| Drink the Kool-Aid|
|But you WANT to stay!|
“”[I]f you really want some fun, read Li Hongzhi's Time magazine interview and enjoy as it slowly goes from "yeah, sounds reasonable" to "wtf, he's talking about aliens invading earth?"
Falun Gong or Falun Dafa (Great Law of the Falun) is a spiritual practice based on Chinese qi gong and founded in 1992 by Li Hongzhi. Some people — including Rick Ross of Cult Education Institute and the Chinese government in Beijing, — regard it as a cult, but scholars have disagreed on its definition. The Chinese government's attempts to suppress the movement have resulted in the group becoming something of a cause célèbre among human-rights groups (until they found about Li Hongzhi's very conservative views) and the anti-China crowd. Li Hongzhi claimed 100 million and claimed CCP official figures of 60 million and 70 million adherents. The 1999 investigation into Falun Gong by the CCP identified 2.3 million. 2004 documents provided by defected Chinese analyst Chen Yonglin claimed 60,000.
Many of its more visible members support social conservatism, segregated paradises[note 1] and anti-communism — these stances have helped to popularize the movement in certain circles in the West. Falun Gong's rallying call is very easy to identify: 法轮大法好 (fǎlún dàfǎ hǎo; "Falun Great Law is good!")
- 1 Teachings
- 2 Cult of personality
- 3 Allegations of bigotry
- 4 Allegations of pseudoscience
- 5 Generic enthusiasm: "full circle"
- 6 Religious media
- 7 Falun Gong and Chinese politics
- 8 "Great law is good" meme on the Chinese internet sphere
- 9 See also
- 10 External links
- 11 Notes
- 12 References
Falun Gong combines Chinese folk religion, modern-day eschatology, and qigong techniques for "harnessing" body energy. The practice identifies as belonging to the "Buddhist school," though it deviates from traditional Buddhism and incorporates language and symbology from Taoism. Its stated central tenets are "truth, compassion, and tolerance" (zhen, shan, ren in Chinese), which it regards as the highest manifestation of the Dao or Buddhist Dharma.
The founder of Falun Gong, Li Hongzhi (李洪志), is regarded in Falun Gong beliefs as a type of savior who has come to the earth to "rectify" the way (the Dharma) and prevent "true" spiritual teachings from being lost. He also believes that Falun Gong's exercises are means to the end of human salvation, as the earth is entering its last days to moral degeneracy.
The Ten Greatest Evils in The World (世界十惡) according to Li Hongzhi:
- 人無善念 人人為敵 (hostility)
- 破壞傳統 文化頹廢 (abandonment of cultural decadence)
- 同性慾亂 心暗魔變 (homosexuality)
- 興賭興毒 隨心所欲 (gambling and drug abuse)
- 開放性亂 導向邪惡 (sex liberation)
- 黑幫亂黨 政匪一家 (gang influence on the ruling body)
- 自主亂民 逆天叛道 (democracy, because it goes against the will of heaven)
- 迷信科學 變異人類 (science, apparently it leads to mutations)
- 吹崇暴力 好勇鬥狠 (violence)
- 宗教邪變 錢客政客 (the influence of money and politics on religion)
Li claimed in a 1999 Interview that Enlightened Beings™ can levitate, perform faith healing and walk through the Great Wall of China just as David Copperfield did. When asked why aliens wanted to corrupt humanity through the use of technology he replied, "The aliens want the human body."
In a radical interpretation of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms he claims that Cao Cao died because he rejected the supernatural powers of Hua Tuo. His lack of faith caused him to die of a brain tumour.:10-13
The current universe we live in was made, "...after being exploded nine times.":2
Only the most basic level of enlightenment is available to those who maintain relationships with non-believer friends and family.:73
Modern Medicine cannot cure illness, only complete obedience to Li's teachings can do so.:10, 22
When asked if it is acceptable to urinate or defecate after practice, Li explained that excrement only contained a small amount of energy. He went on to add, "In teaching this class, the energy I discharged was immensely powerful, and was left all over the walls.":77
Aliens among us
- Aliens have invaded the human mind.
- Aliens come from other planets and dimensions.
- Aliens introduced machinery such as computers and airplanes to humans.
- Aliens taught humans modern science.
- Aliens intend to replace humans.
- Aliens cause wars.
- Aliens want to take over human bodies because human bodies are the most perfect in the Universe.
Cult of personality
“”TIME: Are you a human being?
Li: You can think of me as a human being.
Li Hongzhi claims to have miraculous powers. He claims that he is the savior of humanity, who has come to the earth to "rectify" the way and prevent "true" spiritual teachings from being lost. He further claims that this ancient Chinese knowledge is far superior to science. His propagandists are known for hijacking reprints of Buddhist texts and inserting him as the "Main Buddha of the Universe".
Master Li currently resides in a compound called Dragon Springs in New York state, which housed temples, schools, and residences of the Shen Yun performers Former practitioners noted Li's control of the compound, which restricts internet access, discourages modern medicine, and promoted arranged relationships.
Allegations of bigotry
The organization is vehemently opposed to homosexuality and premarital sex and generally holds the same social views as the Catholic Church. It espouses socially conservative views comparable to those found in Buddhist and Christian beliefs. That includes proscriptions against pre-marital and extra-marital sex, as well as homosexuality, which are described as producing negative "karma." However, these teachings are only regarded as guidelines for personal conduct, and do not necessarily translate into a social or political position. (Whether that would remain true if Falun Gong gained political power is yet to be seen.)
Views on races
The movement's teaching on race-related issues are somewhat questionable. Li Hongzhi maintains that interracial relationships are a symptom of moral degeneration and a sign of the Dharma ending period and that race divisions continue to exist in the afterlife, that people of different skin colors go to different heavens, and that as a result interracial children cannot go to heaven without the personal intervention of Li Hongzhi.
Li Hongzhi himself believes mixed-race people should be outcasts of every human society. At a 1996 Sydney lecture:
The races in the world are not allowed to be mixed up. Now, the races are mixed up and it has brought about an extraordinarily serious problem. Once races are mixed up, one does not have a corresponding relationship with the higher levels, and he has lost the root. Mixed races have lost their roots, as if nobody in the paradise will take care of them. They belong to nowhere, and no places would accept them. Therefore, you find the place where the continents of Europe and Asia meet a desert in the past and a depopulated zone. When the transportation means were not advanced, it was difficult to pass through it. With the progress of modern means, all these are broken through. Thus, races have become increasingly mixed up, which can lead to serious consequences. Of course, I will not go into details. I'm just saying that the higher levels do not recognize such a human race.
