Fun:Puerto Rico

From RationalWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Es posible estar desencantado con la Isla del Encanto.
This is an island surrounded by water. Big water. Ocean water.
Donald Trump
The Puerto Ricans forming the ranks of the gallant 65th Infantry on the battlefields of Korea … are writing a brilliant record of achievement in battle and I am proud indeed to have them in this command. I wish that we might have many more like them.
—General Douglas MacArthur during the Korean War.[1]

Puerto Rico is an unincorporated United States territory that was won from Spain in after a splendid little conflict known as the Spanish-American War. And Spain had previously taken Puerto Rico from the natives, and then of course all but exterminated them. In spite of having over twice the population of Hawaii, which joined the Union at around the same time, this unique US territory is still not yet a state; taxation without representation much? Reasons for why this is the case range from "it's too poor and they'll have to pay income taxes" to, strangely enough, "they aren't Americans",[2] while in reality, it's quite likely this is related to its strong support for the Democrats. However, among other territories like the other Washington and Guam that are also vying for statehood, it is the most likely to get statehood as there are already even some Senate Republicans who'd support the idea (e.g. Marco Rubio, Rick Scott), and because PR's nonvoting delegate is a Republican, proving that it would likely be a purple state, where the GOP could maybe get at least one senator elected and win at least a few of the five congressional districts it would likely have, if the Dems don't gerrymander of course. The region and "country" are divided between statehood, independence, or status quo.

History[edit]

Puerto Rico was first settled by humans sometime around 2000 BCE. By around 1000 CE, the Taíno people had become dominant. They were already fighting with the Caribs from the Antilles before their downfall, but contact with the Spanish would result in them dying out, but some of their culture, like hammocks, maracas, and words like "iguana" and "huracán" (hurricane) still remain. Speaking of the Spanish, the first to arrive was Christopher Columbus on his second voyage in 1493. At the time, there were 30,000-60,000 Taíno on the island. Columbus called the island "San Juan Bautista" after St. John the Baptist (yeah, he had an obsession with naming islands after saints). The first colony was founded by Juan Ponce de LeónWikipedia in 1508. Five years later, he would set sail and reach Florida, the first time a European would reach the mainland U.S. The Spanish would set up a system called the "encomienda",Wikipedia which basically allowed Spanish officials to enslave the native population. This led to a revolt in 1511, which was easily crushed by Ponce de León, and within a couple decades the remaining native population would die due to disease and genocide. African slaves had to be brought in to replace the native ones, although Puerto Rico didn't have as many slaves as places like Haiti or the Virgin Islands.

Despite killing off the native population, control of the island didn't come easily for the Spanish, as other European powers realized the potential of the islands. In 1528, the whole island aside from the capital San Juan was ransacked by the French before a local militia was able to drive them off. They attacked again in 1538 and 1554. In 1594, the English privateer Sir Francis DrakeWikipedia tried to sack the island but was driven back by soldiers entrenched in the forts. Three years later, the English navy came and succeeded in taking the island, but they were forced to abandon it due to an outbreak of dysentery. The Dutch attacked the capital in 1625, but were driven off. In 1702, England would have another unsuccessful attempt to take the island. It would later become a theater for the French Revolutionary Wars,Wikipedia with Britain attacking in 1797 as the Spanish were allied with the French, but once again were unsuccessful. The Napoleonic Wars, which resulted in Spain being occupied, allowed Puerto Rico to get a bit of autonomy, and resulted in them opening their borders to other countries besides Spain, however, the restoration of the Spanish monarchy led to Puerto Rico being a colony again. There were several slave revolts during this time, the most famous being led by Marcos XiorroWikipedia in 1820. The slave trade was abolished in 1833 and slavery itself wouldn't be abolished until 1873. Around 11% of Puerto Rico's population was enslaved.

