Innocence of Muslims

From RationalWiki
Jump to: navigation, search
The film's outlandish depiction of Muhammed.
Unfortunately, the films critical of Islam are made by the people who absolutely don't know how to make films. I have been waiting for decades to watch an Islamic version of ‘Life of Brian.’ Where are our Pythons?
Taslima Nasrin[1]


Inventing "The Other"
Islamophobia
200px-Icon islamophobia.png
Fear And Loathing

Innocence of Muslims, also known as Innocence of bin Laden,[2] is an unwatchably bad extremely informative (read: prejudiced) Islamophobic film notable for inspiring violent protests and riots in the Islamic and Western world during September-October 2012. The film was made by a Coptic Christian fraudster and drug dealer named Nakoula Basseley Nakoula, although it was previously attributed to a non-existent Israeli-Californian real estate developer, whose name was variously given as "Sam Bacile", "Sam Bassiel", and "Sam Bassil",[3][4][2] to express and spread his belief that "Islam is cancer."[5] This goes to show you that not even progressive Southern California cities are immune to crazy Islamophobia. Pastor Terry Jones, who previously burned the Qu'ran in public and sparked mass riots from Islamists, has come out in support of the film, and regularly played it at his megachurch.[6]

The film's content[edit]

Trailers for the film, including one that lasts for nearly fourteen minutes, have been posted online. As a work of cinema, Innocence of Muslims is characterised by its rock-bottom production values, awful dialogue, melodramatic acting, poor direction, crude overdubbing, horrendous costumes and special effects, blatant inaccuracies, and sloppy editing. On at least one occasion, an actor completely flubbed his lines and nobody bothered to re-take the shot. The film also has horrid green-screening, with actors superimposed onto a generic and static image of a desert. Amazingly, despite Innocence of Muslims' disastrously low quality, this film supposedly cost over five million dollars to make.[5]

Innocence of Muslims itself is a puerile, bigoted, and grossly inaccurate biography of Prophet Muhammed and his early followers, who are portrayed as brutish despots, hedonistic gluttons, sadistic mass murderers, perverted philanderers, and child molesters. The movie starts out with a exaggerated depiction of the reportedly increasing persecution of Coptic Christians in Egypt, as Muslim fundamentalists burn and pillage many homes and businesses owned by Copts, including a private clinic, whose doctor and family had to flee to their home, and the Egyptian police is portrayed as completely indifferent to the violence, standing motionless and never intervening as entire communities are burned by Islamist rioters. Later on, the doctor in question reports that the police has supposedly arrested 1,400 Christians, tortured them, and forced them to "confess to the killings". When his horrified daughter asks why are the policemen doing that, he accuses them of "protecting Islamic crimes". He then goes off the rails and writes a crude diagram stating that "Man + X = BT", with BT being overdubbed as "Islamic Terrorist". His daughter then asks him what does X mean, to which the doctor replies: "You'll have to discover that for yourself.", with the implication being that X is Islam. The movie then cuts way back into the past, depicting Muhammad supposedly being born 4 years after his father died in pre-Islamic Arabia, and explaining the story of his life and his followers in the defamatory and vulgar style mentioned above, with Muhammad himself depicted as a greedy and gluttonous Lothario with seemingly endless sexual appetite.

Among other obscure actors and performers, it features a gay porn star named Tim Dax,[7] and an actor trying to channel Michael KelsoWikipedia as the lead role of Muhammad. While movies can be surprisingly expensive to make, even hilariously crappy ones like The RoomWikipedia, the idea that such an obviously cheap and poor quality screed could cost over five million dollars to make is very hard to swallow.[8][9] It is however possible that a full movie doesn't even exist in any finished form due to Nakoula's long history of fraudulent schemes, and the only things ever produced were the trailers posted on YouTube to make a wingnut statement against Muslims.[10][11] Even so, Innocence of Muslims' possible lack of existence has not prevented people from having strong feelings either for or against it.

People involved with the film's production[edit]

The US lost a lot of money and a lot of people in wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, but we’re fighting with ideas.
—Sam Bacile, or whatever he's calling himself these days[5]

Early reports mentioned that "Sam Bacile" identified himself as a wealthy real estate developer and an Israeli Jew, but later on Steve Klein, a Christian fundamentalist who worked with him on the project, referred to the filmmaker as a Coptic Christian, and he also confirmed that the name "Sam Bacile" is just a pseudonym. It was eventually confirmed that the manager of the company that produced the film is a Coptic Christian immigrant named Nakoula Basseley Nakoula, later renamed to Mark Basseley Youseff, and he gave that name when appearing on his court trial, so this is likely to be his real name.[12] Basseley whatever has a long history of fraud and drug-related convictions, including tax evasion for his gas station businesses, attempting to manufacture methamphetamine to pay off his debts, and stealing several Social Security accounts, even one belonging to a 6 year old child.[13] Nakoula was eventually arrested on September 28th, 2012, and sentenced to 1 year in prison for breaching his probation conditions by using the Internet to distribute Innocence of Muslims and claiming a fake name, though some of the court proceedings were undisclosed to the public.[12]

