his opposition to the Trans-Pacific Partnership. He has stated that Middle Eastern countries should be the main force against ISIS. He has thus far focused on domestic policy, leaving his foreign policy agenda murky beyond a few grand outlines, like his moderate pro-Israel stance and his moderate anti-war position.

Sanders defeated Clinton by a wide margin in the New Hampshire primary.[51] On Super Tuesday, he won his home state of Vermont by over 70 points, as well as Minnesota, Colorado and Oklahoma. Clinton, however, crushed Sanders in the South, with decisive wins in Alabama, Arkansas, Georgia, Tennessee, and most notably, delegate-rich Texas.[52]

Unlike most other candidates in the 2016 presidential race from both major parties (especially his Democratic rival, Hillary Clinton), Sanders did not have many endorsements from office-holding members of his party, largely due to his political affiliation as an independent. Only one other Senator and nine sitting members of the House endorsed him,[53] including: Keith Ellison, Raul GrijalvaWikipedia's W.svg, Tulsi GabbardWikipedia's W.svg, Peter WelchWikipedia's W.svg, and Alan GraysonWikipedia's W.svg. It should be noted that in addition to the handful of federal officials, Sanders did enjoy some support from state representatives, primarily from Vermont, New Hampshire and Maine.[54]

Sanders' supporters pointed to aggregate polling consistently showing their man was the stronger candidate against Donald Trump, results that persisted through the primaries.[55] However, he was also a largely untested candidate to the general public, who were far more familiar with Trump or Clinton. Due to his far-left positions by American standards, which have historically been unpopular, his poor debating skills, and the vast amounts of opposition research the Republicans had against him,[56] it is doubtful that his poll numbers would have held up.

[edit] Minority voters

Cornel West, at a #BernieInAL Rally, by DW Nance 2

When the votes through Super Tuesday were tallied, Sanders was shown to be competitive or ahead with young people (of any race or gender), primarily those describing themselves as liberal or very liberal. He was, however, badly outpolled among both white and black voters in the South.[57][58] Sanders' extremely poor performance among older minorities would ultimately seal his fate.

During the Democratic debate in Brooklyn, Sanders said: "Secretary Clinton cleaned our clock in the Deep South, no question about it, that is the most conservative part of this great country. But you know what, we’re out of the Deep South now. And we’re moving up.” Nate Silver at FiveThirtyEight criticised this line of thinking,[59], though Sanders did, indeed, win many primaries outside of the South.

The Sanders campaign highlighted his endorsement of Jesse Jackson for president in 1988,[60] and pointing to pictures of him chaining himself to a black protester[61] and organizing Chicago sit-ins in 1962.[62] His upset win in Michigan gave supporters hope that his civil rights record was beginning to resonate with the black community, but Clinton's 83%-16% win in Mississippi meant she gained delegates overall despite losing Michigan.

Sanders' loss in New York effectively ended the race. Exit polls indicated that, although he won comfortably with under-40s, he was unable to overcome Clinton's lead with older voters, both women and blacks.[63] Sanders vowed to fight on, but finally announced he was "winding down" his campaign after losing the final primary in California by a wider than expected margin.

[edit] The "BernieBros"

It's likely that many disaffected voters who wanted Elizabeth Warren to run flocked to Sanders.[64] As Warren almost certainly would have done had she run, Sanders ran to the left of Hillary Clinton. Due to Clinton's deep unpopularity in some areas, especially the mountain states and West Virginia, Sanders also paradoxically picked up many more conservative Democrats, in many areas matching Obama's 2008 performance.

Bernie & Jane Sanders at at the Agriculture Center at the Arizona State Fairgrounds in Phoenix, Arizona. Photo taken by Gage Skidmore

Nevertheless, and borrowing from Clinton's '08 campaign playbook which slammed Obama supporters as "Obama Boys,"[65] some establishment Democrats and others such as Robinson Meyer, a writer for The Atlantic who coined the term,[66][67][68] claimed neo-reactionary "Bernie Bros"Wikipedia's W.svg were picking Bernie just because he wasn't a woman (Shillary).The Gawker-run blog site Jezebel has a write-up on this phenomenon,[69] and the Sanders campaign's concerns about them. This tactic unsurprisingly infuriated some female Sanders supporters:

There are literally millions of women who support Sanders over Clinton. A new Iowa poll yesterday shows Sanders with a 15-point lead over Clinton among women under 45, while one-third of Iowa women over 45 support him. A USA Today/Rock the Vote poll from two weeks ago found Sanders nationally “with a 19-point lead over front-runner Hillary Clinton, 50 percent to 31 percent, among Democratic and independent women ages 18 to 34.” One has to be willing to belittle the views and erase the existence of a huge number of American women to wield this “Bernie Bro” smear. [70]

Some of the examples of "BernieBros" were women, including conservative women who weren't Clinton supporters. Female Sanders supporters on Twitter were accused of being "functional" "bros" and the like, to try to redeem the tactic. But as one writer put it:

Not all Sanders supporters are dicks. Not all Sanders supporters have dicks. The mainstream left-leaning press’s attempts to insist otherwise are a shameful indictment of the fact that many of them are in the tank for Clinton—and they don’t like being called on it. [71]


Regardless, Sanders denounced any supporters of his who may be sexist.[72]

[edit] The "Sanders Effect," moving the party left

The Sanders candidacy and the enthusiasm behind forced Clinton to move somewhat leftward – or to at least speak that way – as the campaign season moved along.[73] Sanders was allowed to appoint five members to the committee charged with forming the DNC Party Platform in 2016, appointing such folks as Keith Ellison and Cornel West (a staunch Obama critic[74]).