The majority of the population of Puerto Rico at the time was poor and illiterate. The infrastructure was terrible for Puerto Rico's agricultural economy, and increasing taxes and tariffs levied by the Spanish crippled the economy. Furthermore, the Spanish government would jail anyone who wanted to talk about liberal reforms. The Grito de LaresWikipedia (Lares cry) was the first revolt against Spanish rule. Although quickly controlled by the Spanish, it did result in reforms such as the abolition of slavery and the beginning of Puerto Rican political parties. In 1897, the territory was given some level of autonomy (though there was still a Spanish-appointed governor) and allowed them to trade with the U.S. and the rest of Europe. Guess what would happen one year later. Expanding into the Caribbean was always popular in the U.S. since Southerners wanted to add slave states to the union (before the Civil War), with the Golden CircleWikipedia being one such plan. The U.S. finally saw their opportunity when the U.S.S. Maine blew up in Cuba, and used it as a pretense to take Spain's colonies. The U.S. quickly blockaded Puerto Rico, but unlike in the rest of the war the Spanish put up a decent fight there and still held on to half of the island at the end of the war. Ultimately, however, Puerto Rico was ceded to the U.S. after Spain got their asses kicked in Cuba, the Philippines, and Guam. The island was put under military rule and renamed "Porto Rico" (the Portuguese name for the island! It would be changed back in 1935). The Foraker ActWikipedia of 1900 would grant limited civilian governance, and the Jones–Shafroth ActWikipedia of 1917 would grant Puerto Ricans U.S. citizenship. The Puerto Rico Federal Relations Act of 1950Wikipedia allowed Puerto Ricans to draft their own constitution, which was approved two years later. Several nationalist revolts occurred, including the Jayuya UprisingWikipedia and an incident in which two nationalists tried to assassinate Harry Truman. In 1954, four Puerto Rican nationalists shot into the CapitolWikipedia wounding five Representatives; this would be the last insurrection at the Capitol until the 2021 U.S. Capitol riot. These incidents led to the U.S. cracking down on the Puerto Rican independence movement.

Today, the area is still in its odd state between statehood and colonialism, which allows businesses and the government to use it as a source of cheap labor. Over 43% of Puerto Ricans are living below the poverty line (by comparison, that's more than double Mississippi which is at 19%)[3] and the island's government was bankrupted due to forced dependency.[4] Hundreds of thousands of Puerto Ricans have migrated to the U.S. as a result of this in just the past few years alone.[3] The debate over statehood still continues to this day.

Politics[edit]

Puerto Rico's politics are somewhat different than the rest of the United States. There are five major political parties in Puerto Rico, and it's worth noting that none are directly analogous to the Democratic Party or Republican Party, as members of the same Puerto Rican party sometimes caucus with opposing parties on the national level. The five main parties are:

  • Partido Nuevo ProgresistaWikipedia (New Progressive Party), abbreviated the PNP, is the party that advocates for PR statehood. Currently, both their governor and their non-voting House delegate are members of this party. Although members of this party have aligned with both the Democrats and Republicans, it is typically seen as a somewhat more conservative party.
  • Partido Popular DemocráticoWikipedia (Popular Democratic Party), abbreviated the PPD, is the more centrist party and currently holds the majority in the House and a plurality in the Senate. The party advocates for Puerto Rico to continue its status as a U.S. territory.
  • Partido Independentista PuertorriqueñoWikipedia (Puerto Rican Independence Party), abbreviated the PIP, is a social democratic party that advocates for Puerto Rican Independence. It is currently by far the smallest of the parties, having one seat each in the House and Senate.
  • Proyecto DignidadWikipedia (Progect Dignity), abbreviated the PD, is a far-right Christian conservative party. It opposes LGBTQ+ rights, feminism and left wing politics in general. It is known by its detractors as the "Puerto Rican Taliban" due to its extreme social conservatism.
  • Movimiento Victoria CiudadanaWikipedia (Citizens' Victory Movement), abbreviated the MVC, is a big tent left-leaning party of disillusioned, frustrated citizens fed up with the corruption and incompetence of the two largest parties, the PNP and PPD. It recently allied with the PIP to form "La Alianza" (The Alliance) for the 2024 General Election.


Puerto Rico currently has more autonomy than Guam, the U.S. Virgin Islands, or American Samoa do, but there are conditions to this. As its status as a territory rather than a state grants it fewer protections under the U.S. Constitution, its autonomy could be revoked by an act of Senate. Furthermore, it can't vote for President (except during primaries) nor does it have any representation in the Senate, and only a non-voting delegate in the House. On the other hand, it has its own teams in international sports competitions such as the Olympics as if it were independent.

