The Great Replacement

From RationalWiki
(Redirected from Great Replacement)
Jump to navigation Jump to search
We're going to link this as many times as we goddamn have to.
Not to be confused with white genocide, which is the same garbage without the philosophical window dressing.
Frogs, clowns, and swastikas
Icon altright.svg
Rebuilding the Reich, one meme at a time
Buzzwords and dogwhistles
Some dare call it
Icon conspiracy.svg
What THEY don't want
you to know!
Sheeple wakers

The Great Replacement (French: Le Grand Remplacement), called "replacement theory" by Tucker Carlson in an attempt to reframe the conspiracy for his more moderate audience, is a racist, Islamophobic, anti-semitic, white nationalist, far-right genocide conspiracy theory originating in France, which asserts that the white Christian population of Europe, North America (United States and Canada), and sometimes Australia, New Zealand, and South Africa "is being systematically replaced with non-European people", specifically Muslims through mass immigration and low birth rates. All this is caused by a global élite gang of conspirators, probably based in Brussels, or, for the more racist theorists out there, the Jews. The theory is used interchangeably with the white genocide conspiracy theory.

A study done in May of 2022 showed almost a third of all adult Americans believe in some aspects of the Great Replacement.[1]


The phrase originates with a 2012 book called The Great Replacement (Le Grand Remplacement) by French writer Renaud Camus.Wikipedia[2] However, the same idea dates back earlier in the United States to a 1947 book by Theodore G. BilboWikipedia titled Take Your Choice: Separation or Mongrelization. Bilbo was a racist KKK Democrat demagogue from Mississippi who was Governor and then Senator of the state.[3] Roots of the replacement hoax arguably extend a century back, propagated then by white supremacist eugenicists Madison Grant, Lothrop Stoddard,Wikipedia and Albert Johnson.Wikipedia[4]

Camus started out promoting white gay separatism in books such as Tricks: 33 Stories; according to Musab Younis:[5]

Being fucked by Arabs, Camus felt, was passé: what mattered above all was same-race, same-sex intercourse and the extinction of difference: white men who identified as gay should fuck white men, and do so in conspicuously gay spaces.

Camus based his racist theory on ideas put forward in the 1972 book The Camp of the Saints,Wikipedia a novel by Jean Raspail, which describes "mass immigration destroying Western civilization" (and which enjoyed a renewed burst of popularity around 2011), and the Eurabia conspiracy theory. He formed the curiously-named political party "Party of No-harm" (French: Le Parti de l’In-nocence), which pushes a mix of left- and right-wing policies to no electoral success.[6] Today, Camus is the acceptable face of anti-immigrant and anti-Muslim politics, appearing "plausibly high-minded, principally aesthetic, even well-mannered"; historian Mark Lilla called him "a kind of connective tissue between the far right and the respectable right".[7]

Why it's BS[edit]

One of the most common talking points is that the number of non-White babies born has been increasing. This requires that the listener ignore the definition of "White", relying upon an extremely racist form of special pleading known as "the one-drop rule". The child of a White man and Black woman is considered "non-White", but it would be just as easy to classify the child as "non-Black". If you have a town that's made up of 50% Irish and 50% Italians, and everyone marries randomly, a quarter of couples will be Irish-Irish and another quarter Italian-Italian, whereas half will be Irish-Italian; assuming everyone has an equal chance of giving birth, "non-Irish" people will make up 3/4ths of the next generation, yet "non-Italian" people also make up 3/4ths of the next generation. If we repeat the process, only 1/16th of the third generation will be "pure"-Italian, and of the 4th generation, just a mere 1/256th. But to any reasonable person, the town is still half Italian.


The slogans "You Will Not Replace Us" and the more blatantly antisemitic and racist "Jews Will Not Replace Us" used by alt-right protestors during the violent Charlottesville riots in Charlottesville, Virginia, USA has been associated with, and is ostensibly derived from, The Great Replacement conspiracy theory.[8]

Fuel for domestic terrorism[edit]

Christchurch terrorist manifesto[edit]

See the main article on this topic: Christchurch terrorist attacks

Brenton Harrison, the Australian-born perpetrator of the Christchurch terrorist attacks, named his manifesto after this theory.[9] Although the manifesto contained numerous references to the Great Replacement theory, the majority of the manifesto consists of a mix of unrelated white nationalist talking points and alt-right propaganda taken from the internet. The reaction to the manifesto attracted attention to other groups using comparable rhetoric, and led to Facebook banning white nationalist propaganda from their platform.[10]