The platform committee agreed to adopt many of Sanders' policies, and the Clinton camp offered several concessions: abolishing the death penalty, raising the minimum wage to $15 an hour, preserving and expanding Social Security, even reinstating an updated and modernized version of Glass-Steagall. [75] It did not include opposing the TPP, but it did include a caveat where any free trade deal would need to protect workers' rights and the environment if it hoped to pass with Democratic support. He was unable to get amendments that called for a policy imposing a tax on carbon and a national moratorium on fracking, and he could not get the committee to denounce illegal Israeli settlement building, but the committee agreed on supporting a two-state solution that guarantees Israel's security and Palestine's independence.

[edit] DNC convention

Once leaked emails showed that Debbie Wasserman Schultz had been biased against Sanders in the primary, she was forced to resign as head of the DNC.[76] Finally, just before he was to make his speech at the DNC Convention, Sanders supporters and Clinton delegates agreed to strip the autonomy of 2/3rds of superdelegates, forcing them to vote with how their states vote in the primary. [77]

[edit] Criticisms on...

To him, anybody who disagrees with him is a crook; there are no honest disagreements with people. Bernie's view of the world is that the great majority of the people agree with him on all the issues and the only reason he does not win is that the Congress is crooked.[78]
—Barney Frank writing about Sanders in 1991

With wingnuts accusing him of being the second coming of Stalin[79] and some far-left moonbats criticising Sanders for not being a True Socialist™[80] it can be hard to tell what criticisms of his policies are actually rooted in truth.

[edit] Foreign policy

His other foreign policy views are also muddled complex,[81] with votes against both Iraq wars, support for peaceful regime change in Libya,[82] and opposition to intervention in Syria,[83] but votes in favor of the NATO interventions in Afghanistan and Yugoslavia,[84] although his official campaign said that the latter was "begrudgingly".[85] For this, he was criticised by radical left groupings such as the Liberty Union Party,Wikipedia's W.svg where he was unironically nicknamed "Bernie the Bomber".[86]

He supported the Iraq Liberation Act which applied the disastrous sanctions on Iraq and demanded that regime change; this act set the precedent for Bush's invasion.[87] He also supports drone strikes as long as they are used effectively and selectively and do not target innocent people.[88] This makes his position essentially no different from Obama's or Clinton's.

He has not been able to produce a detailed plan of any kind when it comes to foreign policy,[89] whereas Hillary could at least claim four years as Secretary of State, whether you think she did a good job or not. In the PBS debate there was once more a focus on foreign policy, where Sanders said he is deeply critical of Henry Kissinger, calling him "one of the most destructive secretaries of state in the modern [American] history" whereas Clinton counts him as a friend and adviser.[90][91]

[edit] Gun control

His views on gun control are a concern for many who support universally increased measures, as he supports gun control for urban areas but not rural areas.[92][93] During the primaries, he quickly flipped his more pro-gun positions, which were more popular with his Vermont constituents. Clinton repeatedly criticized Bernie Sanders for voting in favor of PLCAA (The Protection of Lawful Commerce in Arms Act) a 2005 law passed with the support of gun companies and the National Rifle Association (NRA) that shields the gun industry from lawsuits when third parties "criminally or unlawfully misuse" their guns. Sanders has said he now supports repealing the law, but he continues to defend its key tenets.[94] He also voted against the 1993 Brady Bill which imposed a mandatory five-day waiting period because he believed that the federal government was overstepping its power.[95]

The NRA helped Sanders get elected in the 90s,[96] although they now rank his overall gun control record as a "D-",[97]. Apparently, he's actually quite pleased about this grade.[97]

In 2009, Sanders, by then a senator, voted to allow firearms in checked baggage on Amtrak trains, as an amendment to the congressional budget. The amendment passed.[98]

[edit] Immigration

While he supports immigration reform (including using "parole in place" in order to bring back already deported immigrants)[99] and detests xenophobia, his stance on open borders is that a huge volume of foreign workers would depress wages and threaten the welfare state and even the nation-state.[100] He voted against Ted Kennedy's bipartisan immigration reform in 2007[101] and for bipartisan legislation that could have allowed indefinite detention for immigrants,[102] though those bills are more nuanced than they appear, with various civil rights groups supporting and criticizing them.[103] He has said that immigration to the United States is a result of global poverty and hinted at support for reform of the role and behavior of the IMF and similar institutions.[104]

[edit] Financial deregulation

He has a long history of opposing deregulation (such as opposing the repeal of the Glass Steagall ActWikipedia's W.svg) but did vote for the Commodity Futures Modernization Act of 2000Wikipedia's W.svg which prevented the SEC from regulating the credit default swaps that helped cause the credit crunch of 2008.

[edit] His position regarding Communist regimes

Sanders has been criticized for lavishing praise on the Sandinista and Castro governments in the '80s.[105][106] Regarding the former, Sanders said in a 1985 interview, "Now, obviously, I will be attacked by every editorial writer in the [Burlington] Free Press with being a dumb dupe. Maybe I am. I was impressed by their intelligence and by their sincerity. These are not political hacks. You don't fight and lose your family and get tortured and go to jail for years to be a hack. They have very deep convictions."[107] When asked, while mayor of Burlington, whether he would condemn human rights abuses or curtailment of freedoms by left-wing regimes, Sanders responded by pointing out similar acts committed by the US government.[105]

