Destiny (person)

From RationalWiki
Jump to: navigation, search
Bonnell, in 2020, during a debate with Vaush.
Like and subscribe
YouTube
Icon YT bullshit.png
Up next
Not to be confused with the video game of the same name. If you were looking for the religious concept of destiny, see fate.

Steven Kenneth Bonnell II (1988–), better known by his online nickname Destiny, is a Twitch streamer and YouTuber. Though primarily a gaming channel, his YouTube channel has become better known for his centrist and neoliberal political content, initially debunking and criticizing Youtube conservatives and reactionaries, but then quickly began denouncing socialists and left-wing content creators in general. His moment of glory came in 2017 when he exposed JonTron’s white nationalist sympathies in a online debate, but since then has made a habit of occasionally engaging in apologetics for far-right personalities.

General positions

Below are a few examples of Destiny's centrist and neoliberal views:

  • Throughout his debates, he consistently summarizes his philosophy as "rules-based utilitarianism".[1]
  • He supports neoliberal, capitalist,[2] and free trade policies.
  • Bonnell believes that voter ID laws are inherently racist.[3]
  • He used to hold a generally favorable view of Black Lives Matter,[4] but later switched his position during the George Floyd protests, and claimed that police brutality can sometimes be justified, and has outright actively incited violent crackdowns and massacres against Black Lives Matter activists.[5][6][7]
  • Destiny’s YouTube content was initially pro-trans, especially since he strongly argued against Ben Shapiro’s conflation of sex and gender.[8] However, he has repeatedly defended TERF activists such as Harry Potter author J.K. Rowling against accusations of transphobia, and argued that Rowling's comments are likely caused by ignorance instead of genuine hatred.[9]
  • He used to frequently use ableist slurs in his videos,[10] but has since claimed he is trying to phase these words out of his vocabulary because he does not like the idea of using a group of people to mean something “bad”, comparing it to using derogatory terms for non-heterosexual people.[11]
  • He supports the European Union and its federalization into a superstate as part of globalization.[12]
  • He does not believe in the existence of natural human rights, and he instead claims that the only rights that exist are the ones that a government will grant and protect.[13]
  • He has a generally hostile and conservative view regarding increasing the national minimum wage to $15 and beyond, claiming that rapidly increasing it would invariably hurt small businesses who may not be equipped to pay such a high amount. He has argued that tying minimum wage to inflation would be positive, however.[14]

Debates and other shenanigans

The good

Destiny has debated many alt-right personalities and their useful idiots, including JonTron,[15] Lauren Southern,[16] Nick Fuentes,[17][18] and Sargon of Akkad.[19][20][1] Former alt-right sympathizers, most notably Caleb Cain (Faraday Speaks, currently a leftist YouTube content creator), credit Destiny and ContraPoints, among others, for their de-radicalization and shift away from conservative extremism.[21][22] In an attempt to balance out debating far-rightists and far-leftists, he has also debated some BreadtubersWikipedia/LeftTubers, including Ben Burgis,[23] Mike from PA,[24] NonCompete,[25] and his former friend[26] Vaush. Finally, he has debated Nazbol Caleb Maupin[27] and Peter Coffin,[28].

Destiny is a formal proponent of social justice, primarily focusing on the rights of minority groups, including trans people.[29]

The not-so-good

In November and December of 2020, Destiny led a canvassing operation to help Raphael Warnock and Jon Ossoff win their important Senate races in Georgia,[30] but upon arrival, he realized that he did not have any reliable voter data and campaign infrastructure, and was left completely unprepared for the event. When asked to pay for staff time and management with an organization that could help, he stubbornly refused any assistance.[31] After the Democrats swept both Senate seats in Georgia, he decided to canvass for Mark Gudgel, a Democratic Party candidate for the Mayor of Omaha, Nebraska, which is Destiny's hometown. However, Destiny's past quickly damaged his legitimacy, and Gudgel promptly rejected Destiny's support due to his controversial past comments and actions, especially his incitement of violence against Black Lives Matter protesters and activists.[32]

The bad

NonCompete: If they're hungry, why not just give them food? Why not just-

Destiny: Because this fantasy world where we can have maximum production to get everybody houses, food, clothing, it doesn't exist. It's not possible.