El Paso terrorist manifesto[edit]

Patrick Crusius of Allen, the perpetrator of the shooting at a Walmart store in El Paso,Wikipedia Texas, was also influenced by the theory, and mentioned in his manifesto The Inconvient[sic] Truth a supposed "Hispanic invasion of Texas" and claimed he was "simply trying to defend my country from ethnic and cultural replacement brought on by an invasion" as well as praising the aforementioned Brenton Harrison Tarrant and his manifesto. Additionally, Crusius also read Tarrant's The Great Replacement manifesto.[11]


See the main article on this topic: Generation Identity

The far-right white nationalist Identitarian movementWikipedia in Europe, North America, Australia, and New Zealand is a major promoter of this theory.[12]

2021 U.S. coup attempt[edit]

See the main article on this topic: 2021 U.S. Capitol riot

Fear of the Great Replacement was a significant driver of the January 6, 2021 coup attempt by Trump supporters. Arrestees were 6 times more likely to come from counties with declines in the percentage of non-Hispanic Whites in the population. Fear that Blacks and Hispanics are overtaking Whites increased the likelihood of being an insurrectionist by 3-fold in the second study. Fear that Blacks and Hispanics will have more rights than Whites increased the likelihood of being an insurrectionist by 2-fold in the third study.[13]

Buffalo shooting[edit]

Another shooting that happened in Buffalo, New York, was caused by Payton S. Gendron, who wrote about the Great Replacement in his manifesto.[14]

Outside of Europe[edit]

The Great Replacement theory is widespread outside of Europe. America is an obvious example of a country outside of the European sphere that adheres to the theory, but the theory also has a presence in other countries such as Canada[15], Mexico[16][17], Brazil[18][19], Japan[20], Iran[21], and Turkey[22].

See also[edit]

External links[edit]


  2. Le Grand Remplacement by Renaud Camus (2011) D. Reinharc. ISBN 2358690317.
  3. The roots of the ‘great replacement theory’ believed to fuel Buffalo suspect by Martha M. Hamilton & Aaron Wiener (May 15, 2022) The Washington Post.
  5. "Bitch Nation" by Musab Younis, London Review of Books, Vol. 41 No. 3 · 7 February 2019, pages 39-40
  6. "Autant j'aime Renaud Camus, autant je suis mal à l'aise avec le parti de l'In-nocence", Emmanuel Carrère, L'Express, 31 Jan 2012
  7. The French Origins of "You Will Not Replace Us", Thomas Chatterton Williams, New Yorker, 4 Dec 2017
  8. “You will not replace us”: a French philosopher explains the Charlottesville chant: American white nationalists may not realize it, but the fear of replacement is essential to the work of a controversial French writer named Renaud Camus. by Sarah Wildman (Aug 15, 2017, 9:20am EDT) Vox.
  9. Renaud Camus's ideas may have inspired the Christchurch mosque slayings in New Zealand McAuley, James. Washington Post - March 15, 2019.
  10. Facebook to ban white nationalism after mosque attacks by Sharon Marris (28 March 2019 08:01, UK) Sky News.
  11. Arango, Tim; Bogel-Burroughs, Nicholas; Benner, Katie (August 3, 2019). "Minutes Before El Paso Killing, Hate-Filled Manifesto Appears Online". The New York Times. 
  12. Austria mulls dissolving far-right movement over Christchurch links by Philip Oltermann (27 Mar 2019 12.37 EDT) The Guardian.
  13. Understanding American Domestic Terrorism: Mobilization Potential and Risk Factors of a New Threat Trajectory by Robert A. Pape et al. (April 6, 2021) The Chicago Project on Security and Threats.
  14. The Buffalo supermarket shooting suspect allegedly posted an apparent manifesto repeatedly citing 'great replacement' theory by Ben Collins, May 14, 2022, NBC News
  15. Some trucker convoy organizers have history of white nationalism, racism Global News
  16. Migration flows and violence against migrants in Mexico Vision of Humanity
  17. Anti-immigrant sentiment grips Mexico City where residents fume about American interlopers Washington Times
  18. The Marginalization of Non-White Refugees in Brazil RioOnWatch
  19. How Brazil’s progressive migration bill was sabotaged Al Jazeera
  20. Prejudice against immigrants explained in numbers
  21. Saudi-backed media promotes "Great Replacement" theory to Iranians Matthew’s Notebook
  22. Erdoğan’s Great Replacement Theory The Dial