[edit] Race

Even though his racial justice reforms are progressive,[108][109] indeed, his participation in the civil rights movement counts as a plus, he has come out against reparations for slaveryWikipedia's W.svg.[110] He has been slammed for signing Bill Clinton's Violent Crime Control and Law Enforcement ActWikipedia's W.svg of 1994, the single most influential piece of legislation on race issues he's been invloved with to date, which heavily incarcerated racial minorities, but he did try to amend it and supported it because of its inclusion of the Violence Against Women ActWikipedia's W.svg.[111]

[edit] 2016 presidential run

During Bernie's 2016 presidential run there were questions as to how he would succeed in getting Congress to agree to his highly ambitious (and in most cases, expensive) goals, especially should both houses of Congress remain in Republican control.[112][113] To his credit, he admitted that this would pose an issue, but said little about how he'd specifically deal with it, outside of requiring an unprecedented amount of outside support for his policies.[114][115]

His age would have made him the oldest person to take office as President, at 75; though this doesn't stand out as much as one would think since Trump, at 70, was also the oldest President to take office in the event.

[edit] Public health

Sanders supports cigarette taxes, but not soda taxes, and ponders the legality of tobacco cigarettes, but did not call explicitly for an outright ban.[116] This is ironic because Eric Garner was killed during an arrest for ostensibly selling cigarettes on a street corner, a black market created by New York's cigarette tax which is so high it effectively constitutes prohibition. In light of that, it's ironic that Sanders has advocated for the decriminalization of marijuana. While cannabis smoke is not as carcinogenic as tobacco smoke,[117] it can lead to many of the same maladies when smoked in similar quantities.

In 1998, the House of Representatives approved a compact struck between Texas, Vermont and Maine that would allow Vermont and Maine to dump low-level nuclear waste at a designated site in Sierra Blanca, Texas. Sanders, at the time representing Vermont in the House, cosponsored the bill and actively ushered it through Congress. Located about 16 miles from the Mexican border, Sierra Blanca’s population is predominantly of Mexican ancestry. At the time, the community was about two-thirds Latino, and its residents had an average income of $8,000, although the low-level nuclear waste included "items such as scrap metal and worker’s gloves… as well as medical gloves used in radiation treatments at hospitals." However, supporters of the bill, which included Bill Clinton and most Democrats in Congress, were not intending to simply dump the waste at random; it would have an officially planned site separated from the community. In the end, however, the Sierra Blanca site was rejected by the Texas state legislature.[118]

[edit] Woo

The manner in which you bring up your daughter with regard to sexual attitudes may very well determine whether or not she will develope (sic) breast cancer, among other things.
—Dr. Bernie Sanders in 1969.[119]

In terms of medicine, Sanders' views on vaccinations are clear and science-based.[120] However, his stance on and promotion of alternative medicine,[119] such as his 2013 sponsorship of a bill that would waste government dollars on totally ineffective and unsafe CAM[121] are rather alarming. In letters the 28-year-old Sanders wrote to the Vermont Freeman, Dr. Sanders also believed that cultural forces were driving Americans to illness and that sexual repression caused cancer.[119]

Sanders rejects climate denial,[122] but supports GMO labeling[123] (despite believing GMOs do not cause health problems),[124] something which some skeptics regard as a Trojan horse for the anti-GMO movement.[125]

In 2011, he called for a moratorium on the licensing of new nuclear plants and the relicensing of those currently in operation.[126]

[edit] Expensive weaponry

Even though Bernie Sanders has frequently pointed out that Hillary Clinton is more hawkish than he is, he has a much more complex history with the military-industrial complex than it at first appears. Most notably, he is supporting the development of the F-35 fifth generation fighter jet which costs $1.2 trillion and arguably of the biggest blunders in of the Pentagon. Some of these will be stationed and manufactured in Vermont.[127] During his 2012 reelection campaign, Sanders ran against a Republican who opposed the F-35 as a waste of resources. Sanders was all for it.[128] When it has come time to choose between defense jobs and a dovish defense policy, Sanders has consistently chosen to stand with the arms-makers rather than the peace activists. In 1985, for example, protesters massed at the General Electric plant in Burlington, Vermont, where Sanders was serving as mayor. They were protesting the fact that the plant was manufacturing Gatling guns to fight socialists in Central America. Bernie had the cops to go in and arrest the protesters.[128]

Despite being called a radical in the current American political spectrum, much of the criticism of Sanders’s foreign policy stances have come from his left flank. The World Socialist Web Site called Sanders a “silent partner of American militarism.” And Counterpunch, a left-wing magazine, has criticized Sanders on more than one occasion for being insufficiently pacifist, accusing him of behaving "more like a technofascist disguised as a liberal" who "never opposes any defense spending bill".[128]

[edit] Endorsement of Clinton

Hillary Clinton understands that we must fix an economy in America that is rigged and that sends almost all new wealth and income to the top one percent. Hillary Clinton understands that if someone in America works 40 hours a week, that person should not be living in poverty. She believes that we should raise the minimum wage to a living wage. And she wants to create millions of new jobs by rebuilding our crumbling infrastructure — our roads, bridges, water systems and wastewater plants.[129]
—Bernie Sanders

On July 12, Sanders reluctantly endorsed Hillary Clinton for President of the United States, knowing that it was better to unite against the then-presumptive GOP nominee Donald Trump,[130] citing some of Clinton's left-wing credentials:

In return, Clinton admired Sanders for "[bringing] people off the sidelines and into the political process", as well as "energiz[ing] and inspir[ing] a generation of young people who care deeply about our country".[132] For supporting Clinton, many Sanders supporters accused Bernie of being a sellout to the Democratic establishment (reviving the talk of Bernie Bros);[133][134] Jill Stein from the Green Party accused Sanders of attempting to "have a revolutionary campaign [with]in a counter-revolutionary party",[135] and Trump – who never sees a populist bandwagon he can't join – said that Sanders "has totally sold out to Crooked Hillary Clinton".[136]