NonCompete: Six times more empty houses in the United States than there are homeless people. We throw away-

Destiny: Wait, how do those two numbers connect at all? What does that have to do with anything at all?

NonCompete: Why should anybody be homeless when we have empty house-

Destiny: I don't know what an empty house has to do with a homeless person. Are you going to steal those houses from people who own them, or what?

NonCompete: Yes, why not?

Destiny: Okay, I mean I'm not... it's strange that as an anarcho-communist, you're telling me that the state needs to seize property from other people. I don't understand! [laughs for 5s][33]

Expectably for someone who spends so much of their time criticizing notable right-wingers and anti-SJWs, Destiny has garnered a sizable leftist fanbase, but in spite of that fact, he openly hates the leftist portion of his fanbase for not fully agreeing with his neoliberal politics, and even went as far as to say:

What God do I have to pray to to get rid of my lefty following? I'd almost rather have fashies at this point, ugh.[34]

Oh sorry also by "lefty" I meant commies and shit, not just people who are progressive/lean left.[35]

In December 2020, he had a acrimonious barfight with @RespectableLaw on Twitter, taking a section of an LSAT practice test to prove that it was extremely easy to become a lawyer, and he even changed his Twitter profile picture and description to claim that he earned an implausibly high score of 184 on the test despite the highest possible score being 180, although this was likely done as a joke.[36] He was subsequently suspended from Twitter for evading his permanent ban on the website.[37] In addition, Destiny repeatedly claimed that the CIA had nothing to do with Pinochet's coup against Salvador Allende in Chile,[38] despite the CIA itself explicitly admitting its main role in triggering the coup and sabotaging Chile's economy.[39] In April 2021, Destiny engaged in a live online debate with a Marxist economist and professor named Richard D. Wolff, where he was absolutely trounced by the professor, having demonstrated his absolute cluelessness about the basics of Marxian economics and socialism, and demanded that Wolff must explain basic terms for him, much to his embarassment.[40]


The ugly

In September 2020, Destiny's long-standing partnership with Twitch.tv was terminated for inciting violence and illegal conduct after defending the Kenosha shooter,Wikipedia and he openly called for Black Lives Matter protesters to be shot to death by far-right militias:[41]

The rioting needs to fucking stop. If that means white redneck militia dudes mowing down dipshit protesters that think they can torch buildings at 10 PM, at this point they have my fucking blessing. Holy shit, this shit needs to stop. It needed to stop a long time ago.[42]

Destiny made a particularly embarrassing blunder during a debate with anarcho-communist Emerican 'NonCompete' Johnson, where he trivialized and outright denied the atrocities and war crimes committed by American soldiers in Vietnam in the direct presence of his Vietnamese co-host and current wife, Luna Oi.[43] In addition, despite its well-known history as a racist slur, Destiny wrote a 10,000-word manifesto claiming that the use of the word nigger in private among people who are not black is justified.[44]

