Information icon.svg Consider taking the RationalWiki Community Survey 2017 or see the results.

God's Not Dead 2

From RationalWiki
Jump to: navigation, search
Our Feature Presentation
Films and TV
Icon film.svg
Starring:

God's Not Dead 2[1] is the long awaited sequel to the Christian propaganda film God's Not Dead, as if it needed a sequel. Released on April 1st, 2016, sources have confirmed that (unfortunately), it was not an April Fool's Joke.Do You Believe That? The film has grossed a telling amount of $23 million worldwide.[2] Much to no one's surprise, it has a much coveted 9% rating on Rotten Tomatoes,[3] making it Rotten. Despite this, The Emoji Movie still somehow managed to do worse, scoring 8%.[4]

Plot[edit]

In this film, Sabrina the Teenage Witch Grace Wesley (Melissa Joan Hart) is an AP History teacher who mentions Jesus to a student in class. She is then sued by Leland Palmer Pete Kane (Ray Wise), who now works for the ACLU despite -- or, in this universe, because of -- basically being a figure of pure evil. A cast of people you might dimly remember from old TV is bulked out by Robin Givens (Head of the Class) as an evil school administrator and Jesse Metcalfe (Desperate Housewives) as a nice lawyer. All your favorite characters from the first film pop up again, now even more extremist. Real-life Christian apologist J. Warner Wallace appears as a witness in the trial, plugging his book, Cold-Case Christianity. Some subplots include a former college blogger getting convinced by anecdotal evidence that prayers can be answered, and Martin Yip, a college student getting disowned by his father for being a Christian. In the end, Grace wins the lawsuit after Tom Endler (Jesse Metcalfe), her defense attorney portrays Grace as a hostile witness. Needless to say, the plot bombs.

Portrayal of atheists[edit]

You would think that they would have made atheists seem less evil in the second movie than the first. However, it seems like they have yet to learn the difference between atheism and misotheism. In this film, atheists are portrayed as mean, selfish, and militant douchebags who believe God is Dead™ and that Christians are evil. Pete is portrayed as an evil lawyer who is such an atheist that he believes that the loss of a single lawsuit will somehow result in secularism ending. Martin's father is also portrayed as cruel, selfish, and just a complete asshole. It is important to point out that most atheists do not behave this way, and that any people that do are not representative of the entire atheist population, contrary to what this movie tries to prove.[citation NOT needed]

It is interesting to note that the two films have messages that completely contradict each other. In the first film, the evil atheist professor (at a university) is the villain for forcing his personal beliefs on the students. However, in the second film, the Christian teacher (at a public school) is the hero for sticking up for her beliefs, "Standing with God and being judged by the world", as she says in the movie. So, while the message of the franchise is not "don't force your beliefs on your students," it's really a more simple and less nuanced idea: Christians=good, atheists=bad. And while not forcing your ideas on someone is great, it's also exactly what this film does. We're not sure how they managed to keep two conflicting things in their heads like this.

Critical judgement reception[edit]

Critics noted that the film was slightly more competent than the original, with Ray Wise in particular giving an entertaining performance, and generally more of an idea about basic things like structure, despite thumping its audience with a leaden and implausible one-note message no more advanced than the original.[5] Variety concluded that it operates at the level of your average middle-school play – except with far greater levels of upside-down logic and bald-faced intolerance for anyone not enraptured by the New Testament.[6] And yes, the Newsboys are back with more terrible Christian rock.

Three-quel?![edit]

David A.R. White (Hey Scotty!), co-founder of PureFlix, has confirmed the making of God's Not Dead 3, which is speculated to tackle the Johnson Amendment. God help us all. We're gonna need it.

In a nutshell[edit]

See also[edit]

References[edit]