However, during the primary, Sanders repeatedly criticized Clinton for her somewhat more right-wing and hawkish views: Hillary had adopted a more hawkish attitude towards the War on Terror, with a particular emphasis on increased mass surveillance methods and longer terrorist watch lists to supposedly defeat terrorism.[137] She has also:

In spite of the fact of being behind in the pledged delegate count and mounting pressure for him to drop out, Sanders refused to concede for quite some time, using his remaining leverage to influence the Democratic Party on legislative agenda, arguing that defeating Trump should not be their only goal.[146][147] However, Sanders later said that he would be willing to cooperate with Hillary Clinton in order to prevent a Trump presidency,[148] a promise he has since made good on (as seen above).

Concerns had been risen about there being a large number of so-called Bernie-or-bust voters; polls seemed to show that these people were but a significant minority.[149] Polling close to the election put the number of Sanders' core supporters who planned to vote for Clinton as high as 90%.[150] Clinton's loss in the election and her narrow margins in Pennsyvania Michigan, and Wisconsin, suggest the fears may have been right after all.

[edit] Would Bernie Have Won?

The unanticipated rise of Bernie Sanders' popularity can be seen as a continuation of a movement of social agitation that saw its first expression in Occupy Wall Street.[151] This movement of politically active young adults is grossly dissatisfied with the Democratic Party's politics and is pushing the national political discussion further left than many Democrats have been willing to go.

Many see Hillary Clinton's loss to a deeply unpopular candidate like Trump as indicative of the Democrats' inability to turn out votes on any level, municipal, state or federal. After Clinton lost to Trump, the pundit Matt Yglesias declared the party "a smoking pile of rubble":

Republicans control the House, and they control the Senate....

In state government things are worse, if anything. The GOP now controls historical record number of governors’ mansions, including a majority of New England governorships. Tuesday’s election swapped around a few state legislative houses but left Democrats controlling a distinct minority. The same story applies further down ballot, where most elected attorneys general, insurance commissioners, secretaries of state, and so forth are Republicans.

...the story of the 21st-century Democratic Party looks to be overwhelmingly the story of failure. [152]

In June of 2016, when it was clear that Clinton had secured the nomination, Rolling Stone's Matt Taibbi observed about the Sanders phenomenon: "This was a barely quelled revolt that ought to have sent shock waves up and down the party, especially since the Vote of No Confidence overwhelmingly came from the next generation of voters."[153]

They ought to be horrified to their marrow that the all-powerful Democratic Party ended up having to dig in for a furious rally to stave off a quirky Vermont socialist almost completely lacking big-dollar donors or institutional support....But to read the papers in the last two days is to imagine that we didn't just spend a year witnessing the growth of a massive grassroots movement fueled by loathing of the party establishment...

When Trump won the general election, angry Sanders supporters launched the meme "Bernie Would have Won," which went viral:

After the election, Sanders supporters raged against the DNC machine on Twitter, Tumblr and other social media sites. The "Bernie Would've Won" meme takes a myriad of forms, but all express the same idea: that Sanders, had he been given the chance, would have taken down Trump.[154]

Sanders played some political capital at the Democratic Convention, and "was given unprecedented say over the Democratic Party platform," [155] but the Congressional Black Caucus unanimously shot down his proposals for open primaries and the removal of superdelegates, a mechanism adopted by establishment Democrats to "protect" incumbents from the grassroots[156]. To what extent the Bernie contingent can effect desperately needed change in the party without these reforms remains to be seen. Democrats who want to win in the future, however, may have to accommodate the Bernie voters.

Poll after poll during the primaries indicated Sanders would have beaten Trump by wider margins than Hillary Clinton, which suggested that even though the polls predicting a Clinton win over Trump turned out to be wrong, that the larger margin of win Sanders consistently enjoyed would have meant victory. And indeed:

Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) would have beaten Donald Trump by a historic margin if he had been the Democratic nominee, according to a private pre-election poll provided to The Huffington Post. The national survey of more than 1,600 registered voters, conducted by Gravis Marketing two days before the general election, found that Sanders would have received 56 percent of the vote while Trump would have won 44 percent. The poll was commissioned and financed by outgoing Florida Congressman Alan Grayson, a Democrat who endorsed Sanders in the presidential primary. [157]

Unfortunately for Sanders, the Republicans had plenty of tricks up their sleeves for a Bernie nomination, which would have made for the most one-sided attack campaign since 1988:

Here are a few tastes of what was in store for Sanders, straight out of the Republican playbook: He thinks rape is A-OK. In 1972, when he was 31, Sanders wrote a fictitious essay in which he described a woman enjoying being raped by three men. Yes, there is an explanation for it—a long, complicated one, just like the one that would make clear why the Clinton emails story was nonsense. And we all know how well that worked out.[56]

Other attacks included:

  • The fact he was on unemployment until his mid-30's.[56]
  • His stealing of electricity from a neighbor when he couldn't afford it.[56]
  • His support of the Sandinistas and Castro, which would have cost him Florida.
  • His violations of campaign finance laws.[56]
  • The failure of his proposed healthcare system when it was attempted in Vermont.[56]
  • His vote for the 1994 Crime Bill.
  • His focus on college education, with fewer plans for non-college educated voters.[56]
  • His bill to send nuclear waste to a poor Hispanic community in Texas.