Steve Klein, a religious extremist who has past involvement with far-right hate groups, incited protests, vandalism, and violent riots against abortion clinics, Mormon temples, and mosques, and was directly involved in training and recruiting fundamentalist Christian paramilitaries, is acting as Nakoula's main spokesman, and has actively promoted the movie across America.[14] Large chunks of the movie are clearly overdubbed by different actors to add in anti-Islamic content, even though it was shot in English, and members of the cast later went on the record to denounce Nakoula for taking advantage of them, and emphasized that they had no idea they were starring in an anti-Islamic movie, having been given completely different lines for a movie called "Desert Warrior".[15] Despite being deceived and tricked by Nakoula to star in Innocence of Muslims, the cast members have received numerous death threats from Islamists, had difficulties with getting new careers, and faced financial problems and public humiliation due to their infamous reputation by starring in the movie.[16]

Violent protests and riots in the Middle East and North Africa[edit]

The film allegedly had a brief run in a single Hollywood cinema in July 2012 under the name "Innocence of Bin Laden",[9] but the trailer became an instant "cult classic" when an Arabic translation was posted to YouTube by a Coptic Egyptian activist.[17] Fortunately, Islam is known as the religion of peace, so Muslims around the world calmly criticized the inaccuracy and poor quality of the trailer and roundly mocked its director for producing such a piece of schlock, then moved on with their lives.

Ha ha, just kidding. Turns out that the "religion of peace" spiel is just a deceptive slogan, and Muslims react violently against "blaspheming" Muhammad and Allah. Salafist supporters of extremist Sharia law used the film to gain popularity amidst mass protests and riots against its "heretical" and Islamophobic content.[18] On September 11th, 2012, violent riots broke out in front of the American embassy in Cairo and at a consulate in Benghazi, Libya, where the American ambassador John Christopher Stevens and several other people were murdered in a coordinated terrorist attack by Ansar al-Sharia, an Islamist terrorist organization that used the protests as camouflage to ambush the embassy.[19] The epidemic of attacks and riots near American embassies spread to several Middle Eastern and North African nations as the unrest intensified, alongside angry demonstrations and protests in the rest of the Arab World.[20] In Sudan, the German and British embassies were also attacked and torched by Islamist rioters,[21] and large protests flared up on September 14th, 2012, as other Muslim countries also experienced attacks and arson against Western embassies.[22] Pakistan's government was forced to block Internet access to YouTube to try to curtail the spread of the movie's content, as the protests and riots against Innocence of Muslims continued to escalate throughout the Muslim world and the death toll skyrocketed.[23]

On September 21st, 2012, the French anarchist and leftist satirical magazine Charlie Hebdo also published cartoons that mocked Muhammad and Islamist fundamentalists, fueling further riots and violence. The protests against Innocence of Muslims continued to spread, as many other American and Western embassies and businesses got attacked by rioters, and even cinemas and theaters were set on fire by Islamist extremists,[24] as civilian casualties continued to steadily rise.[25] To top it off, a wingnut Pakistani minister outright promised a bounty of US$100,000 to anyone, including the Taliban and Al-Qaeda, who murdered Nakoula, the director of the film. The minister, Ghulam Ahmad Bilour, considered this a "sacred duty of Islam",[26] and he also demanded the passage of laws that criminalize "blasphemy" and "insulting our prophet."[27] In response to the riots, President Barack Obama called on all Islamic leaders to speak out against and bring an end to violence and extremism in a speech to the United Nations General Assembly.[28]

In retrospect, the protests and riots against Innocence of Muslims resulted in more than 50 deaths and hundred of injuries across the world,[29] and while only a minority of the people in the countries affected were actively involved in the protests, significant Islamist pressure groups such as the Muslim Brotherhood have manipulated the protesters to destabilize secularist governments. The protests and riots also made it far harder for the new democratic governments that arose after the Arab Spring to stabilize and consolidate their legitimacy, and helped contribute to the eventual downfall of many such governments to autocrats in the so-called "Arab Winter". After Nakoula was arrested and jailed for breaching his probation conditions, the protests and riots finally fizzled out.