And at a 1999 Los Angeles lecture:
In fact, no one knows that even though many people talk about believing in Buddhas or believing in gods, the truth is, if you aren’t someone from that particular god’s world he won’t save you whatsoever. I once made a statement that whether it’s Christianity or Catholicism, in their paradises there are no Eastern people. This is an absolute truth which man doesn’t understand. Yet Western religions went to the East with the Crusades, and the way they spread wasn’t good to begin with, since both Jesus and Yahweh prohibited their disciples from spreading the teachings eastward. It was to prevent the mixing of human races, but they didn’t understand this.
And at a 1999 Sydney lecture:
Student: People of the white race are left over from the previous civilization. Then people of the yellow race and members of other races are…
Teacher: During the previous cycle of civilization the continental plates were different from those of today. But roughly speaking, people of the yellow race lived in the regions of South America and North America. The Native Americans who live there at present are classified as being of the yellow race. The people of the yellow race who lived in the place where China is now—the most central place [where they were] at that time was at Kazakhstan—after the Great Flood, they migrated to the region that is the great desert of Xinjiang. At that time it was a land of fertile soil. Later on they continually migrated eastward. Strictly speaking, Indians, Egyptians, Persians, the yellow race, the white race, and the black race are the six major races of the present Earth. All the other ones are mixed races.
Views on homosexuality
According to a letter to the editor of the San Francisco News Sentinel in 2006 written by a man who claimed to be the son of Falun Gong practitioners, the movement also teaches that "homosexuality is not the standard of being human, the priority of Gods will be to eliminate homosexuals and that gays are demonic in nature." Other postings on the internet echo this.
Allegations of pseudoscience
“”Only Buddha(s) are the greatest scientists.
|—Li Hongzhi's lecture in Sydney|
Falun Gong both denigrates science (antiscience) and pushes non-scientific belief systems (pseudoscience).
According to former members, Falun Gong believes an upcoming apocalypse where communists and people who speak ill of the practice will be sent to a special hell, while practitioners and supporters of the practice will be spared.
Quitting the Party
Falun Gong has long advocated for members to announce that they have quit from the Chinese Communist Party (退党); more specifically, they advocate "三退" (the three quits): quitting not just from the Party but also its affiliated organizations, including the Young Pioneers of China and the Communist Youth League, into which many Chinese are initiated. By "quitting the party", Falun Gong does not mean simply no longer attending Party events; instead, it means publicly renouncing the Party, with renunciations under pseudonyms also being permitted. Many of the criticisms they raise of the Chinese Communist Party in their Nine Commentaries on the Chinese Communist Party (《九评共产党》) are completely legitimate political criticisms of an authoritarian and oppressive party, albeit written in the style of a McCarthy-era polemic. However, Falun Gong's advocacy for quitting the Communist Party is not simple political advocacy; it carries a strong eschatological bent, as evident in the catchphrase "退党保平安" (tuì dǎng bǎo píng Ān; quitting the Party ensures your peace and safety).
According to Falun Gong teachings, those who have joined the Chinese Communist Party or its affiliated organizations, such as the Young Pioneers of China, must announce their separation from the Party and its affiliated organizations in order to avoid the wrath of God. According to one Falun Gong website, the Chinese Communist Party is Satanic in nature, with the Great Red Dragon in the Book of Revelation being the "manifestation of the Communist Party in a different realm." People who have been sworn into the ranks of the Communist Party or its affiliated organizations have therefore acquired the mark of the Beast and will perish when "the Heavens destroy the Chinese Communist Party" unless they "announce [their] departure from these organizations of the Chinese Communist Party [and thereby] wipe away the mark of the Beast."
So far, the paper proclaims that that "hundreds of millions" of people have quit the CCP, even though the Party itself only has 90 million official members.
Ancient Chinese knowledge > science
Falun Gong holds ancient Chinese knowledge to be a superior epistemic system than Western science. For example, Zhuan Falun writes: "Modern equipment is pretty advanced, but I'd say it's still not as good as ancient Chinese medical science.
As part of the larger Qi Gong movement, Falun Gong endorses traditional Chinese medicine, its adherents claiming that the techniques they teach are a replacement for evidence-based medicine. Falun Gong takes a Christian science approach to illness, denying the reality of pain and disease and believing them to be deceptive misperceptions of the pure spiritual nature of man and God. Furthermore, Falun Gong claims that sickness is the result of past-life transgressions.
Because Falun Gong teaches that sickness is the result of karma accrued in past lives, followers sometimes eschew conventional medical treatment in non-life threatening situations.
"Ancient civilizations" and evolution denial
Falun Gong seems to be endorsing a view similar to evolution denial or Vedic creationism. Plate tectonics is mentioned immediately after this paragraph but used as an evidence AGAINST speciation, and for ancient civilizations from "from tens of million years ago". New Age concepts imported into China during a 1978-1983 popular science boom such as Atlantis, Mu and Lemuria are implicitly mentioned.
Some people claim, "Our human race evolved from apes." In fact, let me tell you that man did not evolve from apes at all. Darwin proposed a theory, which says, "Man has evolved from apes." When he made public this theory at that time, he brought it out with great trepidation. His theory is full of loopholes and is incomplete, and yet, it has been accepted by people to this day. Please think about it. The evolutionary process that he proposed of apes evolving to man, a process of tens of millions of years, cannot be found. There isn’t one. Why weren’t there such people between apes and human beings? Not just human beings, but other things as well. None of the evolved animals that he referred to had the transitional process. In addition, why are the species that exist on the continent of Australia different from the species that exist on other continents? He could explain none of these. Nevertheless this theory of evolution with all its loopholes has been accepted by human beings. This is indeed strange!
In fact, man did not evolve from apes at all in our view, only that there are different species existing in each time period. The continental plates on the earth planet inhabited by mankind are shifting and changing. Geologists call the continents of Asia, Europe, America, North America, and South America the continental plates. The continental plates changed from time to time, and the civilizations on them would sink to the bottom of the waters. Then, another continent would perhaps surface in another ocean, and such changes are continually taking place. Now, people have also discovered huge ancient buildings and the existence of past civilizations under the Pacific Ocean, the Atlantic Ocean, the Indian Ocean, as well as many other oceans. However, upon examination, they are all found to be things that existed several hundred thousand years or several million years ago, or even earlier than that. At least, our present mankind knows that the continental plates have not changed in the past several hundred thousand years. When did they sink to the bottom of the waters then? They definitely sunk very early, several hundred thousand years ago or even earlier than that. Therefore, when different continental plates changed, the species on them were also different. They did not come from evolution. There were similarities, but they were not of the same species.