These factors could still put Sanders in a difficult position against Trump, perhaps still even lose. Though Trump himself had shrugged off several scandals, he was faced against someone else who was also perceived as dishonest and was covered in scandals, to be fair. Still, others have argued that it was Trump's anti-establishment rhetoric that helped him shrug off scandals to begin with, and that Bernie could more than match this:

So then, what undermines the power of right-wing populism? Progressive populism! By telling a more compelling story about the causes and culprits of working people’s economic woes, progressive populists like Bernie Sanders are able to seriously weaken one of the central pillars of the right-wing populist appeal. First of all, Bernie could equally wield the power of being an anti-establishment outsider candidate in a populist moment. As such Sanders was also uniquely positioned to go after Trump as a particularly scorn-worthy member of the billionaire class — to frame Trump as a poser who adorns himself with the superficial trappings of populism, while he enriches only himself.[158]

With so much debate over hypotheticals, you'd almost think whoever won would get to be President for real. But with no way to test their claims in an actual campaign setting, bloggers and pundits aren't likely to stop shouting at each other any time soon.

[edit] Notes

  1. Various sources have disagreed as to what Sanders means by this: does Sanders mean that he is a "democratic socialist", or that he is a Democrat and a socialist? Either way, it's probably more accurate to say that Sanders is a social democrat, given his support for the Nordic model. This may seem pedantic, but it does actually make a difference, especially when comparing to European politics – the rise of Jeremy Corbyn in the UK, for instance, as Corbyn comes from a traditional Labourite/socialist background
    "Bernie Is Not a Socialist and America Is Not Capitalist". The Atlantic. March 1, 2016.
    On the other hand Bernie Sanders supports employee ownership and workplace democracy, which are standard positions amongst libertarian-minded socialists so it seems that he's somewhere between the mainstream left and the radical left

