Appeal to faith
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Cogito ergo sum Logic and rhetoric |
Key articles |
General logic |
Bad logic |
An appeal to faith (or an appeal to belief) occurs when someone argues that you must first accept the truth of a statement in order to be able to rationally accept the truth of the statement.
The fallacy is a form of circular logic and an informal fallacy.
Form
In reaffirming believers:
- P1: I have faith that X is true.
- P2: (unstated) Everything I believe is true.
- C: X is true.
In shutting down nonbelievers:
- P1: It is impossible to determine whether X is true unless you believe that X is true.
- P2: You do not believe that X is true.
- C: You cannot determine whether X is true.
Explanation
See the main article on this topic: Faith
Faith, by definition, relies on a belief that does not rest on logic or evidence. Faith depends on irrational thought.
Furthermore, privileging a belief by saying that it is immune to criticism from those who don't accept it is special pleading and can never fail, making it circular logic.
Examples
- "Once you believe it, you will understand!"
- "If you accept the Lord, you will understand!"
- "If you would only take Maslow at his word, you would finally get it!"
- "The way in which I know Christianity is true is first and foremost on the basis of the witness of the Holy Spirit in my heart. And this gives me a self-authenticating means of knowing Christianity is true wholly apart from the evidence." — William Lane Craig combining an appeal to faith with several other fallacies, including an appeal to authority (and a faith-based one at that).
External links
- Appeal to Faith — Logically Fallacious
- Appeal to faith — C. George Boeree
- Logical Fallacy Lesson 7: Appeal to Faith — Rational Responders