Falun Dafa materials often mention a 2-billion year old nuclear reactor in Africa, which is an artifact of an advanced ancient civilization. While the reactor in question definitely exists, all available evidence suggests that it has formed naturally, without any intervention from ancient intelligence.
Discarded scientific concepts and pseudo-scientific concepts are a large source for Falun Gong's worldview. They play a smaller part in the propaganda outside China after the crackdown, but they have not been changed in the texts.
I am telling everyone that this dimensional layer where mankind lives is between two kinds of particles. As for particles, those of us who have studied physics know that molecules, atoms, nuclei, quarks, and neutrinos are each a layer of particles. They are physical elements that constitute larger particles. Which layer of particles does mankind exist in? The largest things that we see with human eyes are planets, and the smallest things that we can see under the microscope are molecules. In fact, our mankind just exists in this dimensional layer between the planets and the molecules. We may find it very vast, very extensive, and incomparably big. I say that modern science is not advanced. No matter how far a spacecraft can fly, it cannot fly beyond this physical dimension of ours. However developed a computer is, it cannot match the human brain. Now the human brain is still a mystery. Therefore, the science of mankind is still very shallow.
Allegations of racism
At a 1999 Sydney lecture:
The Indian race was created by Buddhas, and that's why the dancing of Indians, the way they carry themselves, and their hand gestures are similar to those of Buddhas. Indians really are a race created by Buddhas. As far as Orientals go, a portion of them were created by Nu Wa, while another portion were created by Daos. Actually, to put it more precisely, the earliest race in the early days of North America and South America was the yellow race. They're now called people of the red race, but they're in fact of the yellow race--they were tanned by the sun. (Everyone laughs) The people of the true red race were the ancient Egyptians. Maybe it's not possible to find them now, since most of them have mixed their blood with blacks.
Generic enthusiasm: "full circle"
An idea that once was prominent in Chinese Falun Gong is Yuan Man or "Consummation/Full Circle", a state related to Moksha but not very specific. (Mis)Intepretation by low-level Falun Gong instructor and missionaries often blends this idea into the more indigenous notion of an afterlife, so self-flagellation from removal of palatine uvula to ritual suicides are not uncommon even a few years after the crackdown. Today, it is redefined after the more sane Moksha.
Scholars have noted the embracement of Falun Gong by mainstream media in the Western world, often minimizing its woo and depicting it as simply a series of harmless exercises This is aided by Falun Gong's ability to mobilize its supporters quickly and its penchant for lawsuits and protests, and news publications often uncritically publish information from press releases created by Falun Gong affiliated groups.
|—The slogan of Epoch Times since about 2019 — it's not so much of either as detailed by Media Bias/Fact Check and its Beyond Science section|
Falun Gong publishes the widely-distributed and multilingual newspaper Epoch Times. Besides its usual anti-PRC diatribes that ask readers to "resign" from the Chinese Communist Party regardless of actual membership, the paper often publishes woo and conspiracies such as chemtrails, UFOs, and an entire section titled "Beyond Science". The Beyond Science section includes such things as "12 Million-Year-Old Vehicle Tracks", ancient Sumerian spaceships, and hype over meditation and near-death experiences.
Former employees noted the secrecy of the publication's ownership and funding, and tendency to promote red-baiting as well as anti-abortion and homophobic views. Other former writers noted its almost slave labor-like work environment, where they need to meet a quota of writing five articles per day and reaching 100,000 views. Falun Gong-associated editors then remove mentions of issues which conflict with "traditional values" as well as those unfavorable to Trump. This is not surprising since it was promoted by Chris Kitze of fake new website Before It's News.
In 2015, taking advantage of social anxieties over the refugee crisis, the German edition has taken an anti-Muslim bent, with unverified stories such as that German schools banned Christian festivals to appease Muslims,, a gang of refugees kidnapping and raping a German schoolgirl, and outright antisemitic claims such as that the Rothschild family is profiting from the refugee crisis, sourced from a far right conspiracy website. A German media report found that the paper offers favorable coverage to right wing populist, anti-immigrant groups like Alternative für Deutschland and PEGIDA, presenting them as "guardians of democracy", and accused the German public broadcasters of "media bias". Its staff are mostly practitioners of Falun Gong and untrained in basics of journalism and fact checking, and have a reputation of publishing almost anything, including claims that Chancellor Angela Merkel is attempting to transform German society by replacing White Germans with Muslim refugees. So far, its attempts to bed German far right has paid off, gathering over 4 million views in January 2016, and becoming one of the favorite media sources of PEGIDA supporters.
The paper is heavily supportive of Donald Trump, and in an editorial, praised Trump for "changing America's socialist policies", to the degree of outright promoting conspiracy theories such as QAnon and Spygate, which denies the Trump-Russia connection. It regularly publishes articles praising Trump, including supporting his border wall with Mexico and his brand of US nationalism, and referred to climate change advocacy and government welfare as communism.
In August 2019, Facebook banned The Epoch Times from advertising on its site because The Epoch Times had violated its political ad transparency policies by creating sockpuppet accounts that together bought $2 million worth of pro-Trump ads while disguising the original source of the ads.
During the 2019-20 COVID-19 outbreak, Epoch Times has spread misinformation about the virus being manufactured by the Chinese government, and echoing Donald Trump, began referring to it as the CCP Virus. Special issues of paper were spammed to politicians and residents alike in several countries, including Canada, Australia, and the UK. Epoch Times also produced a widely viewed "documentary" supporting its claims, which was flagged by Facebook as fake news but nevertheless gained prominence among wingnuts. The video falsely linked COVID-19 with HIV based on the existence of similar sequences, which it uses as "proof" that the virus was manmade, even though similar sequences can be found in other viruses and lifeforms. Among the cranks cited was Judy Mikovits, a disgraced former biochemistry researcher turned conspiracy theorist and anti-vaccination activist, who claimed that COVID-19 is no worse than the flu and does not require vaccination, and that it is activated by wearing face masks.
Shen Yun Performing Arts (神韵艺术团) is a Falun Gong-run operation, which presents itself as "a presentation of traditional Chinese culture as it once was: a study in grace, wisdom, and the virtues distilled from the five millennia of Chinese civilization.". Shen Yun promotional websites disclose their connection to political Falun Gong activism Theater material such as the program and sales literature prominently disclose this connection. This doesn't mean it isn't propaganda, it is, since politics is mixed into their performances, either in the narration between performances, the lyrics of songs (with translated supertitles projected on a screen), and in traditional Chinese dance performances.