[edit] See also

[edit] External Links

[edit] References

  1. "Is Bernie Sanders a Democrat?".
  2. Mollie Reilly. (12 July 2016). "Bernie Sanders Endorses Hillary Clinton For President". The Huffington Post.
  3. CNN, (13 October 2015). "(Democratic Debate) Bernie Sanders explains Democratic Socialism" – via YouTube.
  4. "Bernie Sanders confirms presidential run and damns America's inequities". The Guardian.
  5. "Sen. Bernie Sanders ends filibuster". Los Angeles Times.
  6. "What Can We Learn From Denmark?". The Huffington Post. 26 May 2013.
  7. "Actual socialist Bernie Sanders: No, Obama is not a socialist". rawstory.com.
  8. Noam Chomsky on Clinton vs Sanders "Noam Chomsky on Clinton vs Sanders". Upfront. (Al Jazeera English). January 30, 2016.
  9. http://www.nationaljournal.com/tech/president-bernie-sanders-would-dismantle-nsa-spying-20150501
  10. "Snowden deserves leniency, Sanders says".
  11. "Hillary Clinton was a more effective lawmaker than Bernie Sanders".
  12. "Congress’s only socialist becomes a bipartisan dealmaker," MSNBC.
  13. "Cruz, Sanders face off on Obamacare", CNN'.
  14. Chicago Tribune (22 February 2016). "Arrest photo of young activist Bernie Sanders emerges from Tribune archives". chicagotribune.com.
  15. "Here's What Bernie Sanders Actually Did in the Civil Rights Movement". Mother Jones.
  16. "Bernie Sanders meets with 'long-time friend' Jesse Jackson" observer.com.
  17. John Nichols (14 August 2011). "Bernie Sanders Talks Up Primary Challenge to Obama as ‘a Good Idea for Our Democracy and for the Democratic Party’". The Nation.
  18. George Zornick (19 February 2016). "Yes, Bernie Sanders Wanted Obama Primaried in 2012. Here’s Why.". The Nation.
  19. "The Urgency of a Moral Economy: Reflections on the 25th Anniversary of Centesimus Annus". 15 April 2016.
  20. "Bernie Sanders: I annotated a speech by Pope Francis".
  21. "Bernie Sanders once urged abolishing CIA - POLITICO". POLITICO.
  22. "Bernie Sanders + Noam Chomsky on Foreign Policy (5/20/1985)". 21 July 2015 – via YouTube.
  23. Clare Foran. "The Foreign Travels of Bernie Sanders". The Atlantic.
  24. Ishaan Tharoor (19 February 2016). "The angry letter Bernie Sanders wrote to Margaret Thatcher". Washington Post.
  25. "Burlington to get sister city". The Lewiston Journal. (Associated Press). August 23, 1988.
  26. CNN, Eugene Scott. "Sanders accuses Israel of 'disproportionate' response in Gaza".
  27. Cassidy, John (15 April 2016). "The Democratic Debate: A Surprising Exchange on Israel" – via The New Yorker.
  28. http://therealnews.com/t2/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=31&Itemid=74&jumival=16131>
  29. Elizabeth Jensen. "Diane Rehm And A Bungled Interview With Senator Bernie Sanders". NPR. June 12, 2015.
  30. Zaid Jilani. "Bernie Sanders Was for Full Gay Equality 40 Years Ago". (June 26, 2015). Alternet.
  31. Forgive him for the "lifestyles" comment: it was 1983!
    Paul Heintz. "32 Years Before SCOTUS Decision, Sanders Backed Gay Pride March". (June 30, 2015). Seven Days (Vermont).
  32. 32.0 32.1 "Bernie Sanders on LGBTQ rights", via FeelTheBern.Org.
  33. Charles Pulliam-Moore. Bernie Sanders is right: The Human Rights Campaign is definitely part of the 'establishment'. Fusion. (1/21/16, 9:26 AM).
  34. "Bernie Sanders Draws Distinction On Gay Rights". The Rachel Maddow Show (MSNBC: October 27, 2015) 10:58–16:48.
  35. Mark Hensch. "Sanders: I was ahead of the curve on gay rights". (06/27/15). The Hill.
  36. Jason Horowitz. "As Gay Rights Ally, Bernie Sanders Wasn’t Always in Vanguard". (November 27, 2015). The New York Times.
  37. Sam Frizell. "How Bernie Sanders Evolved on Gay Marriage" (October 28, 2015: Des Moines). TIME Magazine online.
  38. "Senators to Obama: Time to Evolve". (June 23, 2011). Advocate.
  39. "INSTANT VIEW 2-U.S. Supreme Court makes gay marriage the law of the land". (June 26, 2015) Reuters.
  40. "The Voter's Self Defense System".
  41. "Sanders Discusses Deficit Commission and 'Don't Ask, Don't Tell' (WCAX)" 3:45–4:15.
  42. "Public Notes on 10-HR1283".
  43. Zach Carter. "Watch Bernie Sanders Demolish A Republican Over 'Homos In The Military'". (02/22/2016). The Huffington Post.
  44. "House Votes on 1999-346".
  45. "I am Senator Bernie Sanders, Democratic candidate for President of the United States — AMA" – via Reddit.
  46. "Bernie Sanders on Twitter". Twitter.
  47. "A Pro-Clinton Super PAC Is Going Negative On Bernie Sanders". The Huffington Post. 15 September 2015.
  48. Alex Seitz-Wald (17 September 2015). "Bernie Sanders raises $1 million off Clinton super PAC attack". MSNBC.
  49. "Bernie Sanders Raises $1.2 Million Off Of Attack By Clinton-Allied Group". The Huffington Post. 17 September 2015.
  50. Jason Easley. "Bernie Sanders Raises $800,000 Off Of Martin O’Malley Super PAC Ad Attacking Him". politicususa.com.
  51. "US election 2016: Trump and Sanders win New Hampshire". BBC News.
  52. "Super Tuesday election results 2016 updates". Washington Post.
  53. https://berniesanders.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/Sanders-Publicly-Committed.pdf
  54. "Sanders Democrats". sandersdemocrats.com.
  55. "RealClearPolitics - Election 2016 - General Election: Trump vs. Sanders".
  56. 56.0 56.1 56.2 56.3 56.4 56.5 56.6 "The Myths Democrats Swallowed That Cost Them the Election" Newsweek.
  57. Philip Elliott / Charleston, S.C.. "Why Bernie Sanders Is Struggling to Win Over Black Voters". TIME.com.
  58. Janell Ross (4 February 2016). "Bernie Sanders’s real problem with black and Hispanic voters". Washington Post.
  59. "Clinton Is Winning The States That Look Like The Democratic Party". 15 April 2016.
  60. "19 Examples of Bernie Sanders' Powerful Record on Civil and Human Rights Since the 1950s". Alternet.
  61. "Shaun King- Bernie Sanders: HE'S CHAINED To 2 Black Women As They Resist Arrest In A Chicago Protest". democraticunderground.com.