See also

External links

References

  1. 1.0 1.1 Your positions are COMPLETELY unfounded ft. Sargon of Akkad from the YouTube channel Destiny 2 March 2019
  2. The capitalist arc of my streaming career from the Youtube channel Destiny 28 May 2019
  3. Voter ID Law Debate with Fan from the YouTube channel Destiny 17 September 2017
  4. Police Brutality & Black Lives Matter - Debate with Twitter User from the YouTube channel Destiny 27 January 2018
  5. Was shooting him justified? from the YouTube channel Destiny 24 April 2019
  6. Daniel Park, Twitch Legal Department Unpartners Destiny After 'Encouragement of Violence'. gamerant.com, 12 September 2020.
  7. Twitch streamer Destiny loses partnership for "encouraging violence" GINX Esports TV 12 September 2020
  8. Are Sex & Gender the Same Thing - Ben Shapiro Video Review from the YouTube channel Destiny 2 January 2018
  9. IS JK ROWLING A TERF? from the YouTube channel Destiny 2 January 2020
  10. Talking About JonTron, Sargon, My Emotional Well-being and More from the YouTube channel Destiny 22 May 2017
  11. Twitch Streamers talk about Ableist and Homophobic Slurs from the YouTube channel “Sabor” 18 August 2019
  12. Why I support the EU from the YouTube channel Destiny 6 February 2019
  13. You can't keep begging the question with that statement... - Destiny Debates Adam Kokesh from the YouTube channel Destiny 4 August 2019
  14. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yd8Lm2owIJQ
  15. Debating JonTron from the YouTube channel Destiny 13 March 2017
  16. Debating Lauren Southern on immigration from the YouTube channel Destiny 16 January 2017
  17. Debating Immigration with Nick Fuentes from the YouTube channel Destiny 9 November 2017
  18. Immigration Debate with Nicholas J. Fuentes from the Youtube channel Destiny 26 September 2017
  19. Debating @Sargon_of_Akkad from the YouTube channel Destiny 2 December 2016
  20. Discussions with Sargon of Akkad, Take 2 from the Youtube channel Destiny 19 March 2017
  21. The Making of a YouTube Radical The New York Times 8 June 2019
  22. My Descent into the Alt-Right Pipeline from the YouTube channel Faraday Speaks 21 March 2019
  23. This is not a healthy positive direction to head in... - Destiny Debate on Socialism ft. Ben Burgis from the YouTube channel Destiny 16 July 2019
  24. This is the dumbest thing I've ever heard... - Destiny Debates Mike from PA from the YouTube channel Destiny 19 August 2019
  25. This feels so idealized… - Destiny Debates NonCompete from the YouTube channel Destiny 14 August 2019
  26. Why I Burned the Vaush Bridge - Debate w/ Xanderhal from the YouTube channel Destiny 15 September 2020
  27. This isn't strengthening your arguments... - Destiny Debates Socialism ft. Caleb Maupin from the YouTube channel Destiny 3 September 2019
  28. "You ran away from every SINGLE point" - Destiny Debates Peter Coffin ft. The Serfs from the YouTube channel Destiny
  29. I think that social justice is a real thing. We have made a ton of progress so far... From Destiny's website
  30. I'm Getting Involved in Politics and Heading to Atlanta from the Youtube channel 'Destiny' 16 November 2020
  31. https://twitter.com/zei_squirrel/status/1336133078130044933
  32. Chris Bowling, After Cutting Ties with Controversial Streamer, Gudgel Staying in Mayoral Race The Reader, 5 Mar. 2021
  33. https://twitter.com/biggestjoel/status/1348513667155963906?s=20
  34. Destiny-chan on Twitter[a w] 1 April 2019
  35. Destiny-chan on Twitter[a w] 2 April 2019
  36. https://twitter.com/RespectableLaw/status/1336513127769403392
  37. https://twitter.com/JordanUhl/status/1336723956129259520
  38. https://www.reddit.com/r/uncensorstiny/comments/kdrezg/curb_your_wiki_destiny_on_pinochet_and_the_cia/
  39. https://nsarchive2.gwu.edu//news/20000919/01-13.htm
  40. Destiny Vs. Richard Wolff: Capitalism Vs. Socialism
  41. Daniel Park, Twitch Legal Department Unpartners Destiny After 'Encouragement of Violence'. gamerant.com, 12 September 2020.
  42. Twitch streamer Destiny loses partnership for "encouraging violence" GINX Esports TV 12 September 2020
  43. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cJqmSw2S31w
  44. https://www.reddit.com/r/Destiny/comments/dmjb18/clarifying_some_previous_events/