One attendee noted that "We paid a premium for seats that would provide us an excellent view of Chinese tradition. Instead, we contributed unwittingly to a religious movement that denies evolution and science, claims the earth was inhabited by aliens, demonizes atheists and homosexuals, and condemns mixed marriages." Another reviewer from the New Yorker noted songs with lyrics such as "We follow Dafa, the Great Way… Atheism and evolution are deadly ideas. Modern trends destroy what makes us human".
An extraordinarily large amount of money is spent on Shen Yun advertising, 62% of Shen Yun Performing Arts Inc.'s budget ($18.5 million in 2017). This compares to only 7.5% of budget for the average company. Shen Yun is apparently able to maintain this budget lopsidedness based on having a very large number of volunteers (Falun Gong members) and a low average wage for employees (<$30,000). The financial structure of Shen Yun does seem to confirm the propagandistic nature of the performance.
New Tang Dynasty Television
New Tang Dynasty Television (新唐人電視臺), also known as NTD, is a Falun Gong-run satellite TV station. The name of the station refers to bringing back the "good old days", i.e., the Tang dynasty. The channel's now-closed website stated its mission is to "promote uncensored information on China; to restore and promote traditional Chinese culture; and to facilitate mutual understanding between the East and West." The channel's former annual Chinese New Year Spectacular special (which ran from 2004-2006) didn't even try to hide the channel's connection to Falun Gong, with it usually taking a break from Chinese ethnic & folk dance & music performances to show messaging and imagery sympathetic to Falun Gong, as well as "artistic representations of the persecution of practitioners in China".
NTD also is behind the QAnon-promoting YouTube channel "Edge of Wonder". A reporter for The Daily Dot states that the channel's hosts "embrace QAnon completely" even though "almost nothing QAnon has foretold has actually taken place."
Falun Gong and Chinese politics
Despite the common perception that they are general troublemakers, Falun Gong states that they are aggressively nonviolent.[note 2] The group's teachings officially eschew most forms of political involvement.[note 3] Of course, given the beliefs of the group, "political involvement" is rather creatively defined — protests and advocating against same-sex marriage or the Chinese government is acceptable, while actually becoming a politician[note 4] is discouraged.
In Australia, the group is on friendly terms with the allegedly xenophobic and far-right group Party For Freedom, which campaigned against Chinese investment in Australia. Furthermore, in 2016, a Falun Gong activist and organizer of multicultural festivals, Shan Ju Lin, was pre-selected as the candidate for the xenophobic One Nation party, where she claimed that Australia is being taken over by the Chinese Communist Party, and that all the "good Asians" will vote for her. Later on, she was dumped by One Nation due to her homophobic comments where she proclaimed that "gays should be treated as patients" and "abnormal sex behaviour leads to abnormal crime". Apparently, she is the wrong type of bigot to run for One Nation. In spite of this, the New South Wales chairman of One Nation, Bob Vinnicombe, also serves as a Falun Gong activist.
Political movement or harmless religious group?
Attitudes towards Falun Gong are sharply divided. Chinese government sources charged that the group was a threat to social stability and was seeking to overthrow the government, while supporters argue that they are being oppressed because the group had grown too large and its beliefs conflicted with the government's atheist philosophy. Public perceptions in the English-speaking world are skewed by the highly successful public relations campaigns operated by Falun Gong practitioners, and knee-jerk paranoia about the Chinese government.[note 5] The group also have attracted significant support among the Western political establishment, and receives funding from the organization National Endowment for Democracy, although it is questionable whether they are actually aware of Falun Gong's teachings For instance, in 2001, some San Francisco lawmakers nominated Li Hongzhi for a Nobel Peace Prize, only to have the nomination withdrawn after becoming aware of his stances on homosexuality. Jiang Zemin, the leader of the Communist Party, banned Falun Gong's publishings in 1997, causing Li Hongzhi to immigrate to the United States. A crackdown on the movement formally began after a 1999 incident in which ten thousand practitioners quietly surrounded the CCP compound in Beijing to request legal recognition in response to a teens' magazine article that attacked the practice. The government produced, among others, a videotape called "Falun Gong--Cult of Evil" and a comic book titled "Li Hongzhi: The Man and His Evil Deeds." They accused Li of being a fraud, a "swindler," a rich tax evader, a decadent patron of foreign casinos and brothels and a "despotic tyrant like Hitler." Even the description on the official arrest and bounty warrant was insulting: "Li is about 1.78 meters in height with slanted eyebrows, single-edged eyelids, a little bit fat…"
Scholars such as Maria Chang argued that the crackdown on Falun Gong is simply the most visible part of the Chinese government's "anti-superstition" campaign against all unregistered religious groups, of which a large number are New Age and Buddhism-based groups, which also include the Unification Church.. Chang also note the role of millenarian movements and secret societies in overthrowing the Chinese emperors of the past, which included the Yellow Turbans, White Lotus Society, Taiping Heavenly Kingdom, and Boxers, which naturally made the communist party in becoming wary of perceived challenges to its power.[note 6]
Before the crackdown, Falun Gong had been promoted and sponsored by regional governments as a healthy traditional/indigenous form of exercise. This led to a large number of people in the Chinese police, jurisdiction and propaganda systems becoming practitioners. It is still debated whether Falun Gong actively extended its structure to gain a power hold, or if some opposition inside the party used connections made through Falun Gong infrastructure for their own benefit.
It has been alleged that Jiang Zemin began the persecution of Falun Gong as a means to repair his own suffering popularity. Of particular note is that he used his power over the military and police to create the 610 Office, a paramilitary security organization loyal to the CCP. Its primary goal was to investigate and apprehend people thought of as threats to the CCP. Its primary target of suppression includes Falun Gong, although house church Christians, Buddhists and other religious or spiritual groups are also included. Discrimination against Falun Gong continued with his successor Hu Jintao. Under Xi Jinping, his rival, allegations of forced organ harvesting from political prisoners, including Falun Gong, continues.
Allegations of satellite sabotage
From June 23, 2002 to August 7, 2007, Chinese civil communication satellites including Sino I, Asia Pacific Sat VI and Asia 3S were hacked 252 times with a total of 160 hours by the Falun Gong organization. According to the International Telecommunication Union, it is illegal to deliberately disrupt or jam normal satellite TV broadcasting.