  62. Kim LaCapria (4 March 2016). "TRUE: Bernie Sanders Sit-in Photos From 1962". snopes.
  63. Dan; Siddiqui, Sabrina; Gambino, Lauren (20 April 2016). "Hillary Clinton wins decisive victory over Bernie Sanders in New York primary", NBC: Huge Split Between Older and Younger Blacks in the Democratic Primary
  64. John Nichols (19 June 2015). "Ready for Warren Becomes Ready to Fight and Backs Bernie Sanders". The Nation.
  65. Obama boys, you see. Yes, she really did go there...
    "WOW. Before the "Bernie Bro," Clinton supporters created the "Obama boy." No, seriously.". Daily Kos.
  66. Hess, Amanda (February 3, 2016). "Everyone Is Wrong About the Bernie Bros; How a necessary critique of leftist sexism deteriorated into a dumb flame war.". Slate. 
  67. Meyer, Robinson (February 5, 2016). "It's Not Just Berniebros I coined the term—now I've come back to fix what I started.". The Atlantic. 
  68. Andrews, Natalie (February 8, 2016). "Bernie Sanders on Sexist Commenters: I Don't Want That Support". Wall Street Journal. 
  69. Joanna Rothkopf. "Bernie Sanders' Campaign Is Concerned About the 'Berniebro,' As They Maybe Should Be". The Slot.
  70. "The “Bernie Bros” Narrative: a Cheap Campaign Tactic Masquerading as Journalism and Social Activism". The Intercept.
  71. Clinton-Shilling Journalists Should Stop Slamming the Bernie Bros
  72. "Bernie Sanders Condemns Supporters' Sexist Comments About Hillary Clinton". The Huffington Post. 7 February 2016.
  73. "Has Clinton’s Move to the Left Backfired?".
  74. "Why Did Bernie Sanders Put an Obama-Hater on the Democratic Platform Committee?". 24 May 2016.
  75. "Democrats just approved a draft of their party platform, and Bernie Sanders' influence is clear".
  76. Dan Roberts in Philadelphia, Ben Jacobs in Washington and Alan Yuhas in New York (July 25, 2016). "Debbie Wasserman Schultz to resign as DNC chair as email scandal rocks Democrats". The Guardian.
  77. https://theintercept.com/2016/07/23/dnc-votes-to-keep-superdelegates-but-sets-some-conditions/
  78. "Edgeoforever✨‍ on Twitter". twitter.com. Retrieved on 18 July 2016.
  79. "Bernie Sanders Stint at 'Stalinist' Kibbutz Draws Red-Baiting From Right". Jewish Daily Forward. Retrieved on 18 July 2016.
  80. Martin, Patrick. "Where’s the socialism in the Sanders campaign?". World Socialist Web Site. Retrieved on 18 July 2016.
  81. "Biggest loser in Iowa was foreign policy". Mondoweiss.
  82. "Hillary Clinton says Bernie Sanders voted for regime change in Libya". @politifact.
  83. "Why Bernie Sanders Opposes U.S. Strike on Syria | The Progressive". progressive.org.
  84. "Bernie Sanders' Troubling History of Supporting US Military Violence Abroad". Alternet.
  85. "Bernie Sanders on NATO". FeelTheBern.org.
  86. Miller, Will (1999). "Bernie the Bomber's Bad Week". Liberty Union PartyWikipedia's W.svg.
  87. "Jeremy Scahill: Clinton is Legendary Hawk, But Sanders Shouldn't Get Pass on Role in Regime Change". democracynow.org. Retrieved on 18 July 2016.
  88. Hattem, Julian (30 August 2015). "Sanders: I wouldn’t end drone program". thehill.com. Retrieved on 18 July 2016.
  89. Just look at his website
  90. "Henry Kissinger’s War Crimes Are Central to the Divide Between Hillary Clinton and Bernie Sanders". The Intercept.
  91. Zack Beauchamp (12 February 2016). "Bernie Sanders is right: Hillary Clinton praising Henry Kissinger is outrageous". Vox.
  92. Matthew Rozsa. "The senator who won't shoot straight: What Bernie Sanders gets wrong about gun control". Salon.
  93. "Bernie Sanders on Gun Control". ontheissues.org.
  94. Beckett, Lois (14 April 2016). "'Small victory' for Sandy Hook families in battle to hold gunmakers to account". The Guardian. 
  95. "Did Bernie Sanders vote against background checks and waiting periods for gun purchases?". politifact.com. Retrieved on 18 July 2016.
  96. "How the National Rifle Association helped get Bernie Sanders elected". washingtonpost.com. Retrieved on 3 July 2016.
  97. 97.0 97.1 CNN, Dan Merica. "Where is Bernie Sanders' gun control plan?". CNN. Retrieved on 3 July 2016.
  98. "U.S. Senate: Roll Call Vote". senate.gov. Retrieved on 3 July 2016.
  99. "Bernie Sanders wants to bring back deported immigrants". usatoday.com. Retrieved on 18 July 2016.
  100. "Bernie Sanders on Immigrants: Silly, Tribal and Economically Illiterate". newsweek.com. 30 July 2015. Retrieved on 18 July 2016.
  101. "Sanders and immigration? It's complicated". POLITICO.
  102. "Hillary Clinton says Bernie Sanders supported Minutemen, indefinite detention for the undocumented". @politifact.
  103. "An Open Letter to Dolores Huerta". The Huffington Post. 24 March 2016.
  104. Vox, (29 July 2015). "Bernie Sanders: "Open borders? That's a Koch brothers proposal"". Retrieved on 18 July 2016 – via YouTube.
  105. 105.0 105.1 "When Bernie Sanders Thought Castro and the Sandinistas Could Teach America a Lesson". The Daily Beast.
  106. "Sanders Siempre: What Bernie Learned in Nicaragua". Seven Days.
  107. "Burlington Mayor Bernie Sanders: Interview After His Trip to Besieged Nicaragua". 27 June 2015 – via YouTube.
  108. "Bernie Sanders" Bernie Sanders.
  109. "Campaign Zero". Campaign Zero.
  110. Ta-Nehisi Coates. "Ta-Nehisi Coates on Bernie Sanders and Reparations - The Atlantic". The Atlantic.
  111. "Senator Sanders remarks on 1994 Crime Bill". Daily Kos.
  112. "The Five Nearly Impossible Challenges for Bernie Sanders and His Supporters". The Huffington Post. 7 May 2015.
  113. Chris Matthews (14 October 2015). "Jim Webb's right: Congress won't pay for Bernie Sanders' revolution - Fortune". Fortune.
  114. "Sanders: I won't be as naïve as Obama was with Congress". POLITICO.
  115. Heather. "Bernie Sanders Explains How He'd Deal With An Obstructionist Congress". Crooks and Liars.
  116. Interview Meet the Press Politico
  117. Melamede, Robert (18 October 2005). "Cannabis and tobacco smoke are not equally carcinogenic". Retrieved on 18 July 2016 – via PubMed Central.