Egyptian death sentences against the movie's cast[edit]

Under the Muslim Brotherhood-affiliated government of Mohammed Morsi, an Islamic court in Cairo sentenced seven Egyptian citizens involved with the film to death for "blasphemy". Tried in absentia, they would have faced the death sentence if they were to ever return to Egypt. After Abdel Fattah el-Sisi's military coup against Morsi and a mass crackdown on the Muslim Brotherhood and conservative Islamists, the death sentences were eventually overturned.[30]

Free speech concerns[edit]

Many people have been murdered, all in response to an unwatchable Internet video titled “Innocence of Muslims.” Whether over a film, a cartoon, a novel, a beauty pageant, or an inauspiciously named teddy bear, the coming eruption of pious rage is now as predictable as the morning dawn.
Sam Harris' commentary on the Innocence of Muslims riots, September 19th, 2012.[31]

Sam Harris and other secularists see the Innocence of Muslims riots as part of a larger pattern where Islamist extremists violently react against a wide range of legitimate criticisms of Islam. Before the nature of his convictions was made public, there was concern that Nakoula was arrested to appease Muslim fundamentalists rather than his past criminal history, and fears that the American government has sent a message that they are prepared to compromise free speech to appease Muslim extremists for the sake of public order have become widespread. Other activists in the US who have actively criticized Islam may fear that similar such "excuses" will be found to persecute them too.[32]

Contrary to public fears, the BBC correctly deduced that the American Constitution mandates that the authorities are to permit the film to be shown regardless of the nature of its content.[33] Several jurists have suggested that the film is not constitutionally protected speech in the U.S., because it appears that Nakoula, Steve Klein, and other producers of the movie have knowingly intended to put people's lives and property at risk. Indeed, the timing of the trailer's release, rougly two weeks before the 11th anniversary of the 9/11 terrorist attacks by al-Qaeda, suggests deliberate provocation against the entire Islamic faith. However, while it is true that the First Amendment does not protect speech that is intended to incite imminent violence, very few Constitutional scholars and lawyers supported the notion that Innocence of Muslims could fail to be protected by the "imminent violence" standard and any other legal theories.[34][35]

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. No Country for Women: God’s soldiers! 15 September 2012
  2. 2.0 2.1 CNN: New details emerge of anti-Islam film's mystery producer/index.html 14 September 2012
  3. Insert your own pun here.
  4. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/09/13/innocence-of-muslims-filmmaker-nakoula-basseley-nakoula_n_1880706.html
  5. 5.0 5.1 5.2 Breaking News: Anti-muslim filmmaker goes into hiding 12 September 2012
  6. Staff and crew of film that ridiculed Muslims say they were 'grossly misled'
  7. http://joemygod.blogspot.com/2012/09/gay-porn-actor-tim-dax-talks-to-us.html
  8. Weigel: Who is Sam Bacile? 12 September 2012
  9. 9.0 9.1 Inside Movies: 'Innocence of Muslims' mystery: Who is Sam Bacile? September 12 2012
  10. Does 'Innocence of Muslims' Actually Exist?
  11. Is Anti-Muslim Film a Hoax?
  12. 12.0 12.1 Innocence of Muslims Filmmaker Nakoula Basseley Nakoula Sentenced to Year in Jail
  13. US identifies anti-Muslim filmmaker
  14. Steve Klein & 'Innocence Of Muslims': Film Promoter Remains Outspoken On Islam
  15. CNN, Actor: Anti-Islam filmmaker 'was playing us all along'. 17 Sept. 2012
  16. An Actress From ‘The Innocence Of Muslims’ Is Suing Google For A Cool $124 Million
  17. NBC News: Questions swirl around anti-Islam film blamed for Egypt protest, attack in Libya 12 September 2012
  18. Middle East Response to “Innocence of Islam” Film Why Are US Embassies Under Attack
  19. New York Times: Obscure Film Mocking Muslim Prophet Sparks Anti-U.S. Protests in Egypt and Libya 11 September 2012
  20. AP: Protestors Storm US Embassy in Yemen.
  21. BBC News: US embassies attacked as anti-Islam film protests escalate 14 September 2012
  22. Protests over anti-Islam film: As it happened
  23. Anti-Islam film: Thousands protest around Muslim world
  24. 'Innocence of Muslims' Protesters Torch Theaters as Riots Escalate in Pakistan
  25. Pakistan film protests: 15 die in Karachi and Peshawar
  26. Anti-Islam film: Pakistan minister offers bounty
  27. Anti-Islam film: Pakistan minister's bounty condemned
  28. Obama's UN General Assembly speech condemns extremism
  29. Death, destruction in Pakistan amid protests tied to anti-Islam film. CNN, 21 September 2012.
  30. CNN: Egyptian court orders death sentences over anti-Islam film
  31. On the Freedom to Offend an Imaginary God
  32. Appeasing thugs by trampling our rights
  33. Film protests: What explains the anger?
  34. https://popehat.com/2015/05/19/how-to-spot-and-critique-censorship-tropes-in-the-medias-coverage-of-free-speech-controversies/
  35. http://www.thefacultylounge.org/2012/09/innocence-of-muslims-and-free-speech.html