On the evening of March 5, 2002, the trunk fiber optical cables in Changchun city and Songyuan city (Li Hongzhi's hometown), Jilin province, were cut off by Falun Gong members and reconnected to programs produced by the cult. Thousands of local citizens failed to receive the normal TV signals.
Victims of organ harvesting?
In 2006, the Kilgour-Matas report was released by David Kilgour, Canadian Minister of Parliament and former-Secretary of State, and David Matas, human rights lawyer and counsel of the Zionist organization B'nai B'rith, which suggested that Falun Gong members have been subject to involuntary organ harvesting. Similar claims have been produced by journalist Ethan Gutmann, who also alleges organ harvesting targeted members of the Uyghur ethnic minority group in the 1990s. This seems like only a minor inconvenience as practitioners can simply regrow removed organs overnight. The United Nations Committee on Torture called for China to schedule an independent investigation into the allegations. However, the U.S. Congressional Research Service later released an analysis of the report arguing that there was insufficient evidence that this was actually the case.
Since 1999, human rights groups have reported that Falun Gong practitioners are subject to widespread arbitrary imprisonment, as well as torture and abuse in custody. An extra-constitutional body, the 6-10 Office was created to lead the suppression of Falun Gong. The authorities mobilized state media apparatus, judiciary, police force, army, education system, families, and workplaces against the group. The campaign, driven by a large-scale propaganda through television, newspaper, radio and internet, urged families and workplaces to actively assist in the campaign. There are reports of systematic torture, illegal imprisonment, forced labour, and psychiatric abuses, with the apparent aim of forcing practitioners to recant their belief in Falun Gong.
Foreign observers estimate that since 1999, hundreds of thousands, and perhaps millions of Falun Gong practitioners have been detained in "re-education through labor" camps, prisons, and detention facilities for refusing to renounce the spiritual practice. At least 2,000 Falun Gong adherents have been tortured to death amidst the persecution campaign, with some observers putting the number much higher. The original allegations also claimed that the Chinese government is engaging in "live exports" i.e. kidnapping people, shipping them overseas, and performing transplantation operations inside their overseas embassies. Questions of feasibility aside, it is highly unlikely that such operations would escape the attention of Western intelligence agencies, and as such this rather sensationalist claim has been removed in the English translation. Furthermore, Ko Wen-je, a Taiwanese mayoral candidate and one of the creators of Taiwan’s organ transplant registry, also accused Gutmann of falsifying claims that he was involved in the organ trade, a claim which Gutmann later withdrew.
In 2016 and 2017, an updated report was authored by Kilgour, Matas and Gutmann for the International Coalition End Transplant Abuse in China (ETAC). According to the report, sources used included a wide range of personal interviews, professional and media statements, as well as data from hospitals and immunosuppressant manufacturing. The updated report concluded that the involuntary harvesting of organs was larger than initially estimated, and claimed that the many of the sources of the organs derive from the killing of Falun Gong practitoners, as well as Uyghurs, Tibetans, and underground Christians.:418 They also accused the party and state institutions of being complicit in the trade, and called for a international investigation into the practices and an end to organ tourism.
Some skepticism about the report should be exercised because the organization that put out report, ETAC, represents itself as an "independent, non-partisan organisation", but Kilgour, its principle author, has quoted in puff pieces for Shen Yun in Epoch Times on at least three occasions. The management committee of ETAC also includes people who appear to be affiliated with Epoch Times — Susie Hughes (ETAC co-founder, Epoch Times photographer), Margo MacVicar (ETACH National Manager, New Zealand, Epoch Times reporter), and Rebecca "Beck" James (ETAC UK National Manager, Outreach in 2019; organizer of a Falun Gong art exhibition)
The Chinese government have previously rejected the claims, and stated that has phased out its system from one dependent on executed prisoners to a voluntary based system. Furthermore, the World Health Organization-affiliated Transplantation Society and medical professionals such as Francis Delmonico also noted China's progress in reforming its organ donation system by establishing a registry of donors and phasing out of organ tourism, The Washington Post also noted that there is no corresponding increase in demand for immunosuppressants (anti-rejection drugs for organ recipients), and there are far less foreigners in China for organ transplantations compared to India and the United States, and that it's not plausible for China to be conducting more transplantation that the US without the information leaking outChinese lawyers who defended Falun Gong practitioners also doubted the claims. In 2019 an organization calling itself the Independent Tribunal Into Forced Organ Harvesting from Prisoner's of Conscience in China, comprised of Human Rights lawyers based out of London and various parts of South East Asia found evidence they deemed compelling that the Chinese government was harvesting organs without meaningful consent and that prisoners of conscience including Falun Gong members were among those targeted. 
A Falun Dafa website argued that China has the capacity to transplant over a million organs a year. This may be a confusion of the information that 169 hospitals collectively performed about 10,000 transplants in China in 2016. There have been high profile cases of illegally performed organ transplants, the largest ever prosecuted uncovered 51 kidneys transplanted by a network of 16 people, some of whom were renowned surgeons at a top hospital. It has been suggested that some reports may be urban legends due to the technical implausibility. There hasnt been any link drawn between Falun Gong and these prosecuted cases.
As with other information on Falun Gong, there is a great deal of obfuscation going on, as most media outlets that feature reports on the group are either drawn directly from Falun Gong supporters or sources within the Chinese government. There also appears to be confusion between organ transplantation from executed criminals, which China has admitted to, versus organ harvesting from Falun Gong practitioners, which China denies. As international customers of organs often prefer to not disclose how many and specifically what organs are imported from China, it is hard to gain a profile on who is 'kidneying' whom through statistics alone.
"Great law is good" meme on the Chinese internet sphere
On the Chinese Internet sphere, "Great Law is Good" also refers to a short verse of propaganda of the "Tuidang" movement, one of the political campaign launched by Falun Gong. It can be best expressed in a series articles named "Nine Commentaries on the Communist Party", the official editorial of this movement published on the Epoch Times, while the "Great Law is Good" propaganda verse is a short summary of it.
The verse is written in a rhyming and vulgar language, as a ballad-formatted, quasi-poem jingle, consists 6 or 7 lines, usually begins with the line "Falun Great Law is Good" (法轮大法好), "Nine Commentaries on the Communist Party" (九评共产党), or "Heaven is watching people's action" (人在做，天在看). It consists mostly ultra-conservative religious rhetoric, claims the government of the Communist Party of China is innately immoral, satanic (literally, with a complete conspiracy theory), and betrays "the Law of heaven, earth and the universe" and will be perished from Earth. Quitting and opposing the Party (a.k.a Tuidang, quit the party) is the only way that brings salvation of oneself and the only hope for one to be saved by Heaven.