  118. "Fact-checking a viral graphic critical of Bernie Sanders". politifact.com. Retrieved on 18 July 2016.
  119. 119.0 119.1 119.2 Sam Frizell. "Bernie Sanders' Long History With Alternative Medicine," Time Magazine. March 6, 2016.
  120. Ben Jacobs. "Gridlocked D.C. Finds Common Ground on Vaccines and Measles". Daily Beast. February 4, 2015.
  121. S. 852 (113th): Veterans' Health Promotion Act of 2013, GovTrack.us
  122. "Senator Bernie Sanders: Climate Change Is Real, Senator Inhofe Is 'Dead Wrong' (VIDEO)". The Huffington Post. 31 July 2012.
  123. "Senate rejects GM food labeling amendment to farm bill". the Guardian.
  124. "bernie-sanders comments on I am Senator Bernie Sanders, Democratic candidate for President of the United States — AMA". reddit.
  125. "NeuroLogica Blog » Should There Be Mandatory GMO Labeling?". theness.com. Retrieved on 18 July 2016.
  126. "US Sen. Sanders: Slow down on nuclear relicensing". Yahoo! News (March 21, 2011: Associated Press).
  127. AM, Jeff Stein On 2/1/16 at 6:00 (1 February 2016). "Is Bernie Sanders a Hawk on Foreign Policy?". newsweek.com. Retrieved on 18 July 2016.
  128. 128.0 128.1 128.2 Mak, Tim (9 February 2016). "Bernie Sanders Loves This $1 Trillion War Machine". thedailybeast.com. Retrieved on 18 July 2016.
  129. Bernie Sanders Endorses Hillary Clinton for President, The Wall Street Journal (full speech). Jul 12, 2016 11:35 am ET
  130. Roberts, Dan (June 24, 2016). "Bernie Sanders: I will vote for Hillary Clinton – to stop Donald Trump". The Guardian.
  131. (July 12, 2016). "Full text: Bernie Sanders endorses Hillary Clinton". Politico.
  132. Lee M. J.; Merica, Dan and Zeleny, Jeff (July 12, 2016). "Bernie Sanders endorses Hillary Clinton". CNN Politics.
  133. Leupp, Gary (July 14, 2016). "Don't Call Him "Bernie" Anymore: the Sanders Sell-Out and the Clinton Wars to Come". CounterPunch.
  134. (July 12, 2016). "'Bernie is a sellout': Sanders supporters blast him for endorsing Hillary Clinton". RT International.
  135. Gass, Nick (July 12, 2016). "Jill Stein shreds Sanders' Clinton endorsement". Politico.
  136. Donald J. Trump (12 July 2016). "Tweet Number 752859250628648962". Twitter. "Bernie Sanders, who has lost most of his leverage, has totally sold out to Crooked Hillary Clinton. He will endorse her today - fans angry!" 
  137. Kurtzleben, Danielle (June 13, 2016). "In Wake Of Orlando Shooting, Clinton Suggests Broader Terrorist Watch Lists". NPR.org. 
  138. Roberts, Dan; Gambino, Lauren (November 19, 2015). "Hillary Clinton calls for more ground troops as part of hawkish Isis strategy". The Guardian. 
  139. Golshan, Tara (July 18, 2016). "Trump on Pence's vote for the Iraq war: "He's entitled to make a mistake" On Clinton: "She's not"". Vox. 
  140. http://civilliberty.about.com/od/ussenators/p/hillary_clinton.htm
  141. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_positions_of_Hillary_Clinton#Anti-terrorism_and_domestic_surveillance
  142. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/hillary-clinton-death-penalty_us_56310eb4e4b00aa54a4c48c9
  143. Cabaniss, Will (September 2, 2015). "The fact-checker's guide to viral graphics contrasting Hillary Clinton, Bernie Sanders". PunditFact.
  144. http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2015/oct/14/hillary-clinton/clinton-says-her-keystone-xl-position-isnt-flip-fl/
  145. http://edition.cnn.com/2015/09/22/politics/hillary-clinton-keystone-pipeline-history/
  146. "Bernie Sanders just made it official—he isn't dropping out". motherjones.com.
  147. "Bernie Sanders offers a concession-style speech — without a concession". washingtonpost.com.
  148. Roberts, Dan (17 June 2016). "Bernie Sanders: I will work with Hillary Clinton to stop Donald Trump". The Guardian. 
  149. "Will Bernie Sanders supporters rally behind Hillary Clinton now? Here’s what we know.". washingtonpost.com.
  150. Kennedy, Kelsey (July 26, 2016). "Despite the Bernie-or-bust contingent, 90% of Bernie Sanders' core supporters now back Clinton". Quartz.
  151. http://www.telesurtv.net/english/opinion/Building-a-Movement-From-Occupy-Wall-Street-to-Bernie-Sanders-20160416-0023.html
  152. http://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2016/11/10/13576488/democratic-party-smoking-pile-rubble
  153. http://www.rollingstone.com/politics/news/democrats-will-learn-all-the-wrong-lessons-from-brush-with-bernie-20160609?page=3
  154. https://mic.com/articles/163185/the-bernie-would-ve-won-meme-what-is-it-where-did-it-come-from-and-is-it-true#.LYCD91TT7
  155. Sanders wins greater say in Democratic platform; names pro-Palestinian activist
  156. Debbie Wasserman Schultz, who would subsequently resign in disgrace as Chairman of the Democratic National Committee, told CNN's Jake Tapper: "Unpledged delegates exist really to make sure that party leaders and elected officials don't have to be in a position where they are running against grass-roots activists."We need more questions like this one from Jake Tapper to Debbie Wasserman Schultz
  157. New Pre-Election Poll Suggests Bernie Sanders Could Have Trounced Donald Trump
  158. [1]
  159. https://justicedemocrats.com/platform/
United States 2016 presidential election articles on RationalWiki
Topics: Affordable Care Act - Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission - DAESH - Gun control - Illegal immigration - Koch Industries - United States Electoral College - Trump's Wall
Parties: Democratic Party (primaries) - Green Party - Libertarian Party - Republican Party (primaries Convention Tea Party)
Candidates: Bush (R) - Carson (R) - Christie (R) - Clinton (D) - Cruz (R) - Huckabee (R) - Jindal (R) - Johnson (Lib) - Kasich (R) - Paul (R) - Perry (R) - Sanders (D) - Stein (Green) - Trump (R) - Walker (R) - Webb (D) Running mates: Kaine (D) - Pence (R)
Winner: Donald Trump
Personal tools
Namespaces

Variants
Actions
Navigation
support
Community
Tools