American Independent Party

From RationalWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
1969 AIP membership card
God, guns, and freedom
U.S. Politics
Icon politics USA.svg
Starting arguments over Thanksgiving dinner
Persons of interest

The American Independent Party was the third-party electoral vehicle for the 1968 presidential campaign of George Wallace, who carried five southern states running on an openly segregationist platform, and split the vote enough in several other states that typically voted Democratic to give the election to Richard Nixon. His main goal was to throw the election to the House of Representatives, which has not happened since 1824, where he would give his votes to whichever candidate promised to stop desegregation.

Because it failed to do this, Wallace returned to the Democratic Party and sought the Democratic nomination unsuccessfully in 1972 and 1976, while the American Independent Party (AIP) became an increasingly fringy hangout for John Birchers and washed-up segregationists in subsequent presidential elections. In 1972, the American Independent Party nominated Bircher John G. SchmitzWikipedia of California, who did poorly and carried no states at all, with his highest vote percentage being 9.3 percent in Idaho. The AIP split into two factions (southern segregationists in the American Independent Party, Birchers in the American Party) for the 1976 and 1980 elections and faded off into history. New Right leader Richard Viguerie, disillusioned with the Republican Ford/Rockefeller ticket, tried taking over the AIP in 1976 and ran for its presidential nomination. Still, the nomination, instead, went to segregationist and former Georgia governor Lester Maddox. Their 1980 candidate was former Louisiana congressman John Rarick. Both campaigns went nowhere. Meanwhile, the splinter American Party nominated another Bircher, Thomas J. Anderson, as their 1976 nominee, and Percy Greaves in 1980.

The American Independent Party is still active only in California and gave Alan Keyes their ballot line in 2008. A related "Independent American Party" has ballot lines in Arizona, Nevada, and Utah and now serves as the state chapter of the radical conservative Constitution Party. The Nevada IAP was founded by AIP founder Bill Shearer, who also led the California AIP during the 1980s and was chairman of the Constitution Party from 1996 to 1999. The Arizona and Utah IAP is a different party founded in 1998, which also claims its roots in the original AIP but no actual succession from that party. The "America's Independent Party" is a new party founded by Alan Keyes supporters in 2008. It is separate from any of the above AIP/IAP organizations. Still, its presidential ticket, Keyes, and vice presidential running mate Wiley Drake, were placed on the California AIP ballot line much to the frustration of Constitution Party nominee Chuck Baldwin, who sued the California AIP over giving their ballot line to Keyes instead of himself.

In the 2008 U.S. presidential election, the chairman of the AIP, Markham Robinson, filed a lawsuit seeking to exclude a presidential candidate from the California ballot on the basis that they were born outside the United States. Was this more birtherist nonsense directed at Barack Obama? Surprisingly not. Instead, the lawsuit targeted John McCain, on the basis that he was born in the Panama Canal Zone and, thus, was ineligible to be POTUS. However, a federal judge threw out the case, since the Constitution only requires a candidate to be a "natural born citizen", which includes those born outside of the United States to a parent or parents who are citizens (at least according to modern legal interpretations; the original document doesn't elaborate on what exactly "natural born" means). Furthermore, when McCain was born, the Panama Canal Zone was still US territory.[1]

In the 2012 Presidential election, they were equally confused. Tom Hoefling of America's Party (and the former political director of Alan Keyes' America's Revival, for additional apostrophe sales) took the party's place on the ballot in California, Colorado, and Florida, with a write-in candidacy possible elsewhere; he came 8th nationally.[2] In 2016, they sounded out Donald Trump in case he didn't quite make the Republican #1 spot.[3]

Many members of the current American Independent Party, probably even most of them, are registered by accident.[4] These are people who tried to sign as an independent (as in unaffiliated with any political party) but checked the wrong box and accidentally joined a wingnut far-right party. Whoops.

See also[edit]


  1. Judge says McCain is a 'natural-born citizen' (September 18, 2008, 12:21 AM EDT) The Associated Press, published through NBC News
  2. See the Wikipedia article on Tom Hoefling.
  3. There's Still Time for a Serious Third-Party Presidential Run (sic), Russell Berman, The Atlantic, April 6, 2016
  4. Are you an independent voter? You aren't if you checked this box by John Myers, Christine Mai-Duc and Ben Welsh (April 17, 2016) Los Angeles Times