Originally printed on the paper bill in circulation in China by Falun Gong's supporters, due to somewhat reduced pressure by the government and the nature of the internet a lot of Falun Gong material has gone online for all to see since 2008, and this verse was widely sent as online spams, email spams. Sure, not everyone is a great fan of the Communist Party and the government, but its funny language, mediocre propaganda techniques and the woo rhetoric has gained a equally notorious reputation among liberal and conservative Chinese.
“”Although there is undoubtedly some truth in the commentaries, they lack balance and nuance, and read like the anti-Communist propaganda written in Taiwan in the 1950s.
Around 2012, some hobbyists of consumer electronics on Internet forums and social media started to write parody versions of the verse, initial version replaced the phrases "Falun Gong" to "Sony", "Communist Party" to companies like "Nintendo", hence the first line, "Sony Great Law is Good! Nintendo will be perished from Earth! Quit Nintendo to save yourself!", and included a picture of parody version of Falun Gong posters, depicted Kaz Hirai, the CEO of Sony, in place of Li Hongzhi as the cult of personality for worshipping.
It meant to be an inside-joke about the cult-like following of major brands of consumer electronics and the frequent holy-war between fanboys on the social media and Internet forums, and people found it hilarious, soon it has became a meme and over 9000 versions has appeared, e.g. "Canon vs. Nikon", "Intel vs. AMD", "Boeing vs. Airbus", etc, and topics later extended to video games, TV series, anime and manga, celebrities, e.g. "Star War Great Law is Good! Quit Star Trek to save yourself! Star Trek will be perished from Earth!"
After the wave of parody has ended, full versions of new verse parody are seldom written, but still, any trend or popular thing is humorously called a "Great Law" ("大法"). Also, "Quit-Save-Perish" (退保灭), or "Keep-Peace-Safety" (保平安), abbreviations of the first line, has became an adjective and adverb for humorously (or sometimes ironically) recommending to stop using something and switch to one alternative.
A collection of "Great Law" copypasta can be viewed here.
- Epoch Times on the Fake News page
- Eastern Lightning
- Unification Church - South Korean right-wing new religious movemnet.
- Happy Science - Japanese right-wing new religious movement.
- See the Wikipedia article on Organ harvesting from Falun Gong practitioners in China.
- You did not read that wrong. Li Hongzhi's Sydney lecture explicitly mentions segregated heavens.
- Just go with it.
- Aside from self-immolation, apparently.
- You know, somebody who might actually be able to change the law
- The Falun Gong Wikipedia article, which completely whitewashes the organization, is currently under discretionary sanctions imposed after a 2007 arbitration.
- Ironically, many of the founding members of the CCP itself were also members of secret societies.
- Dowell, William (May 10, 1999). "Interview with Li Hongzhi". Time Magazine.
- No, they're pretty crazy. That doesn't justify what China has done, but they're straight-up nuts: Or if you really want some fun, read Li Hongzhi's Time magazine interview and enjoy as it slowly goes from "yeah, sounds reasonable" to "wtf, he's talking about aliens invading earth?" Reddit (archived from January 11, 2020).
- Is Falun Gong a cult? by Rick Ross (January, 2009) The Cult Education Institute.
- Why China fears the Falun Gong by James Griffiths (July 14, 2014 · 6:00 AM UTC) PRI.
- Falun Gong and the Future of China by David Ownby (2010) Oxford University Press. ISBN 019973853X. pp. viii, ix, 6-7.
- Falun Gong: The End of Days by Maria Chang (2008) Yale University Press.
- Vuori, Juha A. (2014). Critical Security and Chinese Politics: The Anti-Falungong Campaign. Routledge. ISBN 9781135076931. "note:according to Zong Hairen in 2002. Hairen smuggled intelligence documents out of China which have generally been accepted as authentic by the intelligence community."
- "Foreign Affairs, Defence and Trade References Committee Mr Chen Yonglin's request for political asylum". September 1, 2005. p. 50.
- Benjamin Penny (2012) "The Religion of Falun Gong"
- Li Hongzhi, Zhuan Falun
- Chang 2004, pp 91
- 洪 吟: 李洪志. 68. 世界十惡 Falun Dafa (archived from December 8, 2019).
- Falun Buddha Fa: Fa Teachings in the United States by Li Hongzhi(3rd Translation Edition, March 23, 2014) Falun Dafa (archived from June 19, 2017).
- HONGZHI, LI. "FALUN GONG (english translation 2016)".
- Critics and followers of Falun Gong / Adherents find fulfillment, but detractors call movement a cult by Vanessa Hua (4:00 am PST, December 18, 2005) San Francisco Chronicle.
- Brandy Zadrozny and Ben Collins (August 20, 2019). "Trump, QAnon and an impending judgment day: Behind the Facebook-fueled rise of The Epoch Times". NBC News.
- Pasley, James. Inside Dragon Springs, the high-security compound in upstate New York that's home to a 'cult' tyrannized by China Business Insider, Sep 10, 2019
- "China's Policies Toward Spiritual Movements".
- Misconceptions: "Intolerant"?
- Hu Ping (2007) "The Falun Gong Phenomenon".
- New York Times: Rooting Out Falun Gong; China Makes War on Mysticism
- Lecture in Sydney by Li Hongzhi (1996) Falun Dafa.
- Teaching the Fa at the Western U.S. Fa Conference by Li Hongzhi (February 21 and 22, 1999, Los Angeles) Falun Dafa (archived from May 3, 2015).
- Teaching the Fa at the Fa Conference in Australia by Li Hongzhi (Sydney, May 2–3, 1999) Falun Dafa (archived from May 15, 2015).
- Falun Gong: The face of Chinese opposition, or a Chinese Scientology?, Daily Kos.
- Falun Gong — Harmless exercise fanatics, or weird cult?
- Li Hongzhi. Falun Dafa: Lecture in Sydney
- "从发毒誓谈起为什么要退党". 真像网. Archived at .
- Critics and followers of Falun Gong
- Noah Porter, Falun Gong in the United States.
- Falun Dafa: Prehistoric nuclear reactor in Gabon Republic
- About.com Geology: The Oklo Natural Nuclear Reactor
- Chang 2004, pp 91
- Kavan, Heather. Print Media Coverage of Falun Gong in Australia and New Zealand [online]. In: Horsfield, Peter (Editor). Papers from the Trans-Tasman Research Symposium, 'Emerging Research in Media, Religion and Culture'. Melbourne, Vic.: RMIT Publishing, 2005: 74-85. EISBN: 192116669X. Cited 30 Jun 17.
- Democracy On China
- Kavan 2008
- Epoch Times — archived copies
- Epoch Times website
- Dissident media linked to Falun Gong / Chinese-language print, broadcast outlets in U.S. are making waves by Vanessa Hua (4:00 am, Sunday, December 18, 2005) San Francisco Chronicle.
- Nervous-System Damage From the Sky by Louise McCoy, Epoch Times October 18, 2012.
- UFO Sightings on the Rise in China, With More Predicted by Michelle Yu (October 5, 2010 AT 12:28 AM; Last Updated: October 1, 2015 6:52 pm) Epoch Times.
- Beyond Science Epoch Times.
- 12 Million-Year-Old Vehicle Tracks Found in Stone, Claims Geologist by Tara MacIsaac (October 9, 2016 10:25 AM; Last Updated: October 9, 2016 9:28 pm) Epoch Times.
- Iraqi Transport Minister Announces That Sumerians Launched Spaceships 7,000 Years Ago by April Holloway (October 5, 2016 4:17 PM) Epoch Times.
- Supernormal Abilities Developed Through Meditation: Dr. Dean Radin Discusses by Tara MacIsaac (September 29, 2016 AT 10:16 AM) Epoch Times.
- Mental Clarity During Near-Death Experiences Suggests Mind Exists Apart From Brain: Study by Tara MacIsaac (August 6, 2016 AT 4:55 PM Last Updated: August 7, 2016 9:23 am) Epoch Times.
- Clifton, Eli, This NBC executive became a conspiracy king and a pro-Trump media boss. Quincy Institute for Responsible Statecraft. May 26, 2020
- Rücksicht auf Flüchtlinge: Sankt-Martins-Fest soll in "Lichterfest" umbenannt werden Epoch Times, 31. Oktober 2015 14:01
- Berlin: 13-Jährige 30 Stunden lang entführt und vergewaltigt
- Rothschild und die Asyl-Industrie: Das lukrative Geschäft mit den Flüchtlingen Epoch Times. 15. August 2015
- The Obscure Newspaper Fueling the Far-Right in Europe: The conspiratorial bent of The Epoch Times is forging common cause with European nationalists. by Seth Hettena (September 17, 2019) The New Republic.
- The German Edition of Falun Gong’s ‘Epoch Times’ Aligns with the Far Right Bethany Allen-Ebrahimian, China File. September 23, 2017
- Kopp, Sputnik, Epoch Times & Co: Nachrichten aus einem rechten Paralleluniversum Stefan Winterbauer, Meedia. March 13, 2016
- "The Epoch Times Really, Really Loves The Trump Administration" (in en). BuzzFeed News.
- A letter to our readers regarding Buzzfeed's reporting about The Epoch Times
- Spygate The True Story of Collusion
- President Trump, Build the Wall
- Why We Should Embrace President Trump’s Nationalism by Carol M. Swain (February 28, 2019 Updated: February 28, 2019) The Epoch Times (archived from June 15, 2019).
- Government Welfare: A Cancer Known as Communism
- The End Game of Climate Change Socialism
- Facebook bans ads from The Epoch Times after huge pro-Trump buy: By hiding its multimillion-dollar dark money ad spend, the organization bypassed Facebook's political advertising transparency rules. by Brandy Zadrozny & Ben Collins (Aug. 22, 2019, 2:04 PM PDT / Updated Aug. 26, 2019, 10:22 AM PDT) NBC News.
- Holroyd, Matthew (4 May 2020). "Coronavirus: 'Super-spreaders' of COVID-19 misinformation on Facebook identified". Euronews.
- Manavis, Sarah. "How US conspiracy theorists are targeting local government in the UK".
- Bellemare, Andrea; Ho, Jason; Nicholson, Katie (April 29, 2020). "Some Canadians who received unsolicited copy of Epoch Times upset by claim that China was behind virus". CBC.
- "Scientists Haven’t Found Proof The Coronavirus Escaped From A Lab In Wuhan. Trump Supporters Are Spreading The Rumor Anyway." (in en).
- "Viral video promotes the unsupported hypothesis that SARS-CoV-2 is a bioengineered virus released from a Wuhan research laboratory". 17 April 2020.
- How US conspiracy theorists are targeting local government in the UK by Sarah Manavis (21 April 2020) New Statesman.
- Shen Yun about itself
- Falun Dafa affliation
- E. Assata Wright of The Hudson Reporter on Shen Yun
- Judith Mitchell of The Guardian on Shen Yun
- Whittemore, Walter. "Letter: Propaganda posing as entertainment".
- Jia, Tolentino (2019-03-19). "Stepping Into the Uncanny, Unsettling World of Shen Yun". Retrieved 20 March 2019.
- Behind the blitz: Falun Gong practitioners spend millions on Shen Yun ads. How do they do it? by Matthias Gafni (Jan. 11, 2020) San Francisco Chronicle. See the 9th graphic for the budget figures.
- "Trump, QAnon and an impending judgment day: Behind the Facebook-fueled rise of The Epoch Times" (in en).
- Rothschild, Nike (August 27, 2019). "This massive YouTube channel is normalizing QAnon" (in en).
- David Ownby (2008). Falun Gong and the Future of China.
- One Nation's Shan Ju Lin defends Pauline Hanson, says she fears Chinese Government will 'take over' by Kristian Silva (Updated 21 Dec 2016, 12:07am) ABC News (Australia).
- One Nation dumps anti-gay 'ratbag' candidate Shan Ju Lin by Gail Burke & Kym Agius (Updated 7 Jan 2017, 9:16pm) ABC News (Australia).
- One example
- "公安部揭开"维权"黑幕 北京锋锐律所多名律师被拘". Beijing Evening News. "炒作. lawfirm shut down for fabricating human rights cases. They represented falun gong cases and publicly accused the government of persecuting them for doing so."
- "中国学术期刊电子杂志社 (China state dictionary)". "literal character meaning is, "cooked up." combined character meaning is to make up for the purpose of self-promotion or profit."
- Vivienne Shue, "Legitimacy Crisis in China?".
- The Project For A New American Humanitarianism: Olympian Ambitions from Darfur to Tibet and Beijing by Michael Barker (August 25, 2008) Swans.
- Lubman, Sarah ["A Chinese Battle on U.S. Soil" in San Jose Mercury News (23 December 2001)] retrieved 1 Jul 2017
- Washinton Post:http://www.culteducation.com/group/1254-falun-gong/6727-for-whom-the-gong-tolls.html
- Chang 2004, pp 145
- Chang 2004, pp 59
- "The 610 Office: Policing the Chinese Spirit" by Sarah Cook & Leeshai Lemish (September 16, 2011 04:28 PM) The Jamestown Foundation: China Brief 11(17).
- China's Falun Gong crackdown: 'The persecution is almost underground': The daughter of two held followers and a former detainee tell of continuing abuse 10 years after China launched its crackdown by Peter Beaumont (18 Jul 2009 08.57 EDT) The Guadian.
- Does China Harvest Organs From Living Prisoners? A new PBS documentary examines claims that China collects organs from live and dead prisoners to traffic on its massive black market. by Nina Strochlic (Updated Apr. 14, 2017 9:32AM ET; Published Sep. 29, 2015 5:05PM ET) Daily Beast.
- Infringement of public interests by Falun Gong, Chapter 2 Harassment Goes Everywhere (page 11)
- Report Into Allegations Of Organ Harvesting Of Falun Gong Practitioners In China by David Matas and David Kilgour (6 July 2006).
- Ethan Gutmann, "China’s Gruesome Organ Harvest," The Weekly Standard, Nov 24 2008
- Ebook: Falun Dafa Practitioners’ Cultivation Stories. Zhengjian/PureInsight editorial team. May 1, 2018. p. 132, 145. ""The doctor said, “Your womb has been severed. What method did you use for treatment? How come a new womb has grown?” Dongmei said, “I just practice Falun Gong.”""
- MARKET WIRE via COMTEX, China's Organ Harvesting Questioned Again by UN Special Rapporteurs: FalunHR Reports, 8 May 2008, accessed 16/6/08
- China and the Falun Gong
- Congressional-Executive commission on China, Annual Report 2008.
- Johnson, Ian, Wild Grass: three portraits of change in modern china, Vintage (8 March 2005)
- (23 March 2000) The crackdown on Falun Gong and other so-called heretical organizations, Amnesty International
- John Pomfret and Philip Pan. "Torture is Breaking Falun Gong." The Washington Post, 5 Aug 2001.
- United Nations (4 February 2004) Press Release HR/CN/1073, retrieved 12 September 2006
- Mickey Spiegel, "Dangerous Meditation: China's Campaign Against Falungong", Human Rights Watch, 2002, accessed Sept 28, 2007
- Congressional Executive Commission on China, Annual Report 2008
- U.S. Department of State, 2009 Country Report on Human Rights: China (includes Hong Kong and Macao)
- Andrew Jacobs. 'China Still Presses Crusade Against Falun Gong', New York Times, 27 April 2009.
- Dissecting An Unfair and Unbalanced Report.
- 2014 ELECTIONS: Ko denies organ buying allegations. Taipei Times, Oct 29, 2014
- Bloody Harvest / The Slaughter: An Update by David Kilgour, Ethan Gutmann & David Matas (June 22, 2016; Revised April 30, 2017).
- About Us International Coalition to End Transplant Abuse in China (archived from May 12, 2020).
- Shen Yun ‘The best I’ve ever seen,’ Says Former MP and Acclaimed Rights Defender (December 21, 2011 Updated: October 1, 2015) Epoch Times (archived from April 20, 2020).
- ‘It’s uplifting, it’s fabulous for the senses,’ Says Former Cabinet Minister (December 29, 2012 Updated: October 1, 2015) Epoch Times (archived from April 20, 2020).
- Former Secretary of State David Kilgour Praises Shen Yun for Presenting Traditional Chinese Culture (December 30, 2017) Epoch Times (archived from April 23, 2020).
- Reports on China ‘organ harvesting’ derive from front groups of far-right cult Falun Gong: A wave of corporate media reports on Chinese organ harvesting rely without acknowledgement on front groups connected to the far-right Falun Gong cult, whose followers believe “Trump was sent by heaven to destroy the Communist Party.” by Ryan McCarthy (September 30, 2019) The Grayzone.
- Google search: "Susie Hughes" "epoch times" (archived from 29 Sep 2019 22:03:40 UTC).
- Margo Macvicar Epoch Times (archived from May 11, 2020).
- International Art at Bristol’s Island Gallery, UK by Emiko Dubiel and Roman Dubiel (January 13, 2013 Updated: October 1, 2015) Epoch Times (archived from April 23, 2020).
- Management International Coalition End Transplant Abuse in China (archived from October 18, 2018).
- Management International Coalition End Transplant Abuse in China (archived from May 12, 2020).
- Angry Claims and Furious Denials Over Organ Transplants in China. The New York Times, Aug. 24, 2016
- Spotlight: Experts slam rumors of organ harvesting in China New China, Aug. 19, 2016
- China used to harvest organs from prisoners. Under pressure, that practice is finally ending. by Simon Denyer (September 15, 2017 at 5:12 PM) The Washington Post.
- TTS Interactions with China The Transplantation Society, July 31, 2016
- One doctor’s war against global organ trafficking PBS Newshour, May 29, 2017]
- Conclusion of the China Tribunal's Judgement
- "WHAT IS ORGAN HARVESTING?". Falun Dafa Association of Washington, D.C.. 2019.
- Juan, Shan (May 16, 2016). "More organ transplant hospitals on the way". ""169 organ transplant centers, performing about 10,000 surgeries annually.""
- 江, 杨 (March 19, 2012). "器官移植的灰色地带". Chinese Academy of Science (law blog)/文汇新民联合报业集团所有. ""对人体器官移植稍有了解的人就会知道这则消息并不靠谱""
- 龙, 张 (February 29, 2012). "张龙：“利益”催生活体器官买卖的“地下黑市”".
- "黑中介“换肾一条龙” 起底猖獗的“人体器官黑市”". september 7, 2018.
- For example, 
- Tuidang § Nine Commentaries on the Communist Party
- Nine Commentaries on the Communist Party English online version
- (Chinese) Official 'Tuidang' website with these claims
- (Chinese) News article: what to do when you've received paper bills with anti-Party propaganda, with a picture of these bills
- David Ownby, Falun Gong and the Future of China, (Oxford University Press 2008), p 221.
- (Chinese) A parody news reporting this phenomenon