Puerto Ricans have voted on statehood six times. The first in 1967 resulted in a large victory for remaining a commonwealth. 1993 was a much closer vote where being a commonwealth won a minor plurality. Then in 1997, with a choice between statehood, remaining a commonwealth, free associaton, and independence, the winning option was... "None of the above" at 50.3% (largely because the poll was criticized over some of its definitions). On the fourth in 2012, residents were first asked whether they want to keep the current commonwealth system, which 54% said no, and the most popular alternative option was statehood, with over 60% supporting it (if being a commonwealth was off the table). A fifth one occurred in 2017, where the only two options were statehood and full independence/free association. Statehood won overwhelmingly, but as this vote was boycotted by supporters of commonwealth status, the turnout was low. Finally, in 2020, a nonbinding referendum was held where the two options were statehood or not becoming a state. Statehood won out, 52.52%-47.48%.

Statehood is not only a divisive issue on the island, but also on the mainland United States. PR statehood is very popular among the Puerto Rican community in Florida, to the point that even the Republicans who get elected there have to portray themselves as being not entirely opposed to the idea. This is largely because Florida is the state that would see the most benefits from Puerto Rican statehood, as the potential economic benefits to PR and added interconnectedness that would result from statehood would likely result in a boost to Florida's tourism industry and would allow Puerto Ricans living in Florida to see their family members more often. However, in Nuevo York, the other state with a large Puerto Rican population, the issue of statehood is much more controversial, and Chuck Schumer and AOC (the latter of whom is herself of Puerto Rican descent) have both waffled on the issue.[5]

In 2019, sitting governor, Ricardo Rosselló,Wikipedia was forced to resign (becoming the first sitting governor to do so) after a 900-page transcript of a Telegram chat was leaked of him and his cabinet making numerous offensive, homophobic, and sexist comments, including mocking the victims of Hurricane Maria, threatening the mayor of San Juan, and discussing how they would use the media to target political opponents.[6] This alongside other incidents of corruption led to massive protests, known in Puerto Rico as the "Verano de 2019" (Summer of 2019); in one particular incident, around one million protesters (about a third of the island's population) shut down one of the major highways in order to demand the governor's resignation.[7] Ultimately, he was replaced by Wanda Vázquez Garced,Wikipedia the Roselló-appointed Attorney General, who would be primaried by Pedro Pierluisi.Wikipedia Pierluisi himself went on to win the 2020 gubernatorial election, beating his PPD opponent, Carlos Delgado AltieriWikipedia with 32.93% of the vote against Delgado's 31.75%. As of 2024, Pierluisi failed to secure a primary victory necessary for his re-election, leading Resident Comissioner Jenniffer GonzálezWikipedia to become the gubernatorial candidate for the center-right PNP. The center-left PPD continues to bleed support even with a young candidate, Jesús Manuel Ortiz.Wikipedia The big tent MVC (Movimiento Victoria Cuidadana - Citizens Victory Movement) allied with the the left wing, social democratic PIP to form "La Alianza" (The Alliance) with PIP candidate, Juan Manuel Dalmau Ramírez,Wikipedia taking the helm. The Alianza (and the left wing in PR in general) has seen a surge of support from the youth since 2019, taking the PIP, which was always dead last in the polls to SECOND PLACE in recent 2024 polling. The 2024 election will be the most anticipated in Puerto Rican history if youth voter turnout is high.

Famous Puerto Ricans[edit]

  • Luis Fonsi and Daddy Yankee, two musicians who gave us the infamous "Despacito".
  • Ricky Martin, singer, gay icon, and activist
  • Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (AOC) is a Nuyorican, she was born in Nuevo York and her family is Puerto Rican.
  • Just like AOC, Jennifer LopezWikipedia was also born in New York and her parents are also Puerto Rican.
  • Many, many moreWikipedia

Gallery[edit]

Notes[edit]

  1. Looks quite similar to the flag of Cuba, doesn't it